Magnesium Glycinate

Posted by radinski @radinski, Apr 28 12:34pm

Does anyone not tolerate it? I’ve tried citrate, L-Threonate, and glycinate. Works well for muscle cramps and spasms as well as poor sleep but extremely hard on my bowels. I know citrate is the worst. I can’t tolerate either form. Any suggestions?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Bones, Joints & Muscles Support Group.

Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

To all who are supplementing their magnesium - Did you ask your doctor to test your magnesium levels before you started?

Did you know that, when tested, only about 2% of people have too little magnesium in their bodies? For that reason, the test is not a routine part of a blood panel, and must be requested by your doctor. Magnesium levels are checked with a blood test called MgS (serum magnesium), an add-on to a normal metabolic or vitamin-level screening panel. A normal reading is 1.7 - 2.2 mg/dl.

Your body is a champion at managing the level of Mg in your blood. That means your levels are normal, you will produce expensive urine, not help the symptoms you are trying to treat. And if your levels are just slightly low, rather than a supplement, try treating yourself to a daily "dose" of magnesium from a food. Your body is designed to extract nutrients form whole foods through the digestion process. You can find a list here:
https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/magnesium-test
I just realized that I can QUIT my 200 mg per day of magnesium glycinate - I eat pumpkin seeds and cashews every day, avocado and black beans several times a week, and sometimes dark chocolate as an evening treat.

Has your magnesium level been tested? Can you get what you need from your food?

Jump to this post

@sueinmn
Both my cardiologist and neurologist have suggested I take magnesium supplements but neither tested me for a deficiency. I think I’ll ask at my next appointment. I have soooo many food restrictions with dysphagia, afib, GERD, allergies and more that it’s not simple for me to get everything through diet but I’ll have to add up how much magnesium I think I’m getting. You provided good info though. Thanks.

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

To all who are supplementing their magnesium - Did you ask your doctor to test your magnesium levels before you started?

Did you know that, when tested, only about 2% of people have too little magnesium in their bodies? For that reason, the test is not a routine part of a blood panel, and must be requested by your doctor. Magnesium levels are checked with a blood test called MgS (serum magnesium), an add-on to a normal metabolic or vitamin-level screening panel. A normal reading is 1.7 - 2.2 mg/dl.

Your body is a champion at managing the level of Mg in your blood. That means your levels are normal, you will produce expensive urine, not help the symptoms you are trying to treat. And if your levels are just slightly low, rather than a supplement, try treating yourself to a daily "dose" of magnesium from a food. Your body is designed to extract nutrients form whole foods through the digestion process. You can find a list here:
https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/magnesium-test
I just realized that I can QUIT my 200 mg per day of magnesium glycinate - I eat pumpkin seeds and cashews every day, avocado and black beans several times a week, and sometimes dark chocolate as an evening treat.

Has your magnesium level been tested? Can you get what you need from your food?

Jump to this post

@sueinmn good question and I added it to my list of primary care questions. In general I’m not inclined to adding supplements.
But since starting my current low dose at suppertime I've not had a specific ankle muscle twitch that sometimes happened at night. That’s a relief.

REPLY
Profile picture for Zebra @californiazebra

@sueinmn
Both my cardiologist and neurologist have suggested I take magnesium supplements but neither tested me for a deficiency. I think I’ll ask at my next appointment. I have soooo many food restrictions with dysphagia, afib, GERD, allergies and more that it’s not simple for me to get everything through diet but I’ll have to add up how much magnesium I think I’m getting. You provided good info though. Thanks.

Jump to this post

@californiazebra & @loll Yes, my cardio and my rheumatologist both suggested the magnesium without testing me. Based on this discussion, I did a lot of reading about correct levels and recommended daily intake, and am now convinced my diet alone provides more than enough magnesium. I am stopping the supplement until my cardio appointment in two weeks, then will ask to be tested. Then we will explore the right dosage if I need it. Since magnesium is the modulator for a number of other nutrients, my concern is that overdosing this one element could knock other things like potassium "out of whack".

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

@radinski Have you reviewed your diet to see if you can increase the amount of magnesium-rich foods you eat? Here is a good list of the magnesium content of various foods.
https://health.clevelandclinic.org/foods-that-are-high-in-magnesium
A woman needs about 320mg of magnesium per day, a man about 420. With planning, your diet can meet those needs. If you are diabetic, have celiac or Crohn's disease, or regularly consume alcohol, you may need more, but consult your physician.

You could also try a much lower dose than the 400mg in a typical supplement. Nature Made has one that contains just 100mg per capsule. (It says 200mg on the label, but that is for two capsules.)

Jump to this post

@sueinmn with that, I have been getting way more than needed. Years ago, I was prescribed Magnesium L-Threonate 2,000mg 2xs per day for joint pain by an holistic doctor, with no issues. However, after a while, blood tests showed an “abnormal amount”. So I stopped for a while. Since then I have developed severe muscle cramps and neurologist suggested I began taking them again. She didn’t specify the dose but I started taking 2000mg a day. At this point I can’t tolerate them but there were benefits to joint pain and better sleep. Currently, I take Epsom salt baths and use magnesium cream and oil. Needless to say, no more bowel issues.

REPLY
Profile picture for cmmichaela @cmmichaela

I have just started opening the capsules of magnesium (and my vitamin c, too) and sprinkling some of the contents into my food. Then I close up the capsule until the next time I have a snack or a meal, to spread out my doses. The capsules often contain such a high dose, and far more than I know can be absorbed at once. This process is a bit tedious but my system seems to be responding well. I only just started this process a couple of weeks ago, so I don't have any long term experience with it but maybe it could be worth a try? Maybe try sprinkling into yogurt or a smoothie or something? I also purchased empty capsules to try to empty a bit of the contents of the vitamins/minerals into those to make my own capsules... I haven't attempted it yet. It seems like it might be a challenge, especially when the filled capsule is topped off; the contents spill out pretty easily. (I am more concerned about my vitamin c eating away at my tooth enamel if I continue with sprinkling in my food. A capsule may be helpful there.) Anyway, maybe it would be worth a try?

Jump to this post

@cmmichaela I have so many capsules, that method will probably last until they expire. Thank you! I’ll try that.

REPLY
Profile picture for starbright375 @starbright375

@cmmichaela A couple weeks ago I was looking at magnesium sprays and lotions. I decided to mix one 100 mg capsule with one tablespoon of hand lotion. I applied it before going to bed and getting up in the morning. I notice a difference on my legs. My feet and hands are ok. It is my legs that feel like bursting. I might keep this up. I asked the doctor if there is a prescription lotion so we shall see. I asked Chrome's AI if the magnesium would dissolve enough to penetrate and go where it should. AI said that possibly it would from some brands that had enough magnesium in them. AI suggest the first one on Walmart's page that I had open, it had a big 7 printed on it. It was a spray. I don't remember the name, but saved it. Also said there was a less expensive one for $6.87 that a DR somebody. I am not promoting...just was Chrome's AI messaged to me. I like your idea of sprinkling too. I will try that as it sounds easy too. The company that is heavy on advertising Magnesium gummies on Facebook has Xylitol and advertising sugarless. Why sugarless on small gummies is selling point seems weird since many of those fake sugars especially those ending in Xylitol cause diarrhea in quite a few people, me included. Many people do not know that artificial sugar is the cause of their IBS-D. Evidently, magnesium is for me too. I took one capsule about 9 pm. one night and at 11 pm, 11:15 and 11:30 made trips quickly. It must have set off my digestive system, but must have absorbed some too, because I slept better that night and no bathroom trips, the first time in at least 15 years. The next night, same thing. Decided I best not take any magnesium late at night. Also affected me taking it at lunch. I really hope to sleep like that again once I get the magnesium situation solved. I hope our shortcuts or the spray or lotion work. Because I believe I am really lacking in magnesium. Good luck with your experiments too.

Jump to this post

@starbright375 last week I started Epsom salt baths, spray and cream. Someone in the feed suggested openings capsules for a lesser dose. I have enough of them left to do that until they expire! 😂

REPLY
Profile picture for danarosef @danarosef

How much are you taking?

I get 100mg in my multi which I take in the morning after breakfast. Then I take 120mg at bedtime. I have not had a problem.

Jump to this post

@danarosef too much.

REPLY
Profile picture for Zebra @californiazebra

All good tips here. I was asking Google AI to help me find magnesium glycinate powder because I can't safely swallow capsules with dysphagia and have an intolerance to artificial sweeteners and other additives. AI suggested Seeking Health Magnesium Glycinate Powder as a clean option with no fillers, binders or additives. You mix the powder in water or any liquid. Website is SeekingHealth.com AI states Seeking Health is NSF GMP certified and highly reputable in the supplement world. I haven't ordered it yet. Has anyone tried it?

Jump to this post

@californiazebra no, but is a possibility in the future. Thanks!

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

To all who are supplementing their magnesium - Did you ask your doctor to test your magnesium levels before you started?

Did you know that, when tested, only about 2% of people have too little magnesium in their bodies? For that reason, the test is not a routine part of a blood panel, and must be requested by your doctor. Magnesium levels are checked with a blood test called MgS (serum magnesium), an add-on to a normal metabolic or vitamin-level screening panel. A normal reading is 1.7 - 2.2 mg/dl.

Your body is a champion at managing the level of Mg in your blood. That means your levels are normal, you will produce expensive urine, not help the symptoms you are trying to treat. And if your levels are just slightly low, rather than a supplement, try treating yourself to a daily "dose" of magnesium from a food. Your body is designed to extract nutrients form whole foods through the digestion process. You can find a list here:
https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/magnesium-test
I just realized that I can QUIT my 200 mg per day of magnesium glycinate - I eat pumpkin seeds and cashews every day, avocado and black beans several times a week, and sometimes dark chocolate as an evening treat.

Has your magnesium level been tested? Can you get what you need from your food?

Jump to this post

@sueinmn I concur.

REPLY

Great info. I started taking Magnesium complex with Zinc, 310mg 2x day because I'm having joint & muscle pain from taking injectable statins. I haven't been on Mag. long enough (2 weeks) to notice any difference at this time. Not having side effects mentioned but will pay close attention.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.