Whole Body Vibration for Osteoporosis

Posted by jmanj @jmanj, Jun 24, 2021

I’m looking into Whole Body Vibration to aid in bone building for osteoporosis. I’ve read that Low Intensity Vibration is better than high intensity. Does anyone have any experience with this?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

I appreciate your reply - did you have someone coaching you, or did you just start using the WBV tool. Were there any restrictions with the machine as far as you should not use it? I am going to research this Marodyne.
Thanks for your time.

REPLY
Profile picture for z3french9 @z3french9

I’ve been using the Marodyne for about 4 years and my DEXA scores improved significantly after two years of daily use. My hip score went from osteoporotic to osteopenic. My lumbar improved by 6%. Since that initial improvement, the scores were stable the following DEXA. I take no meds. I do supplement with calcium and turkey tail mushrooms, genestein , boron and MK7. I walk a lot and wear a 10 lb. weighted vest. I can’t say for sure if the LiV is the main reason but it certainly may be a factor. Best of luck!

Jump to this post

Thanks so much for our reply. I have been researching different brands, but have not heard about this one. I will definitely research it. Could you tell me if they were any restrictions as to who could use and who shouldn't use it.

REPLY
Profile picture for janeted @janeted

My specialist rolled her eyes when I asked her about the benefit of body vibration! 🙄🤷‍♀️

Jump to this post

Mine did the same thing. Made me feel like an idiot. I just do not want to be on medication for osteoporosis.

REPLY
Profile picture for mrspancakes @mrspancakes

I appreciate your reply - did you have someone coaching you, or did you just start using the WBV tool. Were there any restrictions with the machine as far as you should not use it? I am going to research this Marodyne.
Thanks for your time.

Jump to this post

No coaching necessary. I stand on it 3-4 times per day while checking email or reading online. No restrictions that I am aware of. I wouldn’t use it if you’ve just had a compression fracture. I would also be careful if you are someone who is unsteady or had mobility issues. The device itself is low to the ground though so it’s not like you are standing on a pedestal.

REPLY
Profile picture for mrspancakes @mrspancakes

Thanks so much for our reply. I have been researching different brands, but have not heard about this one. I will definitely research it. Could you tell me if they were any restrictions as to who could use and who shouldn't use it.

Jump to this post

Marodyne LiV is the name. You can google it.

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

This questions arises frequently - it has been the subject of many studies over the past 10-15 years. This article sifted through hundreds of those studies, and found 15 which they reviewed.
https://bmcwomenshealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12905-024-03290-x
Here is what they reported as the conclusion BY THE STUDY RESEARCHERS:
"The statistical results showed that the authors of nine SRs believed that WBV may be effective in improving bone density in postmenopausal women. Still, the current evidence is insufficient, and further research is needed for confirmation. Additionally, four conclusions maintained a neutral stance, stating that the current quality of evidence is poor, making it difficult to provide a definitive answer. Two conclusions considered WBV to be ineffective."

Other recent studies seem to be reaching similar conclusions. To find this information (and not the ads and promoters) I searched in scholar.google.com using the phrase "whole body vibration therapy for osteoporosis" and limited studies to those from 2021 forward.

So, in answer to your questions, the platforms MAY be helpful, and given the limited evidence, your insurance company most likely will not pay for it. It seems for most of us there is no substitute for frequent weight bearing exercise - walking, running. weights. On the plus side - vigorous daily work - lifting, raking pulling, pushing - such as gardening, mowing, toting kids, groceries and laundry, are all weight bearing exercises.

Jump to this post

@sueinmn thank you so much for these details. Along with the monopoly that Power Plate feeds those that show interest, getting hard science is difficult to come by on vibration plates. Chances are, if you use one, you are also doing many other things to combat osteoporosis. So, my question when someone says that they experienced results is, what else are you doing?
I conclude that the plates may be helpful for other issues, may help increase or enhance certain exercises but the jury is out when it comes to how it effects bone density. With that said, everything points to weight bearing exercises and movement. No shortcut there and there is documented studies that indicate how beneficial exercise is for our condition as well as quality of life in general.
Thanks again.
Pat

REPLY
Profile picture for lorishealth @lorishealth

I am interested in your Marodyne. Might we connect? Lori

Jump to this post

You can contact me at debpropes@me.com and I can give you more details.

REPLY
Profile picture for z3french9 @z3french9

Marodyne LiV is the name. You can google it.

Jump to this post

Thank you so much for your information. I am waiting to hear back from a rep from Marodyne.

REPLY

What about Osteoboost Vibrating Belt?
Any one using one?

REPLY
Profile picture for psanchez33617 @psanchez33617

@sueinmn thank you so much for these details. Along with the monopoly that Power Plate feeds those that show interest, getting hard science is difficult to come by on vibration plates. Chances are, if you use one, you are also doing many other things to combat osteoporosis. So, my question when someone says that they experienced results is, what else are you doing?
I conclude that the plates may be helpful for other issues, may help increase or enhance certain exercises but the jury is out when it comes to how it effects bone density. With that said, everything points to weight bearing exercises and movement. No shortcut there and there is documented studies that indicate how beneficial exercise is for our condition as well as quality of life in general.
Thanks again.
Pat

Jump to this post

I posted above that in addition to using the Marodyne LIV platform 3-4 times daily, I take a few supplements like low doses of calcium, boron, Turkey Tail mushrooms, etc. I also walk daily and do yoga. But I’ve been walking and doing yoga for years prior to my diagnosis 4 years go with osteoporosis. My endocrinologist was shocked when my DEXA showed about 9% bone density improvement in my femur and 5% in my lumbar. This is virtually unheard of without being on some sort of Rx for bone loss. She kept asking me if my primary care had put me on fosamax or something else and I told her “no”. So that’s one experience - since it doesn’t pose any risks to me and may be helping, I will continue to use it.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.