Small lung nodules: How often should they be scanned / monitored?

Posted by sandie956 @sandie956, Jun 22, 2019

Small nodules on each lung. Third CT scan showed no change. Doctor said if next CT in one year shows no change, need no scan again, is this true? I would rather have scans every year?

Doctors said the same to me. But they still check yearly. This last time 2 years had past. My last CT had a little change, but the doctor said she wasn't worried. Ummmm,,,,glad she isn't worried, but I am. I hate waiting for those results…

REPLY

@sandie956 Not knowing more than what you wrote before, I would want to have cans yearly at least. I would especially want this if there was a cance of cancer with the nodules. To my way of thinking it makes sense to keep tabs on these places to stay current with how things are going. I am not a physician, but as a patient iI would want to know. Glad that there is no change in them. Keep us posted.

REPLY

@sandie956– Good morning and welcome to Mayo Connect. I'm in agreement with @alamogal635. There isn't enough information to make a guess how to help. So I have a smattering of questions to ask to gather what we need. OK?
How long ago did you have symptoms to go to a Pulmonologist? Have you seen a surgeon? Have you had a biopsy? What physical symptoms do you have?
There are several of us that have multifocal adenocarcinoma of the lung. (https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/multifocal-adenocarcinoma-of-the-lung-continual-recurrences/) Does any of this fit what your doctor has said or found?

Sandie- We are not physicians so we can not diagnose. we can only really relate our experiences and see if they might fit your needs and answer your questions. So let's get going and see if we can help, OK?

REPLY
@fracturedd

Doctors said the same to me. But they still check yearly. This last time 2 years had past. My last CT had a little change, but the doctor said she wasn't worried. Ummmm,,,,glad she isn't worried, but I am. I hate waiting for those results…

Jump to this post

Hello @fracturedd– I agree. At least once a year is probably good. what kind of a doctor said this to you?

REPLY
@merpreb

Hello @fracturedd– I agree. At least once a year is probably good. what kind of a doctor said this to you?

Jump to this post

My pulmonologist.

REPLY
In reply to @fracturedd "My pulmonologist." + (show)
@fracturedd

My pulmonologist.

Jump to this post

@fracturedd– Do you have any lung lesions? I'm wondering if you have seen a lung surgeon or oncologist for further diagnosis?

REPLY

I have a ton of scaring and multiple nodules. I have seen surgeons. No one will touch my lungs. I have ild,,, kind of as a result of juvenile scleroderma. Couple years ago I collapsed a long, had a talc procedure that went wrong….and,,,,,ugh im a medical mystery basically.

REPLY
@fracturedd

I have a ton of scaring and multiple nodules. I have seen surgeons. No one will touch my lungs. I have ild,,, kind of as a result of juvenile scleroderma. Couple years ago I collapsed a long, had a talc procedure that went wrong….and,,,,,ugh im a medical mystery basically.

Jump to this post

*lung

REPLY

Hi all, I've been following this discussion. You'll notice that I changed the title to "Small lung nodules: How often should they be scanned / monitored?" I think this topic will interest additional members of the Lung Health group, such as @rdunnigan @grecarmar @marfan1 @pattymac @bartlett36 and @sheker

How often one should get scanned or having imaging tests done really depends on the individual and their risk factors. It's really important to talk with your specialist to make sure you're getting the right tests with the best frequency for you.

Choosing Wisely is an initiative of the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) Foundation that seeks to advance a national dialogue on avoiding unnecessary medical tests, treatments and procedures. I looked up some information about pulmonary (lung) nodules on their site and found these 2 articles of interest:
– Five Commonly Performed Tests and Treatments in Pulmonary Medicine May Not Always Be Necessary http://www.choosingwisely.org/five-commonly-performed-tests-and-treatments-in-pulmonary-medicine-may-not-always-be-necessary/
– ACCP and ATS – CT surveillance to evaluate indeterminate pulmonary nodules http://www.choosingwisely.org/clinician-lists/american-college-chest-physicians-american-thoracic-society-ct-surveillance-to-evaluate-indeterminate-pulmonary-nodules/

This short article from Mayo Clinic may also help:
– Can lung nodules be cancerous? https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/lung-cancer/expert-answers/lung-nodules/faq-20058445

Above all, it's important to ask questions. If the suggested frequency of testing make you uncomfortable, tell your doctor and talk about it. Ask questions like:
– How often should I get a CT scan?
– What do you recommend this frequency?
– Would getting scanned more often be harmful for me? Why?

REPLY
@colleenyoung

Hi all, I've been following this discussion. You'll notice that I changed the title to "Small lung nodules: How often should they be scanned / monitored?" I think this topic will interest additional members of the Lung Health group, such as @rdunnigan @grecarmar @marfan1 @pattymac @bartlett36 and @sheker

How often one should get scanned or having imaging tests done really depends on the individual and their risk factors. It's really important to talk with your specialist to make sure you're getting the right tests with the best frequency for you.

Choosing Wisely is an initiative of the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) Foundation that seeks to advance a national dialogue on avoiding unnecessary medical tests, treatments and procedures. I looked up some information about pulmonary (lung) nodules on their site and found these 2 articles of interest:
– Five Commonly Performed Tests and Treatments in Pulmonary Medicine May Not Always Be Necessary http://www.choosingwisely.org/five-commonly-performed-tests-and-treatments-in-pulmonary-medicine-may-not-always-be-necessary/
– ACCP and ATS – CT surveillance to evaluate indeterminate pulmonary nodules http://www.choosingwisely.org/clinician-lists/american-college-chest-physicians-american-thoracic-society-ct-surveillance-to-evaluate-indeterminate-pulmonary-nodules/

This short article from Mayo Clinic may also help:
– Can lung nodules be cancerous? https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/lung-cancer/expert-answers/lung-nodules/faq-20058445

Above all, it's important to ask questions. If the suggested frequency of testing make you uncomfortable, tell your doctor and talk about it. Ask questions like:
– How often should I get a CT scan?
– What do you recommend this frequency?
– Would getting scanned more often be harmful for me? Why?

Jump to this post

Colleen-I don't believe in the 2 year rule when checking for nodules. I once had the misfortune of having an Intern come into my examine room and say that insurance should only cover the first 5 years of CT scans because it wasn't cost efficient. My exam was for a second cancer after 10 years. If I hadn't been scanned I wouldn't be telling this true story.
Small cell lung nodules are more dangerous and any who has had them will most likely have a recurrence.
I say that anyone who has had a cancerous nodule should have at least a CT once a year.

REPLY
@fracturedd

I have a ton of scaring and multiple nodules. I have seen surgeons. No one will touch my lungs. I have ild,,, kind of as a result of juvenile scleroderma. Couple years ago I collapsed a long, had a talc procedure that went wrong….and,,,,,ugh im a medical mystery basically.

Jump to this post

@fracturedd– I'm so so sorry that you have to deal with all of this. It must be scary and have you on your toes all the time. I know that after having lung cancer I'm always looking over my shoulder.
If you don't need oxygen how are you coping with doing your daily routine?

REPLY
@merpreb

@fracturedd– I'm so so sorry that you have to deal with all of this. It must be scary and have you on your toes all the time. I know that after having lung cancer I'm always looking over my shoulder.
If you don't need oxygen how are you coping with doing your daily routine?

Jump to this post

No oxygen. I practice Bikram yoga and try to exercise daily. I try to eat as healthy as possible. I try to think in the present,, every once in awhile I think of how I don't really have any treatment that will help me if needed, and that scares me. So I'm just cautious. I just turned 40 and my body feels healthy it's just my darn lungs! I'm wondering if anyone else has had a talc procedure to fix a collapsed lung and had negative side effects?

REPLY
@fracturedd

No oxygen. I practice Bikram yoga and try to exercise daily. I try to eat as healthy as possible. I try to think in the present,, every once in awhile I think of how I don't really have any treatment that will help me if needed, and that scares me. So I'm just cautious. I just turned 40 and my body feels healthy it's just my darn lungs! I'm wondering if anyone else has had a talc procedure to fix a collapsed lung and had negative side effects?

Jump to this post

@fracturedd – Good morning. What an inspiration you are! Research and breakthroughs for lung diseases and cancer have come a long way but still have miles to go. We just have to take the best care of ourselves that we can and hope for the best. I feel the same way that you do, I feel terrific but when I go full steam ahead my lungs pull me back to reality.
The talc procedure actually uses talc powder to help prevent the build up of fluid. : https://www.uwhealth.org/uw-carbone-cancer-center/palliative-lung-procedures/11037
When did you have this procedure?

REPLY
@merpreb

@fracturedd – Good morning. What an inspiration you are! Research and breakthroughs for lung diseases and cancer have come a long way but still have miles to go. We just have to take the best care of ourselves that we can and hope for the best. I feel the same way that you do, I feel terrific but when I go full steam ahead my lungs pull me back to reality.
The talc procedure actually uses talc powder to help prevent the build up of fluid. : https://www.uwhealth.org/uw-carbone-cancer-center/palliative-lung-procedures/11037
When did you have this procedure?

Jump to this post

I had the pleurodesis done 3 years ago. Once they put the talc in my chest tube they forgot to turn the machine on to inflate my lung so the talc could do is job and make my lung stick to the chest wall,,,I was left over night in such pain and confusion due to pain meds. When my doctor visited me in the morning they realized the chest tube was clogged so essentially the talc just created a clump in the base of my left lung,, which happenes to be my "good" lung. It didn't fix the collapsed lung. So weeks later they used a couple valves to "plug" up the lung and it worked. Ugh that healing was torture!! Anyways my recent CT says,,, change in the talc area. What does that mean!! I feel like that little bit of lung that is now taken up by this clump of talc is really hindering my health. Now I might have hypertension and I think it's because my lungs are working even harder. BTW I'm not over weight and eat super healthy. I don't want to take medicine for hypertension,,ugh. I just wonder if this has happened to anyone else??? And what their side effects have been and how they deal with it.

REPLY
@fracturedd

I had the pleurodesis done 3 years ago. Once they put the talc in my chest tube they forgot to turn the machine on to inflate my lung so the talc could do is job and make my lung stick to the chest wall,,,I was left over night in such pain and confusion due to pain meds. When my doctor visited me in the morning they realized the chest tube was clogged so essentially the talc just created a clump in the base of my left lung,, which happenes to be my "good" lung. It didn't fix the collapsed lung. So weeks later they used a couple valves to "plug" up the lung and it worked. Ugh that healing was torture!! Anyways my recent CT says,,, change in the talc area. What does that mean!! I feel like that little bit of lung that is now taken up by this clump of talc is really hindering my health. Now I might have hypertension and I think it's because my lungs are working even harder. BTW I'm not over weight and eat super healthy. I don't want to take medicine for hypertension,,ugh. I just wonder if this has happened to anyone else??? And what their side effects have been and how they deal with it.

Jump to this post

@fracturedd– Good morning. I continue to be stunned at the preventable illnesses caused by callousness of the medical field. This is absolutely horrible and unforgivable that this happened to anyone. I don't know how anyone pulls through something like this emotionally.
Do you think that your hypertension is caused by your anxiety about this whole catastrophe or because you aren't getting the O2 that you need?

REPLY
Please login or register to post a reply.