TMS or ECT treatments: Did they work for you?

Posted by phxlife @phxlife, May 3, 2023

TMS and ECT treatments are very reputable and often used these days by top notch Psychiatrists. I’m wondering if anyone has had either one recently, and did you have it for depression, or another condition? How did they work for you?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Depression & Anxiety Support Group.

Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

I did TMS for 3 months and I did see improvements but the problem was it didn't last and that seems to be the problem with TMS.

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

Yes

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

I have thought about it, but am afraid it would increase my chronic headaches....

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

Has anyone had TMS treatment for depression and/or anxiety?If so, what results did you experience? What side effects did you have?

REPLY
Profile picture for boilerbob @boilerbob

Has anyone had TMS treatment for depression and/or anxiety?If so, what results did you experience? What side effects did you have?

Jump to this post

I use an Alpha Stim and started recently with neurofeedback. I love my Alpha Stim, bought it for anxiety and insomnia.

REPLY
Profile picture for boilerbob @boilerbob

Has anyone had TMS treatment for depression and/or anxiety?If so, what results did you experience? What side effects did you have?

Jump to this post

I tried TMS two years ago and it did not work. I believe it might work for depression but not anxiety. I have ocd, anxiety and depression. I was very disappointed but not everyone has the same result. I think the only thing you can do is try it.

REPLY
Profile picture for boilerbob @boilerbob

Has anyone had TMS treatment for depression and/or anxiety?If so, what results did you experience? What side effects did you have?

Jump to this post

I am 3 sessions short of my 36 sessions. I have gotten no relief at all. Disappointed and frustrated. They want me to do 10 more sessions. I don’t think I want to continue. Feeling tired was my only side effect.

REPLY
Profile picture for Arvind Natarajan @malebreastcancer47

I use an Alpha Stim and started recently with neurofeedback. I love my Alpha Stim, bought it for anxiety and insomnia.

Jump to this post

@malebreastcancer47
Are you on any other medication.? How does it work for your anxiety and insomnia. Do you use it every day. I tried TMS and it didn’t work. I’m curious about Alpha Stim.

REPLY
Profile picture for Arvind Natarajan @malebreastcancer47

I use an Alpha Stim and started recently with neurofeedback. I love my Alpha Stim, bought it for anxiety and insomnia.

Jump to this post

@malebreastcancer47 also very interested in your experiences. I am wondering if you have headaches, migraines, or any type of pain condition that you may have noticed it helped.

REPLY
Profile picture for mitch4444 @mitch4444

@malebreastcancer47
Are you on any other medication.? How does it work for your anxiety and insomnia. Do you use it every day. I tried TMS and it didn’t work. I’m curious about Alpha Stim.

Jump to this post

@mitch4444

Mayo oncology recommended getting a therapist since I was prone to quitting cancer treatment. I was fortunate to find a therapist that prescribes the Alpha Stim, and also uses it daily, with his wife and kids. Its not covered under my insurance so I paid out of pocket, $850.
I started using it once a week or as needed but last several months, use it daily, 1-2 per day.

My other med is for type 2 diabetes, weight loss and breast cancer treatment. I have never taken med for anxiety, or depression.
Along with Alpha Stim, I also drink chamomile tea (non tea bag) at night. During the day, drink green tea with caffeine vs coffee.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.