Pulmonologist versus Infectious Disease Dr

Posted by bbeers @bbeers, Dec 2, 2023

I was diagnosed with MAC in August. Pulmonary Dr. wanted me to start Big 3 even though I have no symptoms. I asked if I could take one at a time rather than all three at once. He said no. I just wanted to space them out so I could determine which one, if any, was causing side effects. I decided to see an Infectious Disease Dr. and her approach is different. Do you have a preference over one type of Dr. to another. I feel like the ID Dr. might be better equipped to handle this disease. Thank you

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the MAC & Bronchiectasis Support Group.

@bbeers I don’t know where I’d be without my team of ID doctor, pulmonologist, and lung surgeon. Way back when I was diagnosed with MAC ( 2016) my pulmonologist told me to go to infectious disease. Sue said it well. We really need both to manage MAC - a team. Mine always communicate with each other about me. Someone from the team has contacted me every few days lately because I am struggling with RSV . Having a team is best because “two heads are better than one”. They can discuss your unique situation and share ideas. If you aren’t able to have that team approach your ID doctor would be most knowledgeable about MAC and treatment. You need that! Irene5

REPLY
@bee1950

Hi,
I’ve been living with the “ticking time bomb” for 6 yrs. I also have minimal symptoms & have never taken the “big 3”. My pulmonologist referred me to an ID Dr. several years ago, but he did not feel my condition warranted treatment (at the time I was regularly coughing up blood). I started nebulizing sodium chloride (3% initially, then 7%) & I really believe that has helped me stay healthy (no colds, flu, or Covid-fingers crossed). I would speak with the ID Dr. about what she would recommend. Regular exercise, a healthy diet, & 7-8 hrs of sleep are all part of my treatment plan! Take care, Linda

Jump to this post

Wow, 6 yrs. That's unbelievable. Thank you for sharing this with me. I see the ID Dr. next week.

REPLY
@irene5

@bbeers I don’t know where I’d be without my team of ID doctor, pulmonologist, and lung surgeon. Way back when I was diagnosed with MAC ( 2016) my pulmonologist told me to go to infectious disease. Sue said it well. We really need both to manage MAC - a team. Mine always communicate with each other about me. Someone from the team has contacted me every few days lately because I am struggling with RSV . Having a team is best because “two heads are better than one”. They can discuss your unique situation and share ideas. If you aren’t able to have that team approach your ID doctor would be most knowledgeable about MAC and treatment. You need that! Irene5

Jump to this post

Thank you for responding Irene. Sorry to hear you have RSV now on top of everything else. Were your Dr's at the same hospital or clinic. Mine are not. Take care and feel better soon.

REPLY
@bbeers

Thank you for responding Irene. Sorry to hear you have RSV now on top of everything else. Were your Dr's at the same hospital or clinic. Mine are not. Take care and feel better soon.

Jump to this post

My ID is at UMASS . My pulmonologist is at UMASS university hospital which is a couple of miles down the road. Originally my ID was at my local hospital in Connecticut. I still have her, but she doesn’t do the commute anymore. I understand if your two doctors aren’t at the same hospital. However they can still be a team via the internet. My PCP is nowhere near them , but the team connects with my PCP. You can request that. Irene5

REPLY
@kitchensink

I'm newly confirmed for MAC and will start big three after Christmas. Do most people take all three at once? Or can you take one at breakfast, one at lunch, and one at dinner? I was hoping to isolate side effects by taking separately. I need to go back to my ID to confirm before I start.

Jump to this post

I have been in the big 3 since August 23. I was told I could take together or not. I started taking all three at night … 2-2-1/2 hrs after good. So close to bedtime. I’ve no problems at all. I was prepared for some sort of reaction to something… but pleasantly surprised. MWF between 8-10 pm. I didn’t start taking any meds until the second CT showed the bacteria increasing. So, 6 months down…18 to go! Can’t wait for that first glass of celebratory wine! Good luck!

REPLY
@karen71

I have been in the big 3 since August 23. I was told I could take together or not. I started taking all three at night … 2-2-1/2 hrs after good. So close to bedtime. I’ve no problems at all. I was prepared for some sort of reaction to something… but pleasantly surprised. MWF between 8-10 pm. I didn’t start taking any meds until the second CT showed the bacteria increasing. So, 6 months down…18 to go! Can’t wait for that first glass of celebratory wine! Good luck!

Jump to this post

Sorry for typos. None of the three meds helps with that. 😬

REPLY
@irene5

@bbeers I don’t know where I’d be without my team of ID doctor, pulmonologist, and lung surgeon. Way back when I was diagnosed with MAC ( 2016) my pulmonologist told me to go to infectious disease. Sue said it well. We really need both to manage MAC - a team. Mine always communicate with each other about me. Someone from the team has contacted me every few days lately because I am struggling with RSV . Having a team is best because “two heads are better than one”. They can discuss your unique situation and share ideas. If you aren’t able to have that team approach your ID doctor would be most knowledgeable about MAC and treatment. You need that! Irene5

Jump to this post

Thank you for sharing that info with me. I am working on that. Feel better soon.

REPLY
@karen71

I have been in the big 3 since August 23. I was told I could take together or not. I started taking all three at night … 2-2-1/2 hrs after good. So close to bedtime. I’ve no problems at all. I was prepared for some sort of reaction to something… but pleasantly surprised. MWF between 8-10 pm. I didn’t start taking any meds until the second CT showed the bacteria increasing. So, 6 months down…18 to go! Can’t wait for that first glass of celebratory wine! Good luck!

Jump to this post

Thank you for sharing your journey with me. It sure helps to know that there are people who are tolerating the Big 3. Best wishes to you for a speedy recovery !!

REPLY
@bbeers

Thank you for sharing your journey with me. It sure helps to know that there are people who are tolerating the Big 3. Best wishes to you for a speedy recovery !!

Jump to this post

I will add my dr suggested I get something called an acapella. It’s the opposite of a spirometer. Instead of breathing in and measuring, you breathe out. He said it wasn’t a have to do but a good to do. Keeps the lungs open and moving air. I keep by my bed and use it when I think of it but ideally should be doing it a couple/few times a day. Takes minutes, that’s all. Bought it on Amazon.

REPLY
@karen71

I will add my dr suggested I get something called an acapella. It’s the opposite of a spirometer. Instead of breathing in and measuring, you breathe out. He said it wasn’t a have to do but a good to do. Keeps the lungs open and moving air. I keep by my bed and use it when I think of it but ideally should be doing it a couple/few times a day. Takes minutes, that’s all. Bought it on Amazon.

Jump to this post

Get an Aerobika instead of the acapella. Much better anD you can sterilize it by boiling

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.