Erosive Osteoarthritis

Posted by anniebrook @anniebrook, Feb 12, 2021

I have been trying to get answers for many years to find out why my OA in my hands is so painful and debilitating. It doesn't look as bad to the eye as many other people I have met that also have OA but have huge joint nodes but say it's not too painful. I had the traditional basal thumb surgery on left and right hands,left went well 10yrs ago but right which I had one yr later has never been pain free.. About 6 mths ago the pain in the back of my right wrist became so much worse at the same time a large lump appeared.I thought this was probably a Ganglion then a few weeks later a softer round lump appeared on the dip joint on the inside of my right little finger which as made the joint very swollen. Eventually got Xrays of both hands which have now been diagnosed as Erosive Osteoarthritis which I have never heard of. Prognosis doesn't look good with this type of OA. Has anyone else been diagnosed with this and do I ask to be referred to a Rheumatologist ? How do I deal with this ? Is there any meds I can take for pain and to slow down the progression ? Thank you

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Bones, Joints & Muscles Support Group.

I have erosive arthritis in both hands. They are very stiff and the joints have nodules and I cannot fully close my hands. It is not rheumatoid arthritis. If you have access to your xray films you will notice that the joints have “wings”. Years ago I was told the FDA was fast tracking a drug for this particular problem. Whenever I paint or do remodeling or do heaving cleaning the pain increases. I take pain medication when needed. I can no longer wear rings.

REPLY
Profile picture for genie15 @genie15

@loriesco
Wow, you gave me so much new and helpful information! Thanks so much. I also have multiple arthritis sites and no overall diagnosis. I had a knee joint replaced but the inflammation keeps raging and the whole "recovery" has been a miserable mess. I also have had difficulty handling sugar all my life. You have given me a new path of inquiry. So glad you posted.

Jump to this post

@genie15 glad I could offer some suggestions! I hope they provide some relief!

REPLY
Profile picture for heyjoe415 @heyjoe415

Hi Elle,

Its was definitely the chronic use of the Rx NSAID diclofenac that caused my creatinine number to rise above normal. Any NSAID used regularly can possibly cause this. It was a surprise to me. And a high creatinine number means the kidney is not working at 100%.

So in just a few weeks, and by cutting my diclofenac use by about 70%, my creatinine number went from 1.5 to 1. The top range is 1.3, so I was above that line.

As for no NSAIDs before surgery - My shoulder was really hurting, so yeah I missed having it. I was able to take Tylenol and use a lot of gel pads from the freezer! The surgeons insist on stopping those meds because they thin the blood, and they don't want that during surgery.

And when my blood was taken just before surgery, my creatinine number dropped to .9 - so the diclofenac NSAID was definitely affecting my kidneys. The lesson is to not use NSAIDs on a regular or daily basis. I didn't even know that.

I hope that helps you Elle. I'm two months now post-op for my shoulder replacement and I'm off any painkillers, even Tylenol. I've had my knees and a hip replaced before, and the subsequent pain relief is glorious.

Don't get me wrong, joint replacement is a significant and traumatic surgery, and the first few days post-op are the hardest. But the satisfaction rate among patients is generally in the 95% range, so these surgeries have really been refined and are incredibly safe, IMO. The rehab work done by the patient is very important.

Any other questions Elle? Thanks so much for reaching out.

Joe

Jump to this post

@heyjoe415
Was this oral diclofenac or topical diclofenac which gave you the reaction?

REPLY
Profile picture for mcchesney @kathleen1314

@heyjoe415
Was this oral diclofenac or topical diclofenac which gave you the reaction?

Jump to this post

Hi Kathleen,

It was oral diclofenac that raised my creatinine numbers. I have used the topical diclofenac gel, which is available OTC. Some of the drug will still get into your bloodstream through the skin, but I'm pretty sure it's not as impactful on the kidneys as the oral drug, which does require an Rx.

Talk with your Dr about this. Celebrex is another NSAID only available via Rx. It's easier on the stomach but also affects the kidneys. I would also get your Dr's opinion on long-term use of any NSAID.

Hope that helps.

Joe

REPLY
Profile picture for heyjoe415 @heyjoe415

Hi Kathleen,

It was oral diclofenac that raised my creatinine numbers. I have used the topical diclofenac gel, which is available OTC. Some of the drug will still get into your bloodstream through the skin, but I'm pretty sure it's not as impactful on the kidneys as the oral drug, which does require an Rx.

Talk with your Dr about this. Celebrex is another NSAID only available via Rx. It's easier on the stomach but also affects the kidneys. I would also get your Dr's opinion on long-term use of any NSAID.

Hope that helps.

Joe

Jump to this post

@heyjoe415
Thanks for the reply. This lines up with the research of first pass liver problems for many if not all oral products.
This is one reason that I try to take anything topically when it is available.

REPLY
Profile picture for mcchesney @kathleen1314

@heyjoe415
Thanks for the reply. This lines up with the research of first pass liver problems for many if not all oral products.
This is one reason that I try to take anything topically when it is available.

Jump to this post

Thanks Kathleen.

Coincidentally, there is another thread on Connect dealing with diclofenac gel (Voltaren). Even gels and creams can have an impact, so please use with care.

Joe

REPLY
Profile picture for heyjoe415 @heyjoe415

Thanks Kathleen.

Coincidentally, there is another thread on Connect dealing with diclofenac gel (Voltaren). Even gels and creams can have an impact, so please use with care.

Joe

Jump to this post

@heyjoe415
Could you hotlink me to the Connect dealing with diclofenac gel.
I do see this on some research:
"Topical forms of diclofenac (solutions, gels, creams, patches) have been associated with only a low rate of serum enzyme elevations (generally less than 1%) that may be no greater than occurs with placebo or vehicle application. However, product labels for topical diclofenac mention the possibility of liver injury and several cases of clinically apparent liver injury attributed to topical diclofenac have been reported in the literature although the diagnosis in these cases have often been questionable. Thus, if clinically apparent liver injury due to topical forms of diclofenac occurs, it must be exceedingly rare."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK547953/.
Ai overview:
Topical diclofenac generally causes low rates (under 1%) of liver enzyme elevations, similar to placebo, but clinically apparent liver injury from the gel is documented.
There are reported cases of acute liver injury linked to topical diclofenac, often resolving after stopping the gel, suggesting a possible connection.
The resoulution after stopping is important since most topical treatment is meant to be short term and not continued for any long period of time.

REPLY
Profile picture for mcchesney @kathleen1314

@heyjoe415
Could you hotlink me to the Connect dealing with diclofenac gel.
I do see this on some research:
"Topical forms of diclofenac (solutions, gels, creams, patches) have been associated with only a low rate of serum enzyme elevations (generally less than 1%) that may be no greater than occurs with placebo or vehicle application. However, product labels for topical diclofenac mention the possibility of liver injury and several cases of clinically apparent liver injury attributed to topical diclofenac have been reported in the literature although the diagnosis in these cases have often been questionable. Thus, if clinically apparent liver injury due to topical forms of diclofenac occurs, it must be exceedingly rare."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK547953/.
Ai overview:
Topical diclofenac generally causes low rates (under 1%) of liver enzyme elevations, similar to placebo, but clinically apparent liver injury from the gel is documented.
There are reported cases of acute liver injury linked to topical diclofenac, often resolving after stopping the gel, suggesting a possible connection.
The resoulution after stopping is important since most topical treatment is meant to be short term and not continued for any long period of time.

Jump to this post

@kathleen1314 I've used prescription-strength topical for 20 years. No elevation in anything. I'm sure it can't mess with your liver. Can't imagine how it could topically. They probably didn't control the study well enough. If you read the link you provided you see there is no known issue that isn't more than NOT taking it. I saw nothing stating it was for short-term use topically.

REPLY

Thank you for posting on erosive osteoarthritis. I was diagnosed with EOA two years ago, although I think my previous rheumatologist had missed it for a few years. I’ve also had rheumatoid arthritis now for 30 years. I have found that erosive osteoarthritis is more aggressive, painful, and disabling then my rheumatoid arthritis. The difference is that, while there are now medication’s to treat RA, there are none for erosive osteoarthritis. The damage my hands have incurred and continue to incur is stunning.

I can tell you a couple of things that are helping me right now. I wear silver rings, similar to the plastic eight rings, but tailored to my size, joints: they are particularly affected. I buy these on Etsy, where a silversmith from Arizona could not be more gracious and helpful.. last year I ended up having two finger fusions when joints were simply too painful and swollen to allow me to function with my right hand. Both fusions have been helpful and, although it may seem extreme, I am happy that I’ve done them. Finally, this summer. I discovered low-dose naltrexone. You’ll need to talk to your provider about this since this is an off label use. I have been taking LDN now for six months and my use of NSAIDs is much reduced as is swelling in my DIP and PIP joints.

I’m sending you love and support. There are not so many of us out there and even our doctors sometimes are not aware of EOA. I know how frustrating this can feel. I’m glad you posted this discussion.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.