Benign carcinoid tumor in bronchi tube

Posted by jessie1990 @jessie1990, Oct 30, 2025

Hi I've been diagnosed with a benign typical carcinoid tumor in my bronchi tube in right lung was found when I went to A&E with pneumonia back in July of this year I've had 2 bronchoscopys 2 biopys which showed benign carcinoid tumor I was sent for ct scan mri scan and pet scan pet scan was clear I was put under general anesthetic as my lung specialist said he might be able to remove tumor by going down my throat instead of haven surgery but didn't work but he was able to take 40% of tumor out as it was blocking my air way that's how pneumonia set in the 40% he removed also came back benign carcinoid 1 lymph node was removed and checked also clear now I need surgery to remove the rest I'm so confused as doctor said its a benign tumor then Google is telling me it's a low grade cancerous tumor but doctor nor lung specialist said anything about cancer just said its benign doesnt benign mean non cancerous and can any one tell me how surgery went thank you bless you all xx

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Neuroendocrine Tumors (NETs) Support Group.

Profile picture for Zebra @californiazebra

@tomrennie
Thank you for your input. Typical (grade 1) and atypical (grade 2) classifications are specific to lung NETs. Typical is the slowest growing and what I have. My Ki-67 is only 2%! That’s really slow growing. Typical carcinoids are less likely to spread than atypical. The Ki-67 for atypical is higher (usually over 5%). There is also a mitotic count used. Both Ki-67 and mitotic rate are methods of determining how many cancer cells are dividing but the two measurements are not equal. The lower the better on both.

I was thrilled to hear 2% since the Ki-67 for my very aggressive breast cancer tumor was 50%. I’m telling you this to give some perspective on how slow growing typical lung carcinoids are. The Ki-67 percentage of carcinoids doesn’t generally go as high as some other cancers. Keep in mind that all cancers are not created equal. Typical carcinoids are very treatable. I’m doing very well on octreotide injections even though both lungs are filled with carcinoids. I’m even doing very well with my recurrent breast cancer. Medical advances are happening all the time. I know the unknown is scary, but please try to assume the best because I believe it will all turn out better than you think.

Jump to this post

@californiazebra thank you I'm really hoping so just super scared

REPLY
Profile picture for Turkey, Volunteer Mentor @tomrennie

@jessie1990 My net tumors were never classified as typical or atypical. The growth rate of my pnets are measured on a ki-67 grading scale. I am unaware of any instances where the growth rate changes. Lymph node involvement usually begins near the primary tumor. I agree with your logic that if a nearby lymph node was benign, then anything further away should be the same. This is an example of why a specialist is really important. Please keep trying. We are fortunate to have the input of @californiazebra. She will help you ask more specific questions about lung carcinoids during your next appointment.

Jump to this post

@tomrennie hi lung nurse rang me today said it will be around middle of Dec I'm looking at for surgery as surgeon is away for awhile and it's very unlikely the part that is left is going to atypical because the portion the removed was quite big that came back as typical make sure I keep up walking and stuff before surgery it will help me wit recovery

REPLY
Profile picture for Zebra @californiazebra

@tomrennie
Thank you for your input. Typical (grade 1) and atypical (grade 2) classifications are specific to lung NETs. Typical is the slowest growing and what I have. My Ki-67 is only 2%! That’s really slow growing. Typical carcinoids are less likely to spread than atypical. The Ki-67 for atypical is higher (usually over 5%). There is also a mitotic count used. Both Ki-67 and mitotic rate are methods of determining how many cancer cells are dividing but the two measurements are not equal. The lower the better on both.

I was thrilled to hear 2% since the Ki-67 for my very aggressive breast cancer tumor was 50%. I’m telling you this to give some perspective on how slow growing typical lung carcinoids are. The Ki-67 percentage of carcinoids doesn’t generally go as high as some other cancers. Keep in mind that all cancers are not created equal. Typical carcinoids are very treatable. I’m doing very well on octreotide injections even though both lungs are filled with carcinoids. I’m even doing very well with my recurrent breast cancer. Medical advances are happening all the time. I know the unknown is scary, but please try to assume the best because I believe it will all turn out better than you think.

Jump to this post

@californiazebra Thank you for the education. So my 8% ki-67 score would be considered atypical? I agree with the typical being very treatable. That is actually great news for @jessie1990 .

REPLY
Profile picture for jessie1990 @jessie1990

@tomrennie hi lung nurse rang me today said it will be around middle of Dec I'm looking at for surgery as surgeon is away for awhile and it's very unlikely the part that is left is going to atypical because the portion the removed was quite big that came back as typical make sure I keep up walking and stuff before surgery it will help me wit recovery

Jump to this post

@jessie1990 I am glad that they responded. Did they give you a referral for the NET specialist? You have a little time before the surgeon is available in December. A second opinion in your case can only help ease your concerns. Walking is a great idea. I have been coached many times by my docs to never stop moving. I go for walks every day.

REPLY
Profile picture for Turkey, Volunteer Mentor @tomrennie

@californiazebra Thank you for the education. So my 8% ki-67 score would be considered atypical? I agree with the typical being very treatable. That is actually great news for @jessie1990 .

Jump to this post

@tomrennie nurse said there's strong evidence there also that it is typical carcinoid and I will not need other trearment such as chemo I will need regular scans

REPLY
Profile picture for nannybb @nannybb

Oh, he said he knew all about this type of cancer. And he went into great detail in explaining it to me. I also saw a pulmonary specialist first. It is the "slight" deception I am having with.

Jump to this post

@nannybb But is he a NET specialist? Also, what do you mean by "slight deception "?

REPLY
Profile picture for Turkey, Volunteer Mentor @tomrennie

@jessie1990 I am glad that they responded. Did they give you a referral for the NET specialist? You have a little time before the surgeon is available in December. A second opinion in your case can only help ease your concerns. Walking is a great idea. I have been coached many times by my docs to never stop moving. I go for walks every day.

Jump to this post

@tomrennie I haven't mentioned that to her totally forgot to ask actually I will give her a ring tomorrow and ask yes I'm just hoping I'm home in time for Xmas with the kiddies yes I walk every where also I use be a gym freak for while stopped going over all this going on but looking to go back once all this is over

REPLY
Profile picture for jessie1990 @jessie1990

@californiazebra thank you I'm really hoping so just super scared

Jump to this post

@jessie1990 It is super scary. That is completely understandable. Don't beat yourself up over it too much though. I have tried. Not only does it not work, it is bad for your health. The more anxious that I become, the worse I feel. I had to learn this the hard way. Again, much easier said than done.

REPLY
Profile picture for Turkey, Volunteer Mentor @tomrennie

@nannybb But is he a NET specialist? Also, what do you mean by "slight deception "?

Jump to this post

He is a cancer specialist who told me he knew all about carcinoid tumors. He never mentioned them as "NETS" and I had never seen it in all my reading about this type of lung cancer.
I had a problem with seeing the post-op X-ray stating it was done for a benign tumor. That made no sense to me.
When I asked about it, he said it had to be listed that way for insurance to pay. To my way of thinking, that is backwards
First off, I was told to have surgery because the tumor had started growing. I just don't understand why it would be listed as benign. He had done a biopsy, so he should have known at that time. All he said was the biopsy showed it was cancer.

REPLY
Profile picture for jessie1990 @jessie1990

@nannybb yes I'm so confused I really don't no what's going on ive asked my surgeon that will be removing my tumor is it benign he said yes it's benign I've had 2 biopys from 2 different hospitals both benign my pet scan came back clear it's just so confusing

Jump to this post

@jessie1990 My PET came back showing no further CA, but at my post-op he stated there were three more tumors that he wants to watch to see if they start growing. I do not believe they were found on the PET scan....possibly in the X-ray.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.