TMS or ECT treatments: Did they work for you?

Posted by phxlife @phxlife, May 3, 2023

TMS and ECT treatments are very reputable and often used these days by top notch Psychiatrists. I’m wondering if anyone has had either one recently, and did you have it for depression, or another condition? How did they work for you?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Depression & Anxiety Support Group.

Profile picture for drnelson22 @drnelson22

Hello,I am in the middle of my fourth week of six of TMS treatments. I am still having terrible side effects, am exhausted and am feeling very nauseous when I leave daily treatments. I am just as low as when I began treatment and am beginning to wonder if TMS is making me worse. Does anyone have insight into this or a similar experience?

Jump to this post

I participated in TMS treatments twice. Both times it took to the end of the session to see any depression improvement but the improvement continued after TMS was completed. I believe TMS helped with a more effective processing of my mental medications. The first TMS session seemed most effective. After a year, I had the second session. I did not feel as though the second session was as helpful and at this time I do not plan to complete TMS again.

REPLY

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

Hello,
I've had great success with TMS for treatment-resistant depression. I first had TMS treatment about six years ago and had my longest remission ever from severe depression. The depression returned this fall, and I completed a second treatment about two months ago, again with success. In this treatment, I started feeling some relief about three weeks into treatment. And it kept improving. I recall the doctor saying it might take until near the end of treatment to get relief. I wish you well on this journey.

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

Hi!
Thank you so much for replying to my question so quickly. Hearing of your success twice with TMS gives me much hope.
I’m so happy you are doing well and I wish you continued good mental health.
Thank you again for answering my question and for being so kind and compassionate!

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Hi!
Thank you so much for replying to my question so quickly. Hearing of your success twice with TMS gives me much hope.
I’m so happy you are doing well and I wish you continued good mental health.
Thank you again for answering my question and for being so kind and compassionate!

Jump to this post

Happy to hear it was helpful. Those of us with depression need to support one another. I'm glad you are trying TMS, and I hope it is as successful for you as it was for me!

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

Thank you! It is definitely comforting having the support of others who understand .

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

There’s nothing better, than having support from other people, who have been, or are going through severe depressive illness! It can be so debilitating in many ways, and having even just one person, who has the same diagnosis, understand, is a blessing!

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

@ellemccope, you may also wish to review these TMS-related discussions:
- Do TMS (transcranial magnetic stimulation) treatments really work?
https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/tms-transcranial-magnetic-stimulation-treatments-really-work/
- Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Therapy: What's your experience?
https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/tms/

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Has anyone had success with TMS Therapy? I have just completed 12 out of 36 sessions but do not, yet, feel any relief from my treatment resistant depression and anxiety. If you’ve had success, how long did it take before you started noticing an improvement in symptoms?

Jump to this post

Hi! Thank you so much for sharing those posts/comments with me. It was so thoughtful of you. The comments/reviews give me hope the treatments will work for me.
Wishing you all the best!

REPLY
Profile picture for ellemccope @ellemccope

Hi! Thank you so much for sharing those posts/comments with me. It was so thoughtful of you. The comments/reviews give me hope the treatments will work for me.
Wishing you all the best!

Jump to this post

ellemccope,
I did the first round of TMS and it was successful for 4-5 months. Then my
depression returned. I did a second treatment without any success at all.
You should try it and hope it works for you. Sorry to tell you how it worked and
not work for me.
I hope you have better luck than me.
Pete

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.