Looking for a decent portable nebulizer

Posted by raybo @raybo, Jan 19 9:20am

So many of these look the same with a different name and fizz out in short order. I’m taking a long trip soon and need one for those times you are not in your room. Suggestions?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the MAC & Bronchiectasis Support Group.

Profile picture for wandafanda @wandafanda

I’ve been using the PariTrek for over a year when I travel. It works fine and has a nice little carrying case.

Jump to this post

@wandafanda
Do you find the PariTrek to be slow? Does it get too hot if it is run for longer than about 30 minutes? I've heard these complaints from some and wondered if that was your experience with it.

REPLY
Profile picture for raybo @raybo

I just ordered one and in process of sending another back. With so many people with Bronchiectasis COPD etc you’d think some medical org would do a real certification test on them. I’ll get back with names and my results.

Jump to this post

As nebulizers dispense med, they are all approved by the FDA as safe and effective. The FDA does not long term consumer style reviews. I would rely on Amazon for those types of reviews - there seem to be any near 5 star reviews for nebulizers, and most devices seem to be around $35.

FDA.gov contains a list of approved devices.

REPLY

Reporting in on the Pari e-Flow after a week. It is FAST! it is SILENT! and the stream is STRONG! At this point (fingers crossed) I only neb 7% saline once a day. It takes - wait for it - 3 1/2 minutes!

The first time I tried it, I felt like a 7th grader trying their first cigarette - I was coughing from the first breath. Now I have figured out how to close my lips and tongue to slow the flow, so I get through the vial before I begin to cough. When it stopped and shut off after such a short time, I thought something was wrong, but I measured with a syringe and less than 1 ml was left - just as they said.

How did it feel afterwards? The first time I wasn't sure - I had such a coughing jag that it was 10 minutes before I could start airway clearance, then I cleared as much in 5 rounds of breathing as I usually do in 10, and my chest felt good.

Cleaning according to directions was pretty easy - rinse (esp the screen) under flowing tap water, soak in soapy water, boil 5 minutes. I'm a little lazy, so I rinse and wash every day, only boil every 3rd use. I'm healthy right now, but if I have an exacerbation I'll boil it every time. I'm hoping this works for me, so when I travel in September & October it will be easy. I'm running on batteries and watching to see how well they last - I would like to get by without carrying the charger.

Would I buy it again? Since I have the patience of a cranky 3 year old, and have the means to do so, YES. We shall see how it lasts over time. Just the convenience for travel, which we do between 6 and 7 months per year, is wonderful. It is very small, quiet & lightweight with no hoses to manage - the first time I used it my husband didn't even know it was on.

By the way, when purchased from Nebology, it is significantly discounted right now and it comes with 2 power heads. Since each one lasts 6 months to a year, and costs about $100, that is a savings.

I'll report back in a few months.

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

Reporting in on the Pari e-Flow after a week. It is FAST! it is SILENT! and the stream is STRONG! At this point (fingers crossed) I only neb 7% saline once a day. It takes - wait for it - 3 1/2 minutes!

The first time I tried it, I felt like a 7th grader trying their first cigarette - I was coughing from the first breath. Now I have figured out how to close my lips and tongue to slow the flow, so I get through the vial before I begin to cough. When it stopped and shut off after such a short time, I thought something was wrong, but I measured with a syringe and less than 1 ml was left - just as they said.

How did it feel afterwards? The first time I wasn't sure - I had such a coughing jag that it was 10 minutes before I could start airway clearance, then I cleared as much in 5 rounds of breathing as I usually do in 10, and my chest felt good.

Cleaning according to directions was pretty easy - rinse (esp the screen) under flowing tap water, soak in soapy water, boil 5 minutes. I'm a little lazy, so I rinse and wash every day, only boil every 3rd use. I'm healthy right now, but if I have an exacerbation I'll boil it every time. I'm hoping this works for me, so when I travel in September & October it will be easy. I'm running on batteries and watching to see how well they last - I would like to get by without carrying the charger.

Would I buy it again? Since I have the patience of a cranky 3 year old, and have the means to do so, YES. We shall see how it lasts over time. Just the convenience for travel, which we do between 6 and 7 months per year, is wonderful. It is very small, quiet & lightweight with no hoses to manage - the first time I used it my husband didn't even know it was on.

By the way, when purchased from Nebology, it is significantly discounted right now and it comes with 2 power heads. Since each one lasts 6 months to a year, and costs about $100, that is a savings.

I'll report back in a few months.

Jump to this post

I will definitely try this. Thank you. have a lovely trip.

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

Reporting in on the Pari e-Flow after a week. It is FAST! it is SILENT! and the stream is STRONG! At this point (fingers crossed) I only neb 7% saline once a day. It takes - wait for it - 3 1/2 minutes!

The first time I tried it, I felt like a 7th grader trying their first cigarette - I was coughing from the first breath. Now I have figured out how to close my lips and tongue to slow the flow, so I get through the vial before I begin to cough. When it stopped and shut off after such a short time, I thought something was wrong, but I measured with a syringe and less than 1 ml was left - just as they said.

How did it feel afterwards? The first time I wasn't sure - I had such a coughing jag that it was 10 minutes before I could start airway clearance, then I cleared as much in 5 rounds of breathing as I usually do in 10, and my chest felt good.

Cleaning according to directions was pretty easy - rinse (esp the screen) under flowing tap water, soak in soapy water, boil 5 minutes. I'm a little lazy, so I rinse and wash every day, only boil every 3rd use. I'm healthy right now, but if I have an exacerbation I'll boil it every time. I'm hoping this works for me, so when I travel in September & October it will be easy. I'm running on batteries and watching to see how well they last - I would like to get by without carrying the charger.

Would I buy it again? Since I have the patience of a cranky 3 year old, and have the means to do so, YES. We shall see how it lasts over time. Just the convenience for travel, which we do between 6 and 7 months per year, is wonderful. It is very small, quiet & lightweight with no hoses to manage - the first time I used it my husband didn't even know it was on.

By the way, when purchased from Nebology, it is significantly discounted right now and it comes with 2 power heads. Since each one lasts 6 months to a year, and costs about $100, that is a savings.

I'll report back in a few months.

Jump to this post

I ordered same thing, however, they left out the cups and cord which they are sending to me. Looking forward to what I've heard is an awesome nebulizer.

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

Reporting in on the Pari e-Flow after a week. It is FAST! it is SILENT! and the stream is STRONG! At this point (fingers crossed) I only neb 7% saline once a day. It takes - wait for it - 3 1/2 minutes!

The first time I tried it, I felt like a 7th grader trying their first cigarette - I was coughing from the first breath. Now I have figured out how to close my lips and tongue to slow the flow, so I get through the vial before I begin to cough. When it stopped and shut off after such a short time, I thought something was wrong, but I measured with a syringe and less than 1 ml was left - just as they said.

How did it feel afterwards? The first time I wasn't sure - I had such a coughing jag that it was 10 minutes before I could start airway clearance, then I cleared as much in 5 rounds of breathing as I usually do in 10, and my chest felt good.

Cleaning according to directions was pretty easy - rinse (esp the screen) under flowing tap water, soak in soapy water, boil 5 minutes. I'm a little lazy, so I rinse and wash every day, only boil every 3rd use. I'm healthy right now, but if I have an exacerbation I'll boil it every time. I'm hoping this works for me, so when I travel in September & October it will be easy. I'm running on batteries and watching to see how well they last - I would like to get by without carrying the charger.

Would I buy it again? Since I have the patience of a cranky 3 year old, and have the means to do so, YES. We shall see how it lasts over time. Just the convenience for travel, which we do between 6 and 7 months per year, is wonderful. It is very small, quiet & lightweight with no hoses to manage - the first time I used it my husband didn't even know it was on.

By the way, when purchased from Nebology, it is significantly discounted right now and it comes with 2 power heads. Since each one lasts 6 months to a year, and costs about $100, that is a savings.

I'll report back in a few months.

Jump to this post

So glad to hear you like your new nebulizer and that's working well for you. Good tip about using the tongue to slow the flow. How do you do that exactly?

I will be interested in how long it works on battery power. When I tried it, it was not as long as I expected, but perhaps the batteries I used were not fresh. Running on AC power works well for me because the power cord is quite long.

REPLY
Profile picture for scoop @scoop

So glad to hear you like your new nebulizer and that's working well for you. Good tip about using the tongue to slow the flow. How do you do that exactly?

I will be interested in how long it works on battery power. When I tried it, it was not as long as I expected, but perhaps the batteries I used were not fresh. Running on AC power works well for me because the power cord is quite long.

Jump to this post

I'll let you know about the battery life.

Tomorrow I'll pay attention to how I use my tongue 👅 and try to describe it.

REPLY

Misty nebulizer - amazon - $49.99. Easy to use, & clean. Small, lots of mist. Comes with mouthpiece & 2 masks (one for child). Settings for 10 or 20 mins. Setting for 5 mins misting to pour boiling water into & clean. No noise, and it lasts through many uses before needing to be recharged. Cant believe I used a loud, cumbersome machine for 15 years before finding this handy nebulizer.

REPLY
In reply to @sarahlynn1960 "Is this the one?" + (show)
Profile picture for sarahlynn1960 @sarahlynn1960

Is this the one?

Jump to this post

Yes it is. I had to gulp and wait several days before I convinced myself to get it, but now I am glad. And it sterilizes beautifully on the stovetop.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.