Annual Physicals

Posted by texasguy1962 @texasguy1962, 4 days ago

Just curious... my old doctor, and every doctor before her, would administer an in-depth physical exam every year. Look into your eyes, ears, throat, check your belly, heart, lungs, and then, of course, the finger as big as a salt shaker. When you were finished, you pretty much knew if you were healthy or not.
Now, the last 2 doctors I have been to for annuals do this: Ask you how you feel. Listen to your heart and lungs. Send you for bloodwork. That's it. Nothing more. Is this how medicine works now? Unless it shows up in the blood, then everything is fine? I agree, asking me how I feel is a good question, but I'm probably not going to think about 6 or 8 months ago when I woke up throwing up, or maybe pooped something weird, or something like that.
Is medicine today is basically "If you feel okay then you must be okay"?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Men's Health Support Group.

Profile picture for bwjb @bwjb

For 30 years my annual physicals would start with me stripped to my boxer shorts, which my doctor eventually would have me drop at the end to check for testicular cancer, check for hernia and perform the DRE. Then my doctor retired. My current PCP, not a young man either, doesn't even have me take off my shirt to listen to my heart. In the time that it would take to check for testicular cancer, he recites that the US Preventive Services Task Force no longer suggest that be done. When I ask him to check to see if my right inguinal hernia has gotten worse, he does so grudgingly saying if it isn't symptomatic it doesn't need being done, even though my surgical history says a hernia on the left side required surgical repair. Instead of a physical exam, as part of the annual Medicare wellness exam, his nurse has me draw a clock face as part of a cognitive test! My current doctor has seen me naked in the locker room at the gym that I go to, so I don't think he thinks I am too modest for a thorough exam. I can't believe how much the annual physical has changed. I'm tempted to search for an old school doctor nearer retirement age.

Jump to this post

@bwjb Thats all my doctor does is talk take blood pressure, look in my ears.

REPLY

Medicare reform (The Affordable Care Act aka Obama Care) is the reason for the change in your annual history and physical (H&P) which has morphed into the Annual Wellness Exam. Medicare changed the way they pay claims for outpatient provider services to consider wellness efforts as a way to improve our health as opposed to doing a certain set of blood work, chest x-ray, EKG every year that were normal. If you have problems that you’re receiving medications for or that you see the doctor for regularly then Medicare felt they were wasting money paying for the annual H&P. Most Family Medicine and Internal Medicine providers are part of a larger group practicing under the ACA. There is a coding process that goes into the billing process that codes claims in a manner that supports Medicare initiatives to reduce costs. Essentially the healthier your doctor can keep you the better their scores are which leads to practice bonus payments at the end of the federal fiscal year.
Remember I’m only speaking about Medicare aged people not younger ones.
I’ve never had any heart related illness or symptoms so I haven’t had an EKG in over six or seven years. Same with a chest x-ray. I don’t need them if I don’t have symptoms. It’s a new way era of Medicine. Most younger doctors don’t use the stethoscope you might expect to see a hospital doctor using. Electronics has taken over and many younger doctors might not even lay a hand on you from what I’ve heard listening to XMSirrus Doctor Radio. They’d rather depend on test results.

REPLY

Good luck reaching anyone who you saw in the practice on weekends.
There were once doctors on call 24/7.
Now go for pot luck in an ER.

REPLY
Profile picture for seniormed @seniormed

Good luck reaching anyone who you saw in the practice on weekends.
There were once doctors on call 24/7.
Now go for pot luck in an ER.

Jump to this post

@seniormed
Yuuup So True

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.