Have you been told no to hrt if you are 10+ years post menopause?

Posted by gravity3 @gravity3, May 16, 2024

Starting hrt 10 years post menopause and the flawed Women's health initiative study.
I have been told no and yet the current findings seem to indicate that hrt can still help.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for health77 @health77

Don’t worry about it!! Words from another 77 year old!! Enjoy it totally! I have used estrogen for years!! I live in Europe and estrogen has not been refused by doctors here. They never even heard if the pathetic WHI that was such a total failure and frightened every woman in the USA for more than 30 years.

Jump to this post

You’re a clever woman indeed!

REPLY
Profile picture for health77 @health77

Don’t worry about it!! Words from another 77 year old!! Enjoy it totally! I have used estrogen for years!! I live in Europe and estrogen has not been refused by doctors here. They never even heard if the pathetic WHI that was such a total failure and frightened every woman in the USA for more than 30 years.

Jump to this post

This is so interesting that doctors in Europe didn't follow the flawed WHI results. I wasn't aware of this. I sure wish I had been living in Europe 15 years ago!

REPLY
Profile picture for bayhorse @bayhorse

@dvargo, I thought any type of estrogen meant risk, even in cream form. Can you tell me where you got your info that there's no stroke risk with cream? I'd really appreciate!
Thanks...

Jump to this post

I just watched this video today from Dr. Susan. She talks specifically about estrogen risk. You may find it helpful

REPLY

I was on bioidentical hormones from age 54 to age 62. I got off them because at that time , doctors were saying stay on them the least amount of time. I am now 71 and would like to go back on them because of my osteoporosis but my gynocologist told me No as I was 10 years out from menopause.

REPLY
Profile picture for mcallister1002 @mcallister1002

I was on bioidentical hormones from age 54 to age 62. I got off them because at that time , doctors were saying stay on them the least amount of time. I am now 71 and would like to go back on them because of my osteoporosis but my gynocologist told me No as I was 10 years out from menopause.

Jump to this post

@mcallister1002, I wish the gyns would assess individual risk factors instead of just making decisions based on the "10 year rule."

REPLY
Profile picture for mcallister1002 @mcallister1002

I just watched this video today from Dr. Susan. She talks specifically about estrogen risk. You may find it helpful

Jump to this post

@mcallister1002, thanks. Will look at the video as soon as possible.

REPLY
Profile picture for bayhorse @bayhorse

@mcallister1002, I wish the gyns would assess individual risk factors instead of just making decisions based on the "10 year rule."

Jump to this post

I agree. Dr. Susan discusses that in the video I sent.

REPLY
Profile picture for bayhorse @bayhorse

@mcallister1002, thanks. Will look at the video as soon as possible.

Jump to this post

Well, to all of you lovely women out there, don’t hesitate to start or continue taking oestrogen! I was on HRT for five year in my 50s. Now, in my late 70s, I’m on Ovestin cream for incontinence, Hurrah!!

REPLY
Profile picture for kisu @kisu

CLICK ON THE LINK at the bottom copy and paste into the browser
Clinical Expert Series
A Contemporary View of Menopausal
Hormone Therapy
2024 by the American College of Obstetricians
and Gynecologists.
https://rb.gy/yoaouu

Jump to this post

@kisu
Peter Attia MD interviewed Rachel Rubin MD on his podcast (5/12/2025). Episode #348 about HRT. It is very well done and spells out the current options, risks and benefits. I highly recommend listening to it. She references Transitions Pharmacy as a source for discounted HRT.
I was diagnosed with breast cancer (Her2+, Hormone negative) in 2021 at 65. I had been on transdermal estrogen/progesterone for 10years prior. I stopped HRT, had 6 cycles of chemo, bilateral Mastectomy, radiation and more chem to complete 1 year treatment. I was fortunate to have complete pathologic response and had no recurrence. Going off HRT threw me into hot flashes, night sweats, brain fog, joint stiffness, not to mention feeling depleted from chemo. At this point I want to resume HRT and have been given the OK by my oncologist and gyn. I will be starting with a lower dose estrogen/progesterone patch, and vaginal “ring” that delivers continuous dose of estrogen to those tissues, getting replaced every 3 months. I am able to purchase the ring for $180 via the online Transitions pharmacy HRT club, free shipping. Will be adding transdermal testosterone. I hope this interview will shed some light for those seeking answers.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.