Marsh hiking

Posted by payette78 @payette78, 2 days ago

With bronchiectasis and NTM, would you hike on elevated trails around a marsh? Or is it a bad idea?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the MAC & Bronchiectasis Support Group.

@payette78 & @dstella - It becomes a question of what we know, and what our personal risk tolerance is.

We know marshes, whether fresh water or brackish, tend to harbor a lot of NTM. We know that with Bronchiectasis and/or MAC we should avoid sources of concentrated bacteria. Thus we know that repeated, unprotected exposure is a risky activity. I know my tolerance for taking risks is higher than most people, but I don't know yours.

Given all of that, what would I do? If I was on a trip or excursion that included a one time hike near a marsh, I would wear a new N-95 mask and discard it at the end of the outing. If it was a marsh near my home (I have a couple) I would choose a safer path.

REPLY
@sueinmn

@payette78 & @dstella - It becomes a question of what we know, and what our personal risk tolerance is.

We know marshes, whether fresh water or brackish, tend to harbor a lot of NTM. We know that with Bronchiectasis and/or MAC we should avoid sources of concentrated bacteria. Thus we know that repeated, unprotected exposure is a risky activity. I know my tolerance for taking risks is higher than most people, but I don't know yours.

Given all of that, what would I do? If I was on a trip or excursion that included a one time hike near a marsh, I would wear a new N-95 mask and discard it at the end of the outing. If it was a marsh near my home (I have a couple) I would choose a safer path.

Jump to this post

Thanks Sue. I appreciate the thoughtful input. I am not much of a risk taker right now so i will sadly stay away. The marsh in question used to be a favorite place to go in spring to see baby ducks and Canada goslings. I have some nice photos from past springs, so that will have to do for now.

REPLY
@payette78

Thanks Sue. I appreciate the thoughtful input. I am not much of a risk taker right now so i will sadly stay away. The marsh in question used to be a favorite place to go in spring to see baby ducks and Canada goslings. I have some nice photos from past springs, so that will have to do for now.

Jump to this post

It sounds like a lovely place. I probably would go for an easy stroll there, but limit the time to 30-60 min and the number of days/week. You won’t be near the surface and limiting time would also reduce exposure.
Wearing a mask and glasses would further reduce it.

I guess I’m always looking for a middle ground between risks and benefits. Seeing ducklings would be a big mental benefit for me.

REPLY
@pacathy

It sounds like a lovely place. I probably would go for an easy stroll there, but limit the time to 30-60 min and the number of days/week. You won’t be near the surface and limiting time would also reduce exposure.
Wearing a mask and glasses would further reduce it.

I guess I’m always looking for a middle ground between risks and benefits. Seeing ducklings would be a big mental benefit for me.

Jump to this post

I’m finding it so difficult trying to decide what I should avoid or change in order to protect myself. Every summer we stay at a house on a marsh in New Jersey for two weeks. Now I’m not sure I should be staying there at all. I never thought about it before.

REPLY
@jannah

I’m finding it so difficult trying to decide what I should avoid or change in order to protect myself. Every summer we stay at a house on a marsh in New Jersey for two weeks. Now I’m not sure I should be staying there at all. I never thought about it before.

Jump to this post

I am in the same boat. Just got diagnosed last December and still trying to figure out my new reality.

REPLY
@payette78

Thanks Sue. I appreciate the thoughtful input. I am not much of a risk taker right now so i will sadly stay away. The marsh in question used to be a favorite place to go in spring to see baby ducks and Canada goslings. I have some nice photos from past springs, so that will have to do for now.

Jump to this post

Like @pacathy, I would wear a mask and go. I still visit the resacas (backwaters) in our local birding parks, we just try to choose a calm day, and rather than having our snack in the bird blind we hike to the picnic area. I also feed the backyard birds, wearing gloves and mask while cleaning and filling feeders and birdbath.

REPLY
@jannah

I’m finding it so difficult trying to decide what I should avoid or change in order to protect myself. Every summer we stay at a house on a marsh in New Jersey for two weeks. Now I’m not sure I should be staying there at all. I never thought about it before.

Jump to this post

If you ask Dr Falkenham how risky it is in an email, he’d let you know. I did that about white water rafting. He didn’t say go/don’t go, but explained that water that has just run thru tree roots probably has increased MAC. I’ll do the family day trip and avoid seats that take more spray.

REPLY
@pacathy

If you ask Dr Falkenham how risky it is in an email, he’d let you know. I did that about white water rafting. He didn’t say go/don’t go, but explained that water that has just run thru tree roots probably has increased MAC. I’ll do the family day trip and avoid seats that take more spray.

Jump to this post

Thanks for the information. I really appreciate your help. I have learned so much from this group!

REPLY
@sueinmn

Like @pacathy, I would wear a mask and go. I still visit the resacas (backwaters) in our local birding parks, we just try to choose a calm day, and rather than having our snack in the bird blind we hike to the picnic area. I also feed the backyard birds, wearing gloves and mask while cleaning and filling feeders and birdbath.

Jump to this post

Hmmm. Yeah, i hate to deprive my husband of the pleasure we share in going to that spot together. The baby birds bring joy and smiles. It's teeming with red-winged blackbirds in spring too.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.