The Strontium Debate: Is it good for bone health?

Posted by meomurian @meomurian, Feb 20, 2023

Is anyone taking strontium for bone health? My husband is reading studies on its benefits. I am currently getting Prolia injections 2x/year.

***Director's Note:***
There’s not enough clinical research to know if strontium citrate effectively prevents or treats osteoporosis. Mayo Clinic does not recomend its use. Clinically researched osteoporosis medications have demonstrated fracture prevention benefit with less risk.  

The FDA doesn’t regulate supplements in the same way as prescription drugs, so it's not possible to know if if they are safe or work well or even how much of the main ingredient they contain.

If you wish to take a strontium supplement, it is advised to discuss with your doctor. 

All information shared by members on the Mayo Clinic Connect is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding your health. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on the community.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for karenolivia47 @karenolivia47

I had three doses of Fosamax in June, 2024. After the third dose I developed ilial tibial band syndrome--probably the worst pain I've had since childbirth! Mercifully, it disappeared soon after and I never took another dose. In researching non-drug options I came across OsteoStrong and AlgaeCal with Strontium. I started both about 15 months ago. In May, 2024 my lumbar spine was -4.1. Now it is -2.9. Left hip has improved from -2.6 to -2.0--in 15 months. My endocrinologist is STILL pushing Reclast! I'd appreciate thoughts from you all, please.

Jump to this post

Recently, i checked with Consumer Labs and they rated New Chapter as a very good alternative to AlgaeCalPlus, which is very expensive. You can get it in TinyTabs (6per day), easy to swallow and you could adjust the dosage if you wish. It is organic, plant-based and 3rd party tested… it does contain a minimum amount of strontium..there is a fee for using Consumer Labs— for me worth it…ll.. this supplement is available at Amazon.

REPLY
Profile picture for karenolivia47 @karenolivia47

I had three doses of Fosamax in June, 2024. After the third dose I developed ilial tibial band syndrome--probably the worst pain I've had since childbirth! Mercifully, it disappeared soon after and I never took another dose. In researching non-drug options I came across OsteoStrong and AlgaeCal with Strontium. I started both about 15 months ago. In May, 2024 my lumbar spine was -4.1. Now it is -2.9. Left hip has improved from -2.6 to -2.0--in 15 months. My endocrinologist is STILL pushing Reclast! I'd appreciate thoughts from you all, please.

Jump to this post

As always, I suggest that each of us do their own research, to feel comfortable with our own choices… and am always open to suggestions from some terrific people on this message board.

REPLY
Profile picture for karenolivia47 @karenolivia47

I had three doses of Fosamax in June, 2024. After the third dose I developed ilial tibial band syndrome--probably the worst pain I've had since childbirth! Mercifully, it disappeared soon after and I never took another dose. In researching non-drug options I came across OsteoStrong and AlgaeCal with Strontium. I started both about 15 months ago. In May, 2024 my lumbar spine was -4.1. Now it is -2.9. Left hip has improved from -2.6 to -2.0--in 15 months. My endocrinologist is STILL pushing Reclast! I'd appreciate thoughts from you all, please.

Jump to this post

Just started Algae Cal, tastes like a dog bone. I can usually drink something bad tasting if it’s good for me, but this stuff is really bad. Not sure I can stick w it.

REPLY
Profile picture for eileenvan @eileenvan

Just started Algae Cal, tastes like a dog bone. I can usually drink something bad tasting if it’s good for me, but this stuff is really bad. Not sure I can stick w it.

Jump to this post

Yikes! Are you taking AlgaeCal plus? It's a capsule and so is the Strontium Citrate. No taste at all.

REPLY
Profile picture for karenolivia47 @karenolivia47

Yikes! Are you taking AlgaeCal plus? It's a capsule and so is the Strontium Citrate. No taste at all.

Jump to this post

I got algae cal collagen
Will look into Strontium Citrate.
Have to ask my GI dr because I have a tumor on my pancreas and don’t simulate vitamins properly.
Thanks for the reply

REPLY
Profile picture for karenolivia47 @karenolivia47

I had three doses of Fosamax in June, 2024. After the third dose I developed ilial tibial band syndrome--probably the worst pain I've had since childbirth! Mercifully, it disappeared soon after and I never took another dose. In researching non-drug options I came across OsteoStrong and AlgaeCal with Strontium. I started both about 15 months ago. In May, 2024 my lumbar spine was -4.1. Now it is -2.9. Left hip has improved from -2.6 to -2.0--in 15 months. My endocrinologist is STILL pushing Reclast! I'd appreciate thoughts from you all, please.

Jump to this post

With those improvements I would continue what you are doing!!!

REPLY
Profile picture for eileenvan @eileenvan

I got algae cal collagen
Will look into Strontium Citrate.
Have to ask my GI dr because I have a tumor on my pancreas and don’t simulate vitamins properly.
Thanks for the reply

Jump to this post

Check out collagen in capsules or tabs….one place to research is consumer labs….

REPLY
Profile picture for karenolivia47 @karenolivia47

I had three doses of Fosamax in June, 2024. After the third dose I developed ilial tibial band syndrome--probably the worst pain I've had since childbirth! Mercifully, it disappeared soon after and I never took another dose. In researching non-drug options I came across OsteoStrong and AlgaeCal with Strontium. I started both about 15 months ago. In May, 2024 my lumbar spine was -4.1. Now it is -2.9. Left hip has improved from -2.6 to -2.0--in 15 months. My endocrinologist is STILL pushing Reclast! I'd appreciate thoughts from you all, please.

Jump to this post

Hi, I have been struggling with what an effective, but safe amount of vitamin k is for osteoporosis. I want to make sure I am not taking too much K also. Any recommendations on K. Does anyone take Pure Encapsulations Synergy K? Is a small amount of K effective?

REPLY
Profile picture for karenolivia47 @karenolivia47

I had three doses of Fosamax in June, 2024. After the third dose I developed ilial tibial band syndrome--probably the worst pain I've had since childbirth! Mercifully, it disappeared soon after and I never took another dose. In researching non-drug options I came across OsteoStrong and AlgaeCal with Strontium. I started both about 15 months ago. In May, 2024 my lumbar spine was -4.1. Now it is -2.9. Left hip has improved from -2.6 to -2.0--in 15 months. My endocrinologist is STILL pushing Reclast! I'd appreciate thoughts from you all, please.

Jump to this post

@karenolivia4 - You mention OsteoStrong. Do you mean the clinic (not a supplement)? Ive been wanting to try the clinic out, and based on your post (if you mean the clinic), I will!

REPLY
Profile picture for rse1 @rse1

@karenolivia4 - You mention OsteoStrong. Do you mean the clinic (not a supplement)? Ive been wanting to try the clinic out, and based on your post (if you mean the clinic), I will!

Jump to this post

Yes. The clinic.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.