Drug holiday between Reclast and more powerful bone medications

Posted by tillymack @tillymack, Sep 11, 2025

I've been receiving Reclast for the last 4 years after decades of Evista, both for the treatment of osteopenia/osteoporosis/osteopenia. The last DEXA scan was somewhat disappointing as 2 of the 3 regions dipped slightly. I'm more concerned than I would normally be due to the recent discovery of moderate scoliosis.
My endocrinologist is willing to switch to Evenity, Tymlos, or Prolia BUT would require that I stop Reclast and then wait 1-2 years with NO treatment before starting one of these 3 medications. This is called a drug holiday. Is this the usual way to transition from one drug to another? Do I need to seek a second opinion?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for misst1970 @misst1970

I believe that you have to allow the bisphosphonates to wear off to gain the benefits of the anabolic drugs. My osteoporosis doc had me start with Tymlos as he noted it’s not as effective if on a bisphosphonate immediately prior (i believe they “coat” the bone, which blunts the effect of the anabolic). After my two years on Tymlos I then did a reclast infusion. I will have two more annual reclast infusions and then do a drug holiday for several years. They will test my bone markers and when it starts to show a decline I will then start the next drug (yet TBD). My sister is on a bisohosphonate as well, her osteo doc is having her do five years max on it (note it’s not as powerful as reclast - I was told five years of Fosomax or 3 annual reclast infusions). She then has a 3-5 year drug holiday then will go back on the bisphosphonate when her bone markers start to decline. Too much continuous time on bisphosphonate has been found they become less effective and can cause other issues such as brittle bones and atypical fractures. All of the drugs can cause issues with continuous use over a certain number of years. Drug holidays are becoming more common as they have found drugs like Reclast remain in your system for many years. I would ensure your doc is testing however so you can monitor when it’s time to start the next treatment. I believe they commonly want at least a year off bisphosphonates to gain the benefits of the anabolics like Tymlos, Forteo and (from what I understand 3 years after reclast or 2 after a daily bisphosphonate are pretty common). Evenity may be in my future someday, we discussed how I would need to wait at least a year after bisphosphonates (likely at least 2 or 3 after Reclast to receive the most benefit from the drug). The timing and order of the drugs is incredibly important. I would be cautious doing more time on Reclast. Drug holidays have become more common lately as numerous studies are now showing the bisphosphonates build up in your system and can take five+ years to fully clear as well as the issues they are finding with continuous use. If you inquire with your osteo doc as to the reasoning he can likely explain why and share some of the studies with you

Jump to this post

Thanks for the great info.

REPLY
Profile picture for tillymack @tillymack

Thanks very much for your reply!
I treated osteopenia with Evista for decades then sought help from an endocrinologist when my results slipped into osteoporosis territory. My endocrinologist chose Reclast at that time. My options are to continue with Reclast for 2 more years for a total of 6 treatments OR switch to a more powerful medication BUT that would require a 1-2 year drug holiday.
As someone suggested, I Googled my problem and found the article: Taking a break from osteoporosis medicine: What you need to know
Based on what I learned from this article, I'm considering completing the 6 year Reclast to avoid a drug holiday at this time due to my moderate scoliosis with t7 wedge fracture and t10 rotation.

Jump to this post

I'm doubting that any of the really knowledgeable osteoporosis docs would suggest taking 6 years of Reclast. I'm guessing that you have not had your CTX scores checked regularly while taking Reclast. If one does that you can skip the simplistic formula of take Reclast every year for 3 years and then take a holiday. Tracking your bone markers and having annual DXA's can enable you to know when you would actually need another Reclast infusion.
I believe others have already stated that taking time off from Reclast would help one get benefit from a bone builder. Reclast is probably the drug that would most limit the effectiveness of a bone builder med. Anyone know of an actual study of that?

REPLY

I did Tymlos I just finished my FOURTH and hopeful final Reclast infusion today. Now what? My Endro practice is constantly hiring new docs and firing and they are so hard to get into…

REPLY
Profile picture for loriesco @loriesco

I just found out that my DEXA results were not as hoped. 1.3% increase over the hoped for 6.8% increase.
But tangentially, I found out I am insulin-resistant now. Lookie there! A big connection with that and diabetes slowing down the response to the medications. Why do WE have to be our own doctors?! do your research ladies!

Jump to this post

@loriesco what medication are you on, did it cause the insulin resistance

REPLY
Profile picture for mangos @mangos

@loriesco what medication are you on, did it cause the insulin resistance

Jump to this post

@mangos I am on a variety of medication’s and/or supplements. So I’m not sure what you’re after by asking the question. However, none of it caused the insulin resistance. Insulin resistance is genetic/hereditary. I did a great job for 40 years, but my age went out. It’s actually kinda nice to be on the insulin resistance medicine metformin because now I can eat a little bit of sugar. Things changed dramatically after menopause and a little bit of sugar is good to avoid dehydration, along with a touch of salt. Neither I could eat for 40 years. Now it’s kind of mandatory. I have a little bit because I stay active and it’s easy to dehydrate when you lose your muscle mass. When I was young, I did not believe in supplements, but I took care of my dad and over the years. I got to understand that age plays apart of your body no longer being able to digest properly. The things you put into it. So now I play in the supplements and there are specific ones which were very helpful. Vitamin D was amazing at bringing down the A1c for the last 15 years. Periodically, I had to increase it. I might be due for an increase again. I take vitamin code for women over 50 and for me HEME iron is a major player because I have always had anemia of one form or another. B12’s are critical to as they aid in iron absorption and other supplements being absorbed properly. Our bodies are well oiled machines, and when the oil can runs dry, we have to refill it and sometimes change the formula!

REPLY
Profile picture for mangos @mangos

Thank you for that.

Jump to this post

@mangos
Could you expand on your message regarding "I just found out that my DEXA results were not as hoped. 1.3% increase over the hoped for 6.8% increase". I may be thinking of someone else so please excuse me if I've got this all wrong. Were you taking Tymlos with or without HRT and hoping for better DEXA scan results?

REPLY
Profile picture for awfultruth @awfultruth

I'm doubting that any of the really knowledgeable osteoporosis docs would suggest taking 6 years of Reclast. I'm guessing that you have not had your CTX scores checked regularly while taking Reclast. If one does that you can skip the simplistic formula of take Reclast every year for 3 years and then take a holiday. Tracking your bone markers and having annual DXA's can enable you to know when you would actually need another Reclast infusion.
I believe others have already stated that taking time off from Reclast would help one get benefit from a bone builder. Reclast is probably the drug that would most limit the effectiveness of a bone builder med. Anyone know of an actual study of that?

Jump to this post

@awfultruth none of my docs, even Endo’s do bone markers, so I don’t know how I’d get that done, how is that more helpful than a dextra. I was on Reclast 3 years, came off for tooth extraction, improved scores while on Reclast, had a bone scan after 18months off of Recast when dental work done, and my scores had gone back to almost pre- Reclast treatment, Endo just said everyone if different, but I know Reclast is supposed to stay in your bones for those having a drug holiday, but mine didn’t, I don’t understood

REPLY
Profile picture for lbets @lbets

I did Tymlos I just finished my FOURTH and hopeful final Reclast infusion today. Now what? My Endro practice is constantly hiring new docs and firing and they are so hard to get into…

Jump to this post

@lbets my Endo recommended Forteo, then Recast for another 3 and I’d already had 3 years of Recast, then drug holiday. The Endo did not mention Tymlos, why was that one chosen, if you don’t mind telling me

REPLY
Profile picture for tillymack @tillymack

@mangos
Could you expand on your message regarding "I just found out that my DEXA results were not as hoped. 1.3% increase over the hoped for 6.8% increase". I may be thinking of someone else so please excuse me if I've got this all wrong. Were you taking Tymlos with or without HRT and hoping for better DEXA scan results?

Jump to this post

@tillymack that was not me, but I would be interested in knowing how you did on Tymlos, if it was without HRT

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.