DecisionDx-Melanoma (Castle test): When is it necessary?

Posted by birdman518 @birdman518, Nov 2, 2021

After having melanoma removed from my scalp in June, I had my first checkup today with my original dermatologist that found it. He mentioned that I might want to have a Castle test done. From reading about it on the company's website, it almost sounds as if it is for people who have *not* had a SNB and are trying to decide. I *did* have them and all came out clear.
It sounds like the Castle test does not really give much actionable information for someone like me. I am going to reach out to my surgeon (at Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa) to see what they say about it. So far they have said I am clear and only need to have quarterly checkups with my dermatologist like anyone else.
I would appreciate any comments or experiences....
Thanks,
Mitch

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Cancer Support Group.

@jenid

I’m so sorry that happened to you. Call the lab company and ask them if they have any low income program, something that will help you pay this bill. Some of these labs do and it might even cover the whole bill. Good luck.

Jump to this post

The bill shouldn't exist in the first place. I'm contesting the entire test.

REPLY
@teintnatural

The bill shouldn't exist in the first place. I'm contesting the entire test.

Jump to this post

Castle NEVER bills the patient. If insurance doesn't pay, Castle eats the bill. I work at a Skin Cancer clinic and order these tests often. It helps determine how bad the Melanoma is and risk of reoccurrence even if the SNB is clear; we still like to know how "high risk" you are.

REPLY

Mitch, we order the test on any Melanoma whose Breslow depth is above .6, regardless of SLB results. It helps determine how "high risk" you are for reoccurrence. We work very closely with Oncology and Castle never, ever bills the patient. If insurance does not pay; Castle eats the bill. It's a free test, for you - and there's no reason not to get it.

REPLY
@gingerw

@birdman518 I also have had melanoma surgery, but was not given any information on this test, nor the company.

It seems you need to look at your case specifically. Your age, what stage was the melanoma they removed, how deep was it, any post surgery treatment suggested by the surgeons. In regards to the Castle test, is this something your insurance will cover, or are you on the hook for it completely? If you need to pay for it, what is the cost and how accurate is it? Does your doctor have any other patients who did the test and were satisfied with the results?

Your plan to reach out to the surgeon sounds like a sound one, to me. Let me know what they say!
Ginger

Jump to this post

Ginger, what was your Breslow depth? You can request the test, if it was above .6 - it helps access the risk of reoccurence. But, some offices do not know about it or think it's useless. It's helped many of our patients.

REPLY

This is the "guidelines" we use when ordering Castle. It gives insight on how it helps your providers with your particular Melanoma case. If you've had 2 Melanomas within 2 months, you're at a higher risk and just because one SLB came back negative, doesn't mean it's not in another lymph node... or another Melanoma could potentially be spreading to another lymph node soon.

Again, the test is free for you & if insurance doesn't pay... Castle eats the bill. All it does it help your Dermatologist/Oncologist know your future risk.

Shared files

Castle Bioscience Melanoma Study (Castle-Bioscience-Melanoma-Study.pdf)

REPLY
@kalachappelear

Castle NEVER bills the patient. If insurance doesn't pay, Castle eats the bill. I work at a Skin Cancer clinic and order these tests often. It helps determine how bad the Melanoma is and risk of reoccurrence even if the SNB is clear; we still like to know how "high risk" you are.

Jump to this post

I finally got in touch with the Dermatology office - they told me that Castle should never have even submitted the bill to my insurance company, that Castle and the Dr. have their contracted agreement and anything I would have to pay comes out of my Dr.'s agreement with my insurance company and my co-pay. (basically an all-inclusive fee). But Castle never sent me a bill, and it still shows up on my insurance claim history as submitted and denied, and that my out of pocket cost is now $8500 more than it was.

REPLY

Castle always submits bills to insurance, but will never bill or expect you to pay if/when insurance denies. The doctor's office may not fully understand how Castle bills/gets paid. There's not technically a "contracted agreement" between Castle and any doctor's office. They have a rep that comes in that if you order, you order and if you don't - you don't. They don't even really offer contracts, to my knowledge. You can call Castle directly and get more information from them at 866-788-9007, option 3. But, you will never receive a bill from them regardless.

REPLY
@teintnatural

I got a notification from my health insurance company that there was a new claim. I checked it, and it was for this test - to the tune of $8500. I thought it was an decimal since any lab tests on my insurance are only an $85 co-pay. They denied the claim because it's not a coverable test. I just got a statement from Castle Biosciences explaining what this test is, and I looked it up. I never authorized this test. I had a melanoma. It was removed. My doctor sent it to have this test done without my authorization. It's still considered experimental - Medicare will cover up to $7193 of the $8500. However, I'm not old enough to qualify for Medicare yet. So it looks like my doctor stuck me with a test I didn't authorize, for something that isn't proven to be useful, and I'm going to be on the hook for $8500. Because it's not a coverable test, it doesn't even count toward my yearly out of pocket on my insurance.

I don't have $8500. I am on social security, three years away from being eligible for Medicare. If I gave them 100% of my social security check every month I'll be homeless, but I'll have the bill paid within a year. This is so bogus. I'm SO angry. No wonder old people have anxiety. And - if I was poor enough to qualify for a free lawyer, or rich enough to pay for one, I wouldn't be griping.

Jump to this post

The same exact thing just happened to my husband. Did you have any luck getting them to cancel the $8500 bill? We didn’t authorize this test! How can they do this?

REPLY
@yippyskippy2614

The same exact thing just happened to my husband. Did you have any luck getting them to cancel the $8500 bill? We didn’t authorize this test! How can they do this?

Jump to this post

See my last response in the thread. I never received a bill, it didn't actually exist.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.