Dad won't let go of driving

Posted by heartyrainbow @heartyrainbow, Oct 5 5:53pm

My dad was recently diagnosed with dementia, and his doctor told him he needs to stop driving. However, he doesn't trust doctors, and he sees nothing wrong with him driving. Mom took a couple of actions so far:
- She hid his key, but he is determined to either find the key or get a new key.
- They went to get a spare key from the dealer, but she called the dealer beforehand to explain the situation so that they don't give them the key right away.

These are just temporary solutions. He will eventually find a way. Maybe get a new key himself, or maybe even get a new car!
He has been nagging my mom so much about the car it's making my mom sick, literally.
Maybe have his license revoked and sell his car? But he might still try driving my mom's car.

Please give me some ideas on where to go from here. Thank you.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Caregivers: Dementia Support Group.

What an incredibly difficult situation!

I did some digging and found some sites that might offer some help. I hope you're able to find a solution.
https://www.dementiacarecentral.com/caregiverinfo/driving-problems/
Covers legal stuff, but also has tips like Transportation Options
https://yourdementiatherapist.com/alzheimers-dementia/caregiving/driving/
Also offers Alternatives to Driving.
https://alzfdn.org/driving-and-dementia/
More info, including this helpful resource:
"AFA’s dementia-trained social workers answer questions about driving very often. Contact AFA’s Helpline at 866-232-8484 or click the chat icon in the lower right hand corner of this page."

REPLY
@scottrl

What an incredibly difficult situation!

I did some digging and found some sites that might offer some help. I hope you're able to find a solution.
https://www.dementiacarecentral.com/caregiverinfo/driving-problems/
Covers legal stuff, but also has tips like Transportation Options
https://yourdementiatherapist.com/alzheimers-dementia/caregiving/driving/
Also offers Alternatives to Driving.
https://alzfdn.org/driving-and-dementia/
More info, including this helpful resource:
"AFA’s dementia-trained social workers answer questions about driving very often. Contact AFA’s Helpline at 866-232-8484 or click the chat icon in the lower right hand corner of this page."

Jump to this post

Thank you so much Scott for doing research on this. I appreciate it!
I will look at these sites and call the Helpline.

REPLY

@heartyrainbow Welcome to Mayo Clinic Connect. You certainly have a problem on your hands!
Does your mother continue to ride with him? She should make it very clear that she won’t accompany him and then learn how to use Uber. Here is another discussion on driving.
https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/no-more-driving/. Some spouses have mentioned things such as taking away license, cancelling car insurance, etc. I’ll let more members give you suggestions.
how long have you been a caregiver?

REPLY
@becsbuddy

@heartyrainbow Welcome to Mayo Clinic Connect. You certainly have a problem on your hands!
Does your mother continue to ride with him? She should make it very clear that she won’t accompany him and then learn how to use Uber. Here is another discussion on driving.
https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/no-more-driving/. Some spouses have mentioned things such as taking away license, cancelling car insurance, etc. I’ll let more members give you suggestions.
how long have you been a caregiver?

Jump to this post

Hi Becky, thank you for the response!
I live far from my parents, so I have been supporting them remotely, especially in the last couple of months. My mom and everyone else made it clear that he should not drive, but it doesn't seem to matter to him. I have thought of taking away license and his car (my mom has her own car), but he might try getting a new car... but maybe that's the only option?

REPLY

I’d get a consult with an elder law attorney and request information on your legal remedies. Sadly, sometimes the only way to get actual legal authority needed to prevent a tragedy is to get it through the courts. I’d do that before canceling any insurance.

As long as he’s licensed, insurance should cover him if wrecks. His doctor may send a notice to DMV so he must test to keep his license, but with dementia, he may drive regardless of whether he has a license. Reason and judgment go out the window.

The bottom line is that after the doctor tells him to not drive, it becomes a real liability for the family member who doesn’t prevent it. For anyone he injuries, they or their estate could sue the spouse of the driver who was told not to drive, as well as the driver. So, it’s a real liability.

It was difficult to get my dad to give up driving, but we hid the keys and refused to give them back no matter how upset he got. He occasionally says he wants his keys and I say later….but later never comes. Then he forgets about it.

There are a number ways to approach it. I hope you find one that works for your situation.

REPLY
@heartyrainbow

Thank you so much Scott for doing research on this. I appreciate it!
I will look at these sites and call the Helpline.

Jump to this post

Glad to help!

Being disabled by a stroke, there's a lot I can't do anymore, but I can still try and help others in different ways.

REPLY
@celia16

I’d get a consult with an elder law attorney and request information on your legal remedies. Sadly, sometimes the only way to get actual legal authority needed to prevent a tragedy is to get it through the courts. I’d do that before canceling any insurance.

As long as he’s licensed, insurance should cover him if wrecks. His doctor may send a notice to DMV so he must test to keep his license, but with dementia, he may drive regardless of whether he has a license. Reason and judgment go out the window.

The bottom line is that after the doctor tells him to not drive, it becomes a real liability for the family member who doesn’t prevent it. For anyone he injuries, they or their estate could sue the spouse of the driver who was told not to drive, as well as the driver. So, it’s a real liability.

It was difficult to get my dad to give up driving, but we hid the keys and refused to give them back no matter how upset he got. He occasionally says he wants his keys and I say later….but later never comes. Then he forgets about it.

There are a number ways to approach it. I hope you find one that works for your situation.

Jump to this post

Thank you for your input and encouragement, celia16.
That's a good point, I agree that it's better to keep the insurance just in case.
I am also afraid that he would drive even after we take it away. He is very very healthy besides dementia and very motivated to keep driving, so he might take any action he could take.
Hiding the key seems to work only temporarily, so we might need to take extreme measure, taking away car and license.

REPLY
@heartyrainbow

Thank you for your input and encouragement, celia16.
That's a good point, I agree that it's better to keep the insurance just in case.
I am also afraid that he would drive even after we take it away. He is very very healthy besides dementia and very motivated to keep driving, so he might take any action he could take.
Hiding the key seems to work only temporarily, so we might need to take extreme measure, taking away car and license.

Jump to this post

This is a horribly tough situation! My Mom never forgave me for getting her license taken by way of a professional fitness to drive assessment. But at least she didn't get injured or harm anyone else. We had to disable her vehicle to keep her from driving until we could sell it.

In most states, the doctor can order a driver's evaluation or test for anyone deemed unfit to drive. The state issues a notice to appear for testing, and takes the license if the driver does not pass.

Consult an attorney as soon as you can. Insurance may not cover him in an accident if his doctor has deemed him unfit to drive, even if he has not surrendered his license.

As for buying a new car if you sell his, he has to present a license to buy at a dealer, or at the registrar of vehicles to transfer title.

REPLY

@heartyrainbow My first reply disappeared. My experience is that giving up driving is one of the last vestiges of independence. It seems to affect men more than women. My mother had dementia and became fearful of everything. She stopped driving about 8 years before she passed.

My dad did not have dementia, but slowed reflexes to things. He finally realized accidents in the parking lots, and close calls on the road, were his doing. He turned his license in and sold his car at age 93. He passed at age 96.
Ginger

REPLY
@sueinmn

This is a horribly tough situation! My Mom never forgave me for getting her license taken by way of a professional fitness to drive assessment. But at least she didn't get injured or harm anyone else. We had to disable her vehicle to keep her from driving until we could sell it.

In most states, the doctor can order a driver's evaluation or test for anyone deemed unfit to drive. The state issues a notice to appear for testing, and takes the license if the driver does not pass.

Consult an attorney as soon as you can. Insurance may not cover him in an accident if his doctor has deemed him unfit to drive, even if he has not surrendered his license.

As for buying a new car if you sell his, he has to present a license to buy at a dealer, or at the registrar of vehicles to transfer title.

Jump to this post

Thank you, Sue! It's sad to hear your mom never forgave you for getting her license taken away. But I applaud you for being so positive about it!

I will ask attorney about the insurance. It never occurred to me that it may not cover him. Thank you for that information!

As for buying a new car, yes I was thinking you need a license, but as I do more research, I found out that you can buy a car without license if you buy it with cash. You just need some kind of ID like passport, at least in my parents' state.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.