R-ALA, Why do neurologists not prescribe this medication/supplement?

Posted by bigjohnscho @bigjohnscho, Jul 18 7:17am

I have been reading about how R-ALA and its benefits works for peripheral neuropathy.It seems that every article recommends its use.
Why then do practically every neurologist/doctor advise against its use. Am I missing something obvious. I am told it is often prescribed elsewhere e.g. Germany.
John

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Neuropathy Support Group.

I don’t believe there are any pier reviewed studies showing ALA working for neuropathy. Some countries in Europe use an IV solution of ALA. However, you might experience a placebo effect, which is great! As long as you think you are feeling better, then you are feeling better!

REPLY

There is no clinical study demonstrating the superiority of the R isomer over the combined RS iso forms of ALA. That said, experimental data suggest that the R isomer is more bioavailable. The best results to date have been obtained with intravenous dosing. ConsumerLab, the most respected third-party tester of nutritional supplements in the world, has made the Life Extension product its top pick if you want a pure R iso form of ALA. Take on an empty stomach with lecithin to enhance bioavailability.

REPLY
Profile picture for crossette @crossette

Just FYI, Alpha Lipoic Acid was first described for neuropathy in a German paper so that is probably why it is more common in Europe. I tried it for a year but it made no difference in my tingling and numbness in my feet. But my condition was caused by a crushed L3 disc in an accident years ago. People with idiopathic (unknown cause) neuropathy may respond differently.

Jump to this post

@crossette
I have neuropathy in my feet due to "silent" celiac disease. Even before getting this diagnosis I began using Windmill R-ALA supplement starting in winter 2025. I believe it has helped me. I am able to do physical activity and I have had no side effects due to it. My neurologist knows that I am taking this as well as other supplements to help dealing with this autoimmune disorder. But you should definitely speak to your physician--primary care or specialist before starting with it.

REPLY
Profile picture for debbieod @debbieod

Every doctor I see recommends R-ala. . I read many forums and also groups on FB. I see this supplement being recommended to most people who see a neurologist.

Jump to this post

@debbieod My Neurologist recommended ALA at an extremely low dose. I took it upon myself to use the R-ALA form. I'm almost through the first container which basically covers 30 days and I haven't experienced any improvement. I have other issues (polymyalgia rheuatica, for example) and I'm beginning to think that idiopathic small fiber neuropathy may be a misdiagnosis. I take 300 mg. Gabapentin at bedtime. I'll keep trying to figure this all out.

REPLY

What is the difference between ala and r-ala?
Any best brand recommendations?

REPLY

It is my understanding that there are 3 ALAs and R-ALA is 100% the real thing.

REPLY

It has been prescribed in Germany since 1960s. The US FDA has done little research into it. Germany uses the IV version not the pills so much. Since, it is over the counter the neurologist don’t know that much. It injured both my kidneys. What is sold in the US is different from Germany.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10718205/

REPLY
Profile picture for amota @amota

It is my understanding that there are 3 ALAs and R-ALA is 100% the real thing.

Jump to this post

@amota I think the R means full acid? that's why the combo might be better for your stomach if you have acid problems.

REPLY
Profile picture for maggiem7 @maggiem7

What is the difference between ala and r-ala?
Any best brand recommendations?

Jump to this post

@maggiem7
Make sure all supplements are 3rd Party Tested -all reputable companies state it!

REPLY
Profile picture for gnocchi @gnocchi

@amota I think the R means full acid? that's why the combo might be better for your stomach if you have acid problems.

Jump to this post

@gnocchi You are right. Actually, I haven't have any issue with my stomach.
Thank you, your message is helpful.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.