Comparison of Spinal Cord Stimulators from Boston Sci., Nevro
I've lived with severe chronic pain in my legs and lumbar spine for the past ten years. Was on opiates for 8 years until I attended & graduated from Mayo's 3-week Pain Rehab Program in 2018. That program helped immensely and I got off 5 meds I used to take, including morphine and hydrocodone. Unfortunately, in the last year my spine health has worsened. I now have a toxic mix of scar tissue (from a dural tear during a microdiscectomy), stenosis at multiple levels, bulging discs and scoliosis. I am now scheduled to do a trial of Boston Scientific's "Wave Writer" SCS on August 10, 2020. Unfortunately my doctor did not guide me in the selection of this manufacturer/model. I did my own research. I considered doing trials of Nevro's HF-10 and Boston Scientific's Wave Writer. Finally decided on the Wave Writer.
I'm posting here to ask for people's knowledge of and/or experience with these two SCS's. Please reply if you can share any information. Thanks!
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Spine Health Support Group.
Connect

I will look into it. Thank you.
Calmare Scrambler Therapy seems to be a very effective option for neuropathic pain. Here's an article about it by the provider in New Jersey, Dr. Michael Cooney: https://www.paintreatmentdirectory.com/posts/calmare-therapy-for-neuropathic-pain-relief
I have heard of Dr. Michael Cooney. Unfortunatley, he is an hour and fifteen minutes from me. You have to go every week day for 2 weeks. Might be to much driving for me. I can't seem to find any other practitioner closer to where I live. Thank you
Look, my pain specialist is just under an hour from us. But, he was the only doc who worked with the morpine pain pump. Sometimes, you just have to bite the bullet and do what's necessary. An hour and a half , 2 days a week, could turn out to be one of the best investments of your time that you've ever made.
Thank you. But it's 1hr. 15 minutes each way for 10 days in North Jersey traffic, not two days. Did the pain pump work for you?
Glen, I had my stimulator installed in November of 2021. The issue I have been having is I get overstimulated. The machine does take my neuropathy pain down but no complete relief. With the over stimulation I can be on a program and get relief but I am not able to stay on that program without getting overstimulated. Nevro has been pretty good about working with me and I just go in and get adjusted. It works for awhile but then need to get adjusted again. I was hoping for so much more since the trial went fairly well. Hopefully your Nevro tech is patient and persistent in helping you. I have been fortunate that way.
Unfortunately there are very few Calmare therapists. You would know on the first visit whether it will work for you because experiencing some pain relief during the treatment is the key indicator. Can you find someone to drive you? Or stay somewhere nearby? Dr. Cooney has people who come from other countries who consider the trip worth it to get the relief it can provide.
I tried it a few years ago and it did not work.
Did you try this?
"Often, people with neuropathy are forced to seek out invasive procedures – surgery, implanted devices (SCS) or resort to the use of powerful narcotics, such as Ketamine, where success has been uneven, but side effects are often debilitating. In 2010, as a pain management provider, I wasn’t comfortable recommending these types of ‘next level’ neuropathic pain treatment for medication-and treatment-resistant patients. I knew there had to be a better option and began looking in Europe for new pain therapies which were drug-free.
Through a contact in Italy, I discovered scrambler therapy, which checked all the boxes—no side effects, painless to undergo, highly effective for neuropathic pain treatment and, most importantly, drug-free.
Our goal was simply to help lessen our local patients’ chronic pain.
But after sharing a few positive scrambler therapy patient outcomes on our website, we quickly began attracting patients from coast-to-coast and around the globe, including Australia, the UK, South Africa and South America for neuropathic pain treatment.
Today, we treat children, adults and seniors battling fibromyalgia, neuropathy after chemotherapy treatment, complex regional pain syndrome and pain that develops after surgery or from diabetes. We have also treated many people who developed chronic nerve pain after a shingles diagnosis (PHN).
How Scrambler Therapy Works
When someone is injured, the brain sets up a process to heal the injury. For example, cells carry away dead tissue or blood flow is increased to the area. Eventually, the brain realizes the injury has healed, and it cuts off the pain message.
For some people, the brain never sends the all-important message, “there’s no more injury here, we’re healed, so you can stop sending that pain signal.”
That’s where the ‘scrambler’ therapy device comes in. Using small electrodes judiciously placed in the region of the injury (but not directly on the pain site), the freestanding technology sends a mild “no pain” message to the brain through the electrodes.
This message overrides the brain’s pain message signal and corrects it, over a series of one treatment daily for an average of 10 days, to a ‘there’s no pain here” message.
In many cases, pain is lessened for the patient as soon as the first scrambler therapy treatment.
Regardless of how long they've had the condition, many patients are completely pain-free at the end of the 10 days of treatment. This is unmatched by any other neuropathic pain treatment.
Calmare Therapy is Safe and Effective
There have been clinical trials performed at several high-profile research facilities here in the United States, including at the Mayo Clinic and at MD Anderson Cancer Center. Positive results have been found with CRPS, Chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy, low back pain, post-herpetic neuralgia. There have also been many clinical reports of successful treatment of fibromyalgia.
We keep an updated list of these studies on our Clinical Trials web page, so people with specific neuropathic pain conditions can use them as a reference.
When a skilled clinician places the leads in the optimal positions on each trial participant’s body, in accordance with their original injury site, the results are excellent.
For more detailed information, you can watch this very informative hour-long Grand Rounds review (by doctors for doctors) about scrambler therapy, “Calmare Therapy – An Innovative Pain Treatment: What Is It?” presented by the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, a partnership between Harvard Medical School and Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston.
The Calmare MC-5A device has been tested in multi-year clinical trials at some of the most prestigious research institutions, including the Massey Cancer Institute at Virginia Commonwealth University, Mayo Clinic and the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO). In addition, it has received clearance from the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)."
Quoted from
- Calmare Therapy for Neuropathic Pain Relief https://www.paintreatmentdirectory.com/posts/calmare-therapy-for-neuropathic-pain-relief
Hi @gba, in your search for solutions for neuropathic pain, it looks like you found the above information about Calmare Therapy on this website.
– Calmare Therapy for Neuropathic Pain Relief by: Dr. Michael J. Cooney https://www.paintreatmentdirectory.com/posts/calmare-therapy-for-neuropathic-pain-relief
You might also be interested in this related discussion:
- Has anyone tried Scrambler Therapy for neuropathy or for pain? https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/calmare-scrambler-therapy-anyone/
And this Mayo patient story
- Breaking Away From Pain With the Help of ‘The Scrambler’ https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/breaking-away-from-the-pain-with-the-help-of-the-scrambler/
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
4 Reactions