am I exercising too much with a 4.3 ascending aortic aneurysm?

Posted by kmailloux @kmailloux, Mar 15, 2023

I am a 60 year old female, who has been very active her whole life. I was a very competitive gymnast, then moved to triathlons, then to cycling and running, strength training has always supported these activities. I am a certified personal trainer, and the aneurysm is a new diagnosis as of Dec of 2022. it was shocking - I now have a heart condition. I ran a marathon 2 weeks after I turned 60. My Cradic surgeon has stated that I can train for a 50k (31 miles) race, as well as a 150 mile bike ride. I have a 50 lb lifting weight limit. My BP is low and I am on no medications. My questions are .. is the activity too much? I run 5-6 days a week plus strength training and biking. I have mild chest pain - all of this has been told to my doc. they keep telling me everything is ok - I am just so nervous about all of this - but want to keep doing what I love. Any input will be appreciated.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Aortic Aneurysms Support Group.

Profile picture for moonboy @moonboy

@azguy1

I remember feeling the same confusion when I first heard the words “aortic dissection.” Mine was already tearing by the time anyone realized what was happening, and in 2015 I ended up on an operating table for emergency open-heart surgery and a Dacron graft. Because of that, I pay very close attention now to what the numbers actually mean and what the body is trying to tell us.

A dilation of 4.0 cm is something to respect, but it’s not something that should steal the joy from your life. The fact that your doctor has cleared you without restrictions is reassuring. What I learned after my own dissection is that it isn’t the activity itself that’s the danger — it’s how we do it. The aorta hates sudden spikes in pressure. It hates breath-holding. It hates that heavy Valsalva strain we slip into without thinking. You can climb mountains, hike hard, and let your heart rate rise, but the key is keeping every movement smooth and every breath open. When the breathing stays loose, the pressure stays steady, and the aorta stays happier.

I still exercise every day, but I do it with attention instead of fear. If you feel good, if you’re breathing easily, and if your doctor has given you the green light, you’re doing the right things. Knowing your measurement and paying attention to the mechanics of how you move is what keeps you safe. That knowledge is power — and it’s power I wish I’d had before my dissection.

You’re not alone in this. Keep moving, keep breathing, and keep respecting that aorta without letting it run your life. Peace.

Jump to this post

@moonboy Thank you for taking the time to comment. I appreciate it. Yeah, I think about it often and monitor my heart rate with my watch. I will try not to let it take the joy out of my life and keep on getting scanned. Thanks again. I really appreciate it.

REPLY
Profile picture for charlanepj @charlanepj

I absolutely agree with kmailloux. When found my aneurysm was a 4. I was told when it reached 5 we would discuss options. I ended up with an emergency dissection at 4.5 cm. Emergency everything just like kmailloux said. Be mindful, don't lift anything that causes you to grunt, moan, groan, hold your breath, or strain. ASK FOR HELP! I am a 71 YO female and this happened to me at 68. I am going in for another surgery for correction in February. I had no symptoms then and have none now.
Best wishes

Jump to this post

@charlanepj Thank you. Yeah. I appreciate the advice. I’ll keep a close eye on it. Thank you.

REPLY

Thank you. Yeah, I’m always thinking about it. Uhh. This is good advice. On inclines going up hills my heart rate spikes. I’m watching my watch closely. As soon as I take a 1 minute break it drops back to normal. I guess we are lucky with modern watches these days that we can watch such things and be smarter. I appreciate the reply. Thank you.

REPLY
Profile picture for moonboy @moonboy

@azguy1

I remember feeling the same confusion when I first heard the words “aortic dissection.” Mine was already tearing by the time anyone realized what was happening, and in 2015 I ended up on an operating table for emergency open-heart surgery and a Dacron graft. Because of that, I pay very close attention now to what the numbers actually mean and what the body is trying to tell us.

A dilation of 4.0 cm is something to respect, but it’s not something that should steal the joy from your life. The fact that your doctor has cleared you without restrictions is reassuring. What I learned after my own dissection is that it isn’t the activity itself that’s the danger — it’s how we do it. The aorta hates sudden spikes in pressure. It hates breath-holding. It hates that heavy Valsalva strain we slip into without thinking. You can climb mountains, hike hard, and let your heart rate rise, but the key is keeping every movement smooth and every breath open. When the breathing stays loose, the pressure stays steady, and the aorta stays happier.

I still exercise every day, but I do it with attention instead of fear. If you feel good, if you’re breathing easily, and if your doctor has given you the green light, you’re doing the right things. Knowing your measurement and paying attention to the mechanics of how you move is what keeps you safe. That knowledge is power — and it’s power I wish I’d had before my dissection.

You’re not alone in this. Keep moving, keep breathing, and keep respecting that aorta without letting it run your life. Peace.

Jump to this post

REPLY
Profile picture for azguy1 @azguy1

My aortic dilation is 4.0 cm. I exercise a lot hiking and climbing mountains. Often my heart rate gets into the 140s-150s. I never know though if that bad or not. My doc told me no restrictions on exercise. Thanks for posting this thread.

Jump to this post

@azguy1 Yeah, I was hiking and biking with no issue until my ascending aneurysm got to 5.4cm, at which point I went in for surgery to repair. So, when my aneurysm was in the 4cm range like yours is, I was blissfully ignorant and had no issues with exercise. I am now 1.5 years post surgery and am back to hiking and biking with no issues... my heart rate regularly gets into the mid-140's but when it does, I slow down and then get back at it...

Enjoy life but keep monitoring that dilation yearly...

REPLY
Profile picture for houston13 @houston13

@shiloh376 hi , here is one of them, the most important:


In this one Dr Prakash talks about exercise and how it affects BP and aneurysms in

The other video I have posted is from Dr Andrew Huberman’s channel and he and a guest explain why and how high BP increases when lifting heavy weights, but watch Dr Prakash’s he focus solely on aneurysms

Hope it helps!!

Jump to this post

@houston13 Thank you so much!

REPLY
Profile picture for shiloh376 @shiloh376

@houston13 How can I find your videos? I am very interested. Shiloh376 Brian

Jump to this post

@shiloh376 hi , here is one of them, the most important:


In this one Dr Prakash talks about exercise and how it affects BP and aneurysms in

The other video I have posted is from Dr Andrew Huberman’s channel and he and a guest explain why and how high BP increases when lifting heavy weights, but watch Dr Prakash’s he focus solely on aneurysms

Hope it helps!!

REPLY
Profile picture for houston13 @houston13

The main issue with exercise is avoiding any exercise that leads you to hold your breath and/or grunt, that is common when trying to maintain back stability, sometimes while doing planks, crunches or lifting heavy weights. It is known that during those moments your BP rises significantly and high BP is the worst enemy of an aneurysm. That is why cardiologists normally tell patients to limit weight lifting to 30lbs. I have posted videos in this forum about exercising and aneurysms, look through my posts and you will find them. One of them is from a cardiologist who does research in the subject the other is by Dr Andy Galpin with Dr Huberman, it is not about aneurysms but how and why straining makes BP increase and by how much

On the other hand keeping your body healthy it’s paramount in case you ever need surgery to repair your aneurysm. I had mine repaired in 2020, I was 54 and my aneurysm was 5.2 cm. I was in very good physical shape and my surgeon gave me >99% of having no complications. I was out of the hospital in 5 days back to work in 3 weeks

Jump to this post

@houston13 How can I find your videos? I am very interested. Shiloh376 Brian

REPLY
Profile picture for kmailloux @kmailloux

Thank you so much for your feed back.. and yes I am trying to pin point the chest pain. It drives me crazy, trying to figure out what is causing it. the Doctors don't want to do more testing because I am a very healthy 60 year old ... expect and aortic aneurysm, that could be life threatening. I am new to this all and still trying to come to grips with it.. it doesn't help when the doc's and nurses give you the standard "don't lift more than 50 lbs" Im 5'2" and 125lbs how is that the same as a 6'2" man of 250 lbs.. doesn't make sense to me.. As does the as much cardio as you are use to guideline.. I am used to Marathons - is that much blood going thru the aorta good for the aneurysm ? no one seems to know.. Any helo is great.

Jump to this post

@kmailloux Hi. I am a 71 year old man diagnosed 8 years ago with an AAA that was 4.4 cm. I am very active and have gradually increased the intensity of my daily walks of about 2 miles walking at a brisk pace. I also lift light weights about 5 times a week gradually having increased the amount. I do lots of squats with no weight and pushups against the kitchen counter. In the gym I bench press using 25-35lb dumbells doing about 10 reps backing off as I begin to strain. I use exercise bands at home as well so I am exercising frequently. In 8 years my aneurysm has not grown at all. I have a CAT scan with contrasting dye to keep track at least once a year but more often lately since I have increased the amount and intensity of the workouts i do.

So I am curious. Here we are 2 and 1/2 years later and I am wondering how you are doing. Have you backed off on your exercise? Has there been any change in the size of your aneurysm? How are you doing? Brian

REPLY

I absolutely agree with kmailloux. When found my aneurysm was a 4. I was told when it reached 5 we would discuss options. I ended up with an emergency dissection at 4.5 cm. Emergency everything just like kmailloux said. Be mindful, don't lift anything that causes you to grunt, moan, groan, hold your breath, or strain. ASK FOR HELP! I am a 71 YO female and this happened to me at 68. I am going in for another surgery for correction in February. I had no symptoms then and have none now.
Best wishes

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.