Comparison of Spinal Cord Stimulators from Boston Sci., Nevro

Posted by elsa @elsa, Jul 26, 2020

I've lived with severe chronic pain in my legs and lumbar spine for the past ten years. Was on opiates for 8 years until I attended & graduated from Mayo's 3-week Pain Rehab Program in 2018. That program helped immensely and I got off 5 meds I used to take, including morphine and hydrocodone. Unfortunately, in the last year my spine health has worsened. I now have a toxic mix of scar tissue (from a dural tear during a microdiscectomy), stenosis at multiple levels, bulging discs and scoliosis. I am now scheduled to do a trial of Boston Scientific's "Wave Writer" SCS on August 10, 2020. Unfortunately my doctor did not guide me in the selection of this manufacturer/model. I did my own research. I considered doing trials of Nevro's HF-10 and Boston Scientific's Wave Writer. Finally decided on the Wave Writer.
I'm posting here to ask for people's knowledge of and/or experience with these two SCS's. Please reply if you can share any information. Thanks!

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Spine Health Support Group.

Profile picture for chichibug @chichibug

Nevro has been ordered for me, I have tried Boston and another that did little. How were you told to get help when it shocked you? This is beyond medically correct! I will talk to my doctor about what support I will have before I have the trial.
Thank you so much for this info.

Jump to this post

Please keep in mind NEVRO has had an F rating & is NOT accredited by the BBB. From VERY painful experience...it is almost impossible to reach your "coach" & they are so careless it almost seems spiteful. (I'm sure this is not everyone's experience, but it has been mine & the BBB seems to agree)

REPLY
Profile picture for mikkimoe @mikkimoe

Just read of big law Suite with the spinal cord stimulators. I had one that almost shocked me to death. Wanted to join the suit but can't find my documentation.

Jump to this post

I was just reading your issues with being shocked. I had the implant installed September 2024. I’m still trying to find the program that gives me the best relief. About a month ago I started getting random shocks nothing crazy but all over my body. Occasionally I’ll get a shock that’s a bit much and I’ll let out a yell. Could you explain how yours started and how long it was before it became unbearable? Thanks!

REPLY
Profile picture for denman55 @denman55

My Pain Management Physician gave me a brochure on the NEVRO HFX SCS and I wanted to know if anyone has used this model and whether or not you have had success with it. Thanks

Jump to this post

Reading the comments from HFX users stating that they get occasional shocks...I had a Medtronics SCS implanted back in 2018. It worked fairly well in reducing my pain for about two and a half years. I remember the first time I laid down on my back on a hard surface. Ouch!! It was truly a shocking experience. The paddle would get pushed against the spinal cord causing the shock. I learned to turn the unit off whenever I was going to do any work while lying on my back.
From what I read in 2021, the HFX was supposed to eliminate those shocking feelings. I guess such may not be the case. Users may also have to turn the unit off at times as I learned to do.

REPLY
Profile picture for heisenberg34 @heisenberg34

Reading the comments from HFX users stating that they get occasional shocks...I had a Medtronics SCS implanted back in 2018. It worked fairly well in reducing my pain for about two and a half years. I remember the first time I laid down on my back on a hard surface. Ouch!! It was truly a shocking experience. The paddle would get pushed against the spinal cord causing the shock. I learned to turn the unit off whenever I was going to do any work while lying on my back.
From what I read in 2021, the HFX was supposed to eliminate those shocking feelings. I guess such may not be the case. Users may also have to turn the unit off at times as I learned to do.

Jump to this post

December 31,2024 I had my Nevro HFX iQ spinal cord stimulator implanted. I chose to use the app with my iphone vs hand control. It's been a very interesting experience. Now beginning my 8th month post op.
It took about 4 months to heal to a point where the area where my modulator is no longer sensitive when touched, and never "shocked" me. I do still use my "eggcrate" foam back square when sitting on the wooden pew at church.
I never experienced what you did. I'm currently charging my implant with the charger pad while writing to you. I do my online assessments daily which is monitored by the Nevro corp and forwarded to my pain MD. If I need my stimulation increased (you don't feel it) the app will trigger you to change to the next level.
I see the Nevro tech at my MDs office every three months.
I couldn't be happier with the results. But you have to actively participate.
Implant change in ten years, minor op procedure. Mariette

REPLY
Profile picture for denman55 @denman55

My Pain Management Physician gave me a brochure on the NEVRO HFX SCS and I wanted to know if anyone has used this model and whether or not you have had success with it. Thanks

Jump to this post

Thanks for your response. The Medtronic’s SCS apparently uses different frequencies than HFX. I was very happy with it for the most part. Never discovered why it stopped working.

REPLY
Profile picture for heisenberg34 @heisenberg34

Thanks for your response. The Medtronic’s SCS apparently uses different frequencies than HFX. I was very happy with it for the most part. Never discovered why it stopped working.

Jump to this post

With the Nevro scs you never feel the stimulation, that's a great feature with their system.
Patient support is great. If there is a malfunction they will address it and take care of it.
The company and physician who inserted it, would never leave you in the dark about any malfunction.
You can seek a pain physician in your area who uses the Nevro system and they will switch out your current one and attach theirs.

REPLY
Profile picture for Mariette R. @marietter

With the Nevro scs you never feel the stimulation, that's a great feature with their system.
Patient support is great. If there is a malfunction they will address it and take care of it.
The company and physician who inserted it, would never leave you in the dark about any malfunction.
You can seek a pain physician in your area who uses the Nevro system and they will switch out your current one and attach theirs.

Jump to this post

When my Medtronic’s unit seemingly died, I swapped out the Medtronic’s battery for the NEVRO battery. Did not provide relief either. Upon testing, it was suggested that the paddle lead had developed issues, including sever burned out electrodes. So, no relief. The old paddle along with everything else was removed in May of 2023. Tried new SCS but too much scar tissue to get a new lead in place. So now it’s all on this pain pump that I’ve been trying to get adjusted for over two years.

REPLY
Profile picture for heisenberg34 @heisenberg34

When my Medtronic’s unit seemingly died, I swapped out the Medtronic’s battery for the NEVRO battery. Did not provide relief either. Upon testing, it was suggested that the paddle lead had developed issues, including sever burned out electrodes. So, no relief. The old paddle along with everything else was removed in May of 2023. Tried new SCS but too much scar tissue to get a new lead in place. So now it’s all on this pain pump that I’ve been trying to get adjusted for over two years.

Jump to this post

Best wishes and hoping this will give you the pain relief you need.

REPLY
Profile picture for Mariette R. @marietter

Best wishes and hoping this will give you the pain relief you need.

Jump to this post

👍

REPLY
Profile picture for mikkimoe @mikkimoe

Just read of big law Suite with the spinal cord stimulators. I had one that almost shocked me to death. Wanted to join the suit but can't find my documentation.

Jump to this post

Spare me.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.