Afib and heart failure

Posted by katiekateny @katiekateny, Dec 29, 2024

My EP as told me to stop taking Flecainide and metoprolol.

I have been reading over these last several months. It seems that my heart failure is because of the walls (muscle) thickening. Once this begins it is progressive.

My cardiologist has run me through every test/procedure that exists…no reason for heart failure has been found other than it seems that Afib was the original cause of the “remodeling”

So, it seems to me that stopping Afib (slowing it down, stop for a while, whatever) would be critical. Then, why does EP think it is ok for me to stop flecainide and metoprolol?

I have a watchman implant that was successful…so risk of stroke is no more….but…while stroke is the biggest short term risk…what about this on going remodeling?

Anyone shed some light on this?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Heart Rhythm Conditions Support Group.

@lindy9

Add to my post, and I apologize for the length. My friends aunt was diagnosed with stomach cancer at age 80. She was told that she needed an operation, chemo and radiation. She said No!

They told her it was her only hope or she would die soon. She lived 12 more years. A friend had breast cancer. She did it all, lost her hair, and spent the last year of her life in doc office, hospital, etc. until she died. She like many others I know ended up saying, if they could do it over again, she would not have gone that route.

Jump to this post

@lindy9
We all have to do what we think is best for you.

What works and is best for one person is based on their own decisions not someone elses.

I know for me I go to Mayo Jacksonville. All the doctors who care for me do so as a team. So my experience with medical institutions is different from yours. That does not change your experience and your feelings.

I have had probably 6 basal cells and on squamous cell cancers removed. They do a MOHS surgery which takes the minimal amount of tissue out and then pathologist looks at margins. If the margins are free of cancer then nothing further if does show more tissue taken and then again back to pathologist.

Out of the six only one required additional tissue taken. How much have I paid for this outstanding service, 0$. Now I say not paid but I do pay for Medicare insurance and a secondary insurance.

If you read my post I only post my experience and will always say you have to do what is best for you both mentally and physically.

Your decisions are your decisions and what is best for you.

REPLY
@jc76

@elewis203
I know many other health facilities will give second opinions after sending medical information to them. I did this with UFHPTI. I am a Mayo patient but wanted a second opinion. Mayo sent my medical information to UFHPTI (must sign consent forms but UFHPTI handled it).

I then got a second opinion from them in person.

Not sure which Mayo Clinic you live closest to but call them. Also consider Cleveland Clinic another outstanding heart specialty clinic.

Jump to this post

Thanks for your reply. We live in Menlo Park, California (10 minutes from Stanford Hospital) and there isn't a Mayo Clinic nearby.
I'm going to Call Mayo Clinic and ask if they will give a 2nd opinion, using all the testing from Stanford. My husband is not strong enough to travel.

REPLY
@lindy9

Thank you for your concern, however.... 1 I have been reading for months the comments on this blog, what people experience with the meds and treatments. Some work, some for awhile, and the side effects of the meds. What goes on with the treatments, and no thanks. 2 I now live in another country for over 10 years, and they have what are considered excellent docs etc.

Although there are different names for the heart beat problems, I had serious episodes for 7 years from age 14=21, and learned some people are extremely sensitive to caffeine. I quit and did not have problems until age 75 when I was eating coffee ice cream made in the US, and realized that was the problem. Since then have had minor issues.

I will make some add'l changes and see what happens. Was talking to my sister last night and she and her husband had gone to docs and they did umpteen tests and said they could find nothing. That is why I don't go. Been there and done that.

I am not interested in spending the rest of my life having tests, reactions to meds which I always have, and yucky treatments. I know how they do in the US surrounded by teams. If I would have something done it would be here. Nine years ago, I had a cancer on my cheek. He examined it, opened a book and showed me the type I had, and dug a small hole to remove all the same time, and was healed and cannot tell I had a problem. The whole procedure with antibiotics cost equal to $140. In the US there would have been visits and team of doctors and bills and stress.

I could write a book on the ridiculous experiences I have had with docs that did not help. We are all different, but for me, knowledge, habit and diet changes to get rid of the root of the problem, and prayer work for me. We will all die of something, but for me it will not be because of drug reactions, icky treatments, teams of doctors, or in the hospital, and I have seen what occurs there in the US and here.

Jump to this post

So are we supposed to die because you say to stay away from meds and doctors???

REPLY
@lindy9

Thank you for your concern, however.... 1 I have been reading for months the comments on this blog, what people experience with the meds and treatments. Some work, some for awhile, and the side effects of the meds. What goes on with the treatments, and no thanks. 2 I now live in another country for over 10 years, and they have what are considered excellent docs etc.

Although there are different names for the heart beat problems, I had serious episodes for 7 years from age 14=21, and learned some people are extremely sensitive to caffeine. I quit and did not have problems until age 75 when I was eating coffee ice cream made in the US, and realized that was the problem. Since then have had minor issues.

I will make some add'l changes and see what happens. Was talking to my sister last night and she and her husband had gone to docs and they did umpteen tests and said they could find nothing. That is why I don't go. Been there and done that.

I am not interested in spending the rest of my life having tests, reactions to meds which I always have, and yucky treatments. I know how they do in the US surrounded by teams. If I would have something done it would be here. Nine years ago, I had a cancer on my cheek. He examined it, opened a book and showed me the type I had, and dug a small hole to remove all the same time, and was healed and cannot tell I had a problem. The whole procedure with antibiotics cost equal to $140. In the US there would have been visits and team of doctors and bills and stress.

I could write a book on the ridiculous experiences I have had with docs that did not help. We are all different, but for me, knowledge, habit and diet changes to get rid of the root of the problem, and prayer work for me. We will all die of something, but for me it will not be because of drug reactions, icky treatments, teams of doctors, or in the hospital, and I have seen what occurs there in the US and here.

Jump to this post

While I am a nurse and have worked in the medical field for over 40 years, I certainly can appreciate your point of view. You are so right about the US approach to everything--a "team" with everyone having their own expertise and often not working in conjunction with each other. It really takes someone who is highly invested in their own issues to do diligent research to make sure they know their options in treatment. So many patients are either too trusting or too intimidated to speak up regarding their treatment options. You are also correct about medications; a smart cardiologist once told my husband that "all medication is really a poison" and that the "benefits" had to override the side effects to make them worth taking. This doc was highly against statins (they were very new then) and encouraged lifestyle changes as the "cure" for high cholesterol. While we tried the "seaweed and bark" (joking) diet plan, my husband's cholesterol problem was more genetic than purely dietary and the endocrinologist that finally ordered a statin for him really did save his life. It is a combination of things in the end. It is the desire to live a better quality of life. My nurse friend's father took her non-medical sister in the ambulance with him during his heart attack because he knew she would let him smoke one last cigarette on the way! As for me, after one A-fib experience that lasted 6 weeks before I could safely get cardioversion, I have done everything on the list to reduce my chances of reoccurrence except change my age! No caffeine, chocolate, alcohol, heavy meals; exercise daily as I did before, lost 10 pounds (even though I wasn't overweight), sleep improvement with attention to the position I sleep in. I take the meds and hope to heaven they work and so far I have no side effects, luckily! We all will die of something as you said, so it is quality of life in the time we have left that matters! As my husband said years ago after his heart attack--when he quit smoking cold turkey and began exercising and eating more healthy foods, "I'm not willing to die for a pork chop!" I loved your comments; unfortunately, Americans are much more willing to want a pill/treatment for their "condition" than to do the things they can do for themselves.

REPLY
@elewis203

Is it possible to get a 2nd opinion from Mayo Clinic with only sending test information (from another teaching hospital, Stanford)?
My husband had open heart surgery at Mayo in 2012 and is having shortness of breath, diagnosed as needing a new aortic valve. Stanford is moving at a snail's pace and he needs help right away.
I would appreciate any thoughts.

Jump to this post

@elewis203, if you would like to seek a second opinion from Mayo Clinic cardiology experts, you can submit a request here: http://mayocl.in/1mtmR63

REPLY

I encourage members to review the Community Guidelines https://connect.mayoclinic.org/blog/about-connect/tab/community-guidelines/

These Community Guidelines offer 12 short rules of conduct that help keep the Mayo Clinic Connect community safe, supportive, inclusive, and respectful.

Most importantly, I like to underline
- Experiences and information shared by members on the Mayo Clinic Connect are not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.
- Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on the community.
- Exercise tolerance and respect toward other participants whose views may differ from your own.

You can report any message that require attention of the moderating team by clicking the 3 dots (…) to the bottom right of the message.

REPLY
@bettycll

I have been told there are two types of heart failure: systolic and diastolic. When EF is low, the HF is systolic.

In my case, I have adequate EF, but I have been told that my heart is "thickening" and I have diastolic HF.

To circle back to the original question by katieketeny (who also has thickening), I am taking both Flecainide and metoprolol; both of which are prescribed by my EP and my cardiologist. I do not have a HF specialist.

While I have had AFib several times in the past (currently in NSR), no one has told me that AF could have caused this thickening, so I find that very interesting. FYI... I have been on Xarelto since my first instance of AF.

I have been wondering about this diagnosis of diastolic heart failure and what could have caused it since my EF is over 60. I am also concerned that it could be progressive.

Any information on Diastolic Heart Failure would be helpful. Thanks!

Jump to this post

@bettycll, heart failure can be confusing. You might be interested in this related discussion where Mayo Clinic cardiologist explains:
- Confused about Stiff Heart, Diastolic Heart Failure, or HFpEF? https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/confused-about-stiff-heart-diastolic-heart-failure-or-hfpef/

I'll also post his video here where he explains
Dr. Farris Timimi, a Mayo Clinic cardiologist and heart failure specialist, describes the phenomenon of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction, in which the heart has difficulty filling before pumping.

REPLY
@sjm46

While I am a nurse and have worked in the medical field for over 40 years, I certainly can appreciate your point of view. You are so right about the US approach to everything--a "team" with everyone having their own expertise and often not working in conjunction with each other. It really takes someone who is highly invested in their own issues to do diligent research to make sure they know their options in treatment. So many patients are either too trusting or too intimidated to speak up regarding their treatment options. You are also correct about medications; a smart cardiologist once told my husband that "all medication is really a poison" and that the "benefits" had to override the side effects to make them worth taking. This doc was highly against statins (they were very new then) and encouraged lifestyle changes as the "cure" for high cholesterol. While we tried the "seaweed and bark" (joking) diet plan, my husband's cholesterol problem was more genetic than purely dietary and the endocrinologist that finally ordered a statin for him really did save his life. It is a combination of things in the end. It is the desire to live a better quality of life. My nurse friend's father took her non-medical sister in the ambulance with him during his heart attack because he knew she would let him smoke one last cigarette on the way! As for me, after one A-fib experience that lasted 6 weeks before I could safely get cardioversion, I have done everything on the list to reduce my chances of reoccurrence except change my age! No caffeine, chocolate, alcohol, heavy meals; exercise daily as I did before, lost 10 pounds (even though I wasn't overweight), sleep improvement with attention to the position I sleep in. I take the meds and hope to heaven they work and so far I have no side effects, luckily! We all will die of something as you said, so it is quality of life in the time we have left that matters! As my husband said years ago after his heart attack--when he quit smoking cold turkey and began exercising and eating more healthy foods, "I'm not willing to die for a pork chop!" I loved your comments; unfortunately, Americans are much more willing to want a pill/treatment for their "condition" than to do the things they can do for themselves.

Jump to this post

am curious about this one statement that you made - "my husband's cholesterol problem was more genetic than purely dietary and the endocrinologist that finally ordered a statin for him really did save his life. "

1 how high was his cholesterol?
2 what symptoms did he have with the high cholesterol?
3 being genetic, the parent or person who had before him, what happened?

REPLY
@colleenyoung

@bettycll, heart failure can be confusing. You might be interested in this related discussion where Mayo Clinic cardiologist explains:
- Confused about Stiff Heart, Diastolic Heart Failure, or HFpEF? https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/confused-about-stiff-heart-diastolic-heart-failure-or-hfpef/

I'll also post his video here where he explains
Dr. Farris Timimi, a Mayo Clinic cardiologist and heart failure specialist, describes the phenomenon of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction, in which the heart has difficulty filling before pumping.

Jump to this post

Hi Colleen - THANK YOU for this message (by the way, I started a reply earlier and lost it - so if you get two replies, that is why). I found Dr. Timimi's explanation very helpful. Another individual indicated that AFib was a factor (I do have AFib, but am currently in NSR). I also experience shortness of breath - can't climb a staircase without huffing and puffing, nor walk up a hill. I did not realize that this diastolic heart failure could be a cause for my SOB, since I also have CLL and other issues. NO ONE seems to be familiar with this, and I SO appreciate the information! Heart failure is generally considered when EF is 20 or 25. Mine is 64. My doctor says age is a factor. If that is so, why do I not hear of it frequently? There are many of us over 70! Thanks again for the information. I would love to hear from others who have been diagnosed with thickening or diastolic heart failure and hear what they do and how they manage it. My doctor is recommending Jardiance. I am a bit concerned because I am not diabetic. As you can see, I have lots of questions and concerns, so I appreciate any information.

REPLY
@bettycll

Hi Colleen - THANK YOU for this message (by the way, I started a reply earlier and lost it - so if you get two replies, that is why). I found Dr. Timimi's explanation very helpful. Another individual indicated that AFib was a factor (I do have AFib, but am currently in NSR). I also experience shortness of breath - can't climb a staircase without huffing and puffing, nor walk up a hill. I did not realize that this diastolic heart failure could be a cause for my SOB, since I also have CLL and other issues. NO ONE seems to be familiar with this, and I SO appreciate the information! Heart failure is generally considered when EF is 20 or 25. Mine is 64. My doctor says age is a factor. If that is so, why do I not hear of it frequently? There are many of us over 70! Thanks again for the information. I would love to hear from others who have been diagnosed with thickening or diastolic heart failure and hear what they do and how they manage it. My doctor is recommending Jardiance. I am a bit concerned because I am not diabetic. As you can see, I have lots of questions and concerns, so I appreciate any information.

Jump to this post

Betty, you may appreciate this related discussion:
- Jardiance for congestive heart failure: pros and cons https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/jardiance-for-chf/

@bettycll, I wonder if you might benefit from specialty care called cadio-oncology?

Mayo Clinic offers expertise in addressing heart problems (called cardio-oncology), potential or current issues. The Cardio-Oncology Clinic (https://www.mayoclinic.org/departments-centers/cardio-oncology-clinic/overview/ovc-20442193) evaluates people prior to cancer treatment and patients who have experienced side effects due their treatment.

Is your cancer care team in close communication with your cardiology care? Might they have a cardio-oncology specialist where you receive care?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.