Cardiologist disregarded my CAC score of 595

Posted by woolam50 @woolam50, Oct 7, 2025

I'm 53, I am about 30 lbs overweight, I've lost 30 lbs this year. I eat extremely healthy due to the fact that as soon as I hit puberty, the weight was just a battle to keep off. My cholesterol has always been in the normal, but the last few years my tri and LDL have went up. After losing a friend to unexpected heart attack, I decided to get all the preventive testing I could. My primary recommended the CAC to help put me at ease, I had some chest tightness with stress. Also during this visit, labs came back normal cholesterol but 126 LDL up from 90ish. So when I got a 595 CAC score I nearly lost it!! ok, since then I've done some research and found it's just part of a puzzle, but apparently it is an indicator that I have plaque build up- even with healthy diet. As I started some research, I knew my uncle died of unexpected heart attack at 51 (was healthy), my grandma smoked heavy, but had a stroke at 59, my other uncle stroke and blockage 62 - drinker and previous smoker, my super healthy uncle (my dad was 1 of 6 boys) had a heart attack at 66 and they said it was hereditary - bc no other real indicators. So I get and stress test, it's abnormal. My cardiologist (just assigned) says abnormal just means between normal heart beat and heart attack - grey area. The CAC score is not an indicator and shouldn't be used, "he's seen much higher numbers" - if my parents didn't have early heart attack, my uncles don't matter, when I said what about 126 LDL, he says "everyone has cholesterol in their blood" he then went on to let me know, I wasn't just gonna get a stent, he literally said this like 5-6 times, and I never mentioned it. Is this Dr as crazy as I feel. btw, I stated due to the many factors, a CT scan was called for - he ordered, and due to LDL and high CAC a statin would be called for - he prescribed. He seemed mad about the whole thing. YES I'm definitely seeing a new Cardiologist once CT scan is done. Why did this Dr. act to defensive about CAC info?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Heart & Blood Health Support Group.

Profile picture for kobe2026 @kobe2026

in medical studies they found statins yield a 1% increase of preventing heart attacks verus the placebo group. Side effects of statins are intense, best to do with.
New study suggests benefit-to-harm balance of statins for healthy adults “generally favourable”
https://bmjgroup.com/new-study-suggests-benefit-to-harm-balance-of-statins-for-healthy-adults-generally-favourable/
Millions fewer people may need statins, a new study suggests. But guidelines have yet to agree
https://www.statnews.com/2024/06/10/cardiovascular-disease-statins-aha-guidelines/
Have the benefits of statins been overstated?
https://www1.racgp.org.au/newsgp/clinical/have-the-benefits-of-statins-been-overstated
@seniormed

Jump to this post

should be best too do without...edited@kobe2026

REPLY
Profile picture for kallettla @kallettla

Sorry about the score. I have a zero calcium score, but my carotids are blocking and my aorta has calcification. I recently read that a 0 calcium score means that perhaps I have plaques, but they can't be seen because they aren't calcified. They are the kind that rupture. Once they are calcified they are more stable. You may want to get your ApoB and LP (a) checked. I have high LP (a) that's why I am blocking. Look up the lipidologist Tom Dayspring. He is on YouTube. He has a great interview with Dr Carvalho.

Best wishes.
Karen

Jump to this post

@kallettla 0 is great. Wow! You can’t do better than that. Congrats.

REPLY
Profile picture for cher51 @cher51

@kallettla 0 is great. Wow! You can’t do better than that. Congrats.

Jump to this post

@cher51 except that it means nothing. I likely have the more dangerous unstable soft plaque like I have in my carotids.

REPLY
Profile picture for kallettla @kallettla

@cher51 except that it means nothing. I likely have the more dangerous unstable soft plaque like I have in my carotids.

Jump to this post

@kallettla That is what I want to find out. My problem is the LAD 486. Soft can cause blood clots. Yikes!

REPLY

Yes it does seem like you need a new cardiologist. A CT with contrast will show exactly how much blockage you have and where. Since you are symptomatic and had an abnormal stress test, I would expect it to be warranted. I would do some searching for a new cardiologist, and you can also lean some on your primary care doc in the meantime to assist. Good luck!

For what it's worth, I just had one, and it really wasn't much of an issue. It's a very fast test. The dye makes you feel a little funny, but it was a breeze through it.

REPLY
Profile picture for pizi @pizi

I'm 70 years old, had an angiogram yesterday because of the CAC score I received earlier....2659. I don't now, and never have exhibited symptoms, so I didn't freak out completely, but my doctor nearly did. The only reason I had the CAC was, I kept hearing my friends talking about it, and their scores. I casually brought it up to my doctor up at my yearly checkup. He agreed it would be kinda nice to see where I'm at.
So....the angiogram revealed I have minimal narrowing of the arteries, one of the smaller ones had a 70% blockage, two other small ones were at 50 and 30%, but blood flow is strong. I've always been VERY active and I do eat right. My dad had a very similar condition, and he lived to be 92. He did have a triple bypass at age 74, however he was not active at all! I will improve my diet, and get on an organized exercise program and I expect to be just fine!

Jump to this post

@pizi I am so glad that you posted this because my situation at age 57 is similar to yours with a cac score of 1146. Just like you I was active throughout my life and while I did it necessarily watch everything I ate for the most part I was reasonable. My angiogram also showed no blockages more than 30% but it appears my right coronary artery was dilated or I guess the exact word they use is ectasia . I continue exercising but just lowered the intensity but increase the frequency and certainly watch my saturated fat intake much closer and cut out most simple carbs. Just like in your case my father had bypass when he was 74 - 75 and even though he was not very active and did not necessarily watch his diet and certainly enjoyed some alcohol he had a long life until he passed about a year ago at almost 89.

REPLY
Profile picture for ssmfltr @ssmfltr

@pizi I am so glad that you posted this because my situation at age 57 is similar to yours with a cac score of 1146. Just like you I was active throughout my life and while I did it necessarily watch everything I ate for the most part I was reasonable. My angiogram also showed no blockages more than 30% but it appears my right coronary artery was dilated or I guess the exact word they use is ectasia . I continue exercising but just lowered the intensity but increase the frequency and certainly watch my saturated fat intake much closer and cut out most simple carbs. Just like in your case my father had bypass when he was 74 - 75 and even though he was not very active and did not necessarily watch his diet and certainly enjoyed some alcohol he had a long life until he passed about a year ago at almost 89.

Jump to this post

@ssmfltr that sounds genetic. I was tested and turns out I had an elevated LP(@) same as my father. It doesn't matter how much excersise i do I can't prevent it from happening

REPLY

I am 59 have had genetically high cholesterol but with a good ratio since my 30s (and the good ratio has improved over the years. I had a postpartum stroke at 42 with no residual effects and no history or explanation other than the stress of pregnancy on my body. I've never been overweight except maybe 5 pounds or so due to a bad birth control med in my 20s whch I stopped -and it took me 5 months to lose the baby weight. I did the CAC scan 3 years ago and got a zero score.
I too would have had some concern with a score in the hundreds and it never hurts to get a second opinion.
Congratulations on your weight loss! Most of my normal weight is genetic too - mom and sister have always been thin or underweight. Part of it is me - I do well with portion control and reasonable choices and I've been exercising daily since 1982 except less so just during pregnancy.
I'd also look into the link between the extra weight and any heart issues but I'm not a medical provider. Again congrats on the weight loss -that's awesome!!

REPLY

Unfortunately doctors (most ) are angry and tired of over work and under pay too many people, not enough doctors. We have to be our own advocates now . doctor's will not take the time to know you or even take an interest. Most don't even remember you on your second visit. we have to know what we need done as they're not going to tell you anything anymore. They simply don't care . healthcare is not what we used to have years ago. also people don't work anymore, there is a shortage of health care providers. In Oregon doctors offices often have signs posted, help wanted , no experience, no schooling needed. Medical Assistants no longer need schooling either (in Oregon) probably
everywhere by now.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.