Time to choose a penis pump. Any recommendations?

Posted by themurfs @themurfs, Jul 11, 2024

I cannot decide between manual or automatic. I was referred to TIMMMEDICAL to purchase. Any suggestions on these options and also brands?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

Profile picture for Chuck @chucklesg

Engagement rings!

Jump to this post

@chucklesg ah TROLLS here also

REPLY
Profile picture for richmaple @richmaple

@harvey44 Good Morning, may I ask about which ring(s) you find that work from amazon?

Jump to this post

@richmaple they come in different sizes so I don't know which might work best for you. I'm including a link to the Amazon product i bought and i use the size A. They're very durable and i haven't found that they stretch out of their original size.
https://www.amazon.com/Timm-Standard-Latex-Free-Erection-Maintaining/dp/B0DS455V7B/ref=sr_1_49

REPLY
Profile picture for kenlily18 @kenlily18

hi i had my prostate removal 18 months ago i have a problem with ED and it frustrates me . I have tried viagra snd Cialis that don’t work for me . Urologist suggested penis pumps or operation of an insert valve for pumping up the penis . I didn’t want anymore operations , perhaps a pump . Any suggestion the type of penis pump to buy

Jump to this post

I always strongly encourage my patients to use a vacuum erection device as a means of stretching the penis and improving blood flow in that area. Here is the information I provide my patients regarding a vacuum erection device.

Vacuum erection device:
Regular use of a VED helps maintain penile length, improve blood flow, and prevent scar tissue (fibrosis) after prostate surgery or radiation, or if you've had longstanding erectile dysfunction. Think of it as “physical therapy” for your penis.

You can purchase a medical-grade VED through the Mayo Store at the websites below. The major difference in cost is whether it is electronic (battery operated - more expensive) or manual pump (less expensive). Otherwise they are all equally good and perform the same function. A medical-grade vacuum device is like getting prescription eyeglasses—built for safety, comfort, and effectiveness. Cheaper pumps online are more like toy sunglasses—they may look similar but don’t work as well, may not fit properly, and can even cause harm. For penile rehabilitation after surgery or radiation, I recommend a medical-grade device because it’s safer, lasts longer, and is designed for your health needs.

The Mayo Clinic store has several different types of devices available for purchase.

Step-by-Step Instructions
1. Get Set Up
o Make sure the device is clean and assembled.
o Apply a small amount of water-based lubricant around the base of the cylinder and on the penis to help create a seal.
2. Position the Device
o Place the cylinder snugly against your body at the base of the penis.
o Make sure there are no gaps so air does not leak out.
3. Create the Vacuum
o Use the hand pump (or battery pump, if included) slowly.
o You will see the penis gradually enlarge and become firm.
o A gentle stretching feeling is normal; stop if you feel pain.
4. Rehabilitation Use (without constriction ring)
o For rehab, do not place the tension ring.
o Pump until the penis is stretched/erect, hold for about 1–2 minutes, then release.
o Repeat this cycle 5–10 times in one session.
o Goal: use the device at least 3–4 times per week (daily if possible).
5. If Using for Intercourse (with constriction ring)
o After pumping, slide the tension ring onto the base of the penis.
o Remove the cylinder; the ring will help maintain erection.
o Do not keep the ring on for longer than 30 minutes.

Tips for Success
• Be patient—results improve with consistent use over weeks to months.
• Some mild bruising or discomfort at first can happen; it usually improves with practice.
• Always use water-based lubricant (not oils or lotions).
• This is not just for sex—using the device regularly helps preserve penile health, even if you are not sexually active.

REPLY
Profile picture for Sevann Helo, MD @drsevannhelo

I always strongly encourage my patients to use a vacuum erection device as a means of stretching the penis and improving blood flow in that area. Here is the information I provide my patients regarding a vacuum erection device.

Vacuum erection device:
Regular use of a VED helps maintain penile length, improve blood flow, and prevent scar tissue (fibrosis) after prostate surgery or radiation, or if you've had longstanding erectile dysfunction. Think of it as “physical therapy” for your penis.

You can purchase a medical-grade VED through the Mayo Store at the websites below. The major difference in cost is whether it is electronic (battery operated - more expensive) or manual pump (less expensive). Otherwise they are all equally good and perform the same function. A medical-grade vacuum device is like getting prescription eyeglasses—built for safety, comfort, and effectiveness. Cheaper pumps online are more like toy sunglasses—they may look similar but don’t work as well, may not fit properly, and can even cause harm. For penile rehabilitation after surgery or radiation, I recommend a medical-grade device because it’s safer, lasts longer, and is designed for your health needs.

The Mayo Clinic store has several different types of devices available for purchase.

Step-by-Step Instructions
1. Get Set Up
o Make sure the device is clean and assembled.
o Apply a small amount of water-based lubricant around the base of the cylinder and on the penis to help create a seal.
2. Position the Device
o Place the cylinder snugly against your body at the base of the penis.
o Make sure there are no gaps so air does not leak out.
3. Create the Vacuum
o Use the hand pump (or battery pump, if included) slowly.
o You will see the penis gradually enlarge and become firm.
o A gentle stretching feeling is normal; stop if you feel pain.
4. Rehabilitation Use (without constriction ring)
o For rehab, do not place the tension ring.
o Pump until the penis is stretched/erect, hold for about 1–2 minutes, then release.
o Repeat this cycle 5–10 times in one session.
o Goal: use the device at least 3–4 times per week (daily if possible).
5. If Using for Intercourse (with constriction ring)
o After pumping, slide the tension ring onto the base of the penis.
o Remove the cylinder; the ring will help maintain erection.
o Do not keep the ring on for longer than 30 minutes.

Tips for Success
• Be patient—results improve with consistent use over weeks to months.
• Some mild bruising or discomfort at first can happen; it usually improves with practice.
• Always use water-based lubricant (not oils or lotions).
• This is not just for sex—using the device regularly helps preserve penile health, even if you are not sexually active.

Jump to this post

@drsevannhelo Great information. Thankyou. One more point that may help some.
Lubricant - use lots.
For those uncircumsised - the pain is your skin stretching.
It's enough to make you give up.
I was quite stingy with the lubricant & only put a smear on the rubber end of the device.
Cover the whole penis with it.
It makes a real difference.

REPLY
Profile picture for kenlily18 @kenlily18

hi i had my prostate removal 18 months ago i have a problem with ED and it frustrates me . I have tried viagra snd Cialis that don’t work for me . Urologist suggested penis pumps or operation of an insert valve for pumping up the penis . I didn’t want anymore operations , perhaps a pump . Any suggestion the type of penis pump to buy

Jump to this post

It has been several months since I saw a brief discussion on guys recommending penis pumps/masturbators. I recall a few men recommended the same battery powered electric pump. I did some research and the "EXCELSIOR SMART AUTOMATIC PENIS PUMP WITH STROKER SLEEVE (9 OR 12 INCH)" seems to sound like the best product out there, but I wonder as to any feedback anyone has on this pump vs others...pros/benefits vs cons/cautions.
My brief background: I am one-year post-op (April 2025) for my radial prostatectomy, and I have not had even a twitch of stimulation or erection, despite my urologist claiming that he preserved both neurovascular bundles, in order to maintain my ability to get an erection. I am noticing that my penis is actually slightly smaller which I attribute to both the surgical necessity of the anastomosis to stretch and reconnect the urethra from below where the prostate had been, back up to the bladder since a ~one-inch portion of the urethra is removed by necessity with the prostate. And of course, lack of use and the 'ole "use it or lose it" rule seems to be applying itself to my situation. Thanks for your replies in advance.

REPLY
Profile picture for rlpostrp @rlpostrp

It has been several months since I saw a brief discussion on guys recommending penis pumps/masturbators. I recall a few men recommended the same battery powered electric pump. I did some research and the "EXCELSIOR SMART AUTOMATIC PENIS PUMP WITH STROKER SLEEVE (9 OR 12 INCH)" seems to sound like the best product out there, but I wonder as to any feedback anyone has on this pump vs others...pros/benefits vs cons/cautions.
My brief background: I am one-year post-op (April 2025) for my radial prostatectomy, and I have not had even a twitch of stimulation or erection, despite my urologist claiming that he preserved both neurovascular bundles, in order to maintain my ability to get an erection. I am noticing that my penis is actually slightly smaller which I attribute to both the surgical necessity of the anastomosis to stretch and reconnect the urethra from below where the prostate had been, back up to the bladder since a ~one-inch portion of the urethra is removed by necessity with the prostate. And of course, lack of use and the 'ole "use it or lose it" rule seems to be applying itself to my situation. Thanks for your replies in advance.

Jump to this post

I bought mine from Augusta medical solutions several years ago. The battery operated one broke and it also lost power as the battery wears down. So I ended up with the manual one. I also bought a lifetime warranty for $99. If anything breaks, I just pay for shipping and they replace it. I use this for rehab and to avoid further shrinking, not for sex.

REPLY
Profile picture for rlpostrp @rlpostrp

It has been several months since I saw a brief discussion on guys recommending penis pumps/masturbators. I recall a few men recommended the same battery powered electric pump. I did some research and the "EXCELSIOR SMART AUTOMATIC PENIS PUMP WITH STROKER SLEEVE (9 OR 12 INCH)" seems to sound like the best product out there, but I wonder as to any feedback anyone has on this pump vs others...pros/benefits vs cons/cautions.
My brief background: I am one-year post-op (April 2025) for my radial prostatectomy, and I have not had even a twitch of stimulation or erection, despite my urologist claiming that he preserved both neurovascular bundles, in order to maintain my ability to get an erection. I am noticing that my penis is actually slightly smaller which I attribute to both the surgical necessity of the anastomosis to stretch and reconnect the urethra from below where the prostate had been, back up to the bladder since a ~one-inch portion of the urethra is removed by necessity with the prostate. And of course, lack of use and the 'ole "use it or lose it" rule seems to be applying itself to my situation. Thanks for your replies in advance.

Jump to this post

This is the one I use:
https://www.erecaidpumps.com/edp-mos100/
I’ve been using it daily since mid-February. Pretty basic, but it gets the job done. The ED nurse at the cancer center I go to recommended avoiding the battery-powered ones.

I’m lucky, I suppose, in that I don’t seem to have lost any length compared to before surgery. I did have nerve-sparing surgery done, though the surgeon did remove the nerves on my left side. I’ve not had anything I’d really call an erection yet, but I do get daily sensations sort of like my penis *wants* to be erect, but just can’t figure it out. The best I managed (spontaneously on its own) was a visibly-noticeable 1/4 erection, so things are going on down/in there, but no real results yet.

I’m also just using this therapeutically, not for intimacy. I’m also on a daily half-does of Viagra for the same purpose.

REPLY
Profile picture for rlpostrp @rlpostrp

It has been several months since I saw a brief discussion on guys recommending penis pumps/masturbators. I recall a few men recommended the same battery powered electric pump. I did some research and the "EXCELSIOR SMART AUTOMATIC PENIS PUMP WITH STROKER SLEEVE (9 OR 12 INCH)" seems to sound like the best product out there, but I wonder as to any feedback anyone has on this pump vs others...pros/benefits vs cons/cautions.
My brief background: I am one-year post-op (April 2025) for my radial prostatectomy, and I have not had even a twitch of stimulation or erection, despite my urologist claiming that he preserved both neurovascular bundles, in order to maintain my ability to get an erection. I am noticing that my penis is actually slightly smaller which I attribute to both the surgical necessity of the anastomosis to stretch and reconnect the urethra from below where the prostate had been, back up to the bladder since a ~one-inch portion of the urethra is removed by necessity with the prostate. And of course, lack of use and the 'ole "use it or lose it" rule seems to be applying itself to my situation. Thanks for your replies in advance.

Jump to this post

Like florida11, I also bought from Augusta Medical Systems. I got the SomaTherapy-ED model that was recommended by my urologist. It's the hand pump one. It works well. I only use it for therapy. It comes with rings to maintain an erection and I tried it a couple of times and it did give me a workable erection that I could use for penetration. It was weird however as the ring only holds the blood in but doesn't allow fresh warm blood to replace the cold blood and your penis feels cold. I can get a 1/4 to 1/3 erection at three months out from RALP, so hopefully if I'm persistent with therapy, full erections will come back.
Best of luck to you.

REPLY
Profile picture for rlpostrp @rlpostrp

It has been several months since I saw a brief discussion on guys recommending penis pumps/masturbators. I recall a few men recommended the same battery powered electric pump. I did some research and the "EXCELSIOR SMART AUTOMATIC PENIS PUMP WITH STROKER SLEEVE (9 OR 12 INCH)" seems to sound like the best product out there, but I wonder as to any feedback anyone has on this pump vs others...pros/benefits vs cons/cautions.
My brief background: I am one-year post-op (April 2025) for my radial prostatectomy, and I have not had even a twitch of stimulation or erection, despite my urologist claiming that he preserved both neurovascular bundles, in order to maintain my ability to get an erection. I am noticing that my penis is actually slightly smaller which I attribute to both the surgical necessity of the anastomosis to stretch and reconnect the urethra from below where the prostate had been, back up to the bladder since a ~one-inch portion of the urethra is removed by necessity with the prostate. And of course, lack of use and the 'ole "use it or lose it" rule seems to be applying itself to my situation. Thanks for your replies in advance.

Jump to this post

I used the Vacurect both for therapy following my nerve sparing prostatectomy in October of 2024 and again in preparation for my recent Coloplast inflatable implant (IPP). Following surgery I started having night erections almost suitable for penetration...woohoo!. That lasted 4 months then things started to go away. Also my penis was shrinking in the Vacurect chamber as I marked the clear cylinder. I then added in Trimix shots every few days, but was never able to get an erection firm enough so in October of last year went to a sexual medicine Urologist who ran ultrasound scans of my penis that showed severe scaring (fibrosis) and restricted blood flow on the right side likely from either previous injury or surgical damage to nerves or blood supply during surgery. This was not going to get better and would likely lead to Peyronie's disease down the road. On a recommendation, I called Dr Patel at UCSD and after the initial exam, he asked me what my timeline was ? I told him not in a hurry. He said great, go buy a traction device and use it 30 minutes morning and evening and use the Vacurect twice a day with no ring installed as well. This is to stretch the penis back out so he can stall a longer/larger device and get back lost length. I did all that for 4 months gaining back a little over 1/4" per month for 4 months.
Had the implant installed 5 weeks ago and the length is within 1/2" of what I was before the prostatectomy surgery. Dr Patel has assured me that it will continue to stretch back to full length (maybe a bit more) within 6 months. While disappointed that I had to go Bionic down there I am happy about the result. Most men (70%) report lost length after implant, but that is not the case for me due to 4 months of preparation. One last comment, ...per Dr Patel, unless you had "Retzius Sparring" prostatectomy, most men receiving a prostatectomy have had their bladder detached and dropped down into the "Space of Retzius" to close the gap created by removing the prostate and a chunk of the urethra. This minimizes penile shrinkage however that space is where they put the IPP reservoir so in my case they had to make a second incision in the abdomen for the reservoir.

REPLY
Profile picture for rlpostrp @rlpostrp

It has been several months since I saw a brief discussion on guys recommending penis pumps/masturbators. I recall a few men recommended the same battery powered electric pump. I did some research and the "EXCELSIOR SMART AUTOMATIC PENIS PUMP WITH STROKER SLEEVE (9 OR 12 INCH)" seems to sound like the best product out there, but I wonder as to any feedback anyone has on this pump vs others...pros/benefits vs cons/cautions.
My brief background: I am one-year post-op (April 2025) for my radial prostatectomy, and I have not had even a twitch of stimulation or erection, despite my urologist claiming that he preserved both neurovascular bundles, in order to maintain my ability to get an erection. I am noticing that my penis is actually slightly smaller which I attribute to both the surgical necessity of the anastomosis to stretch and reconnect the urethra from below where the prostate had been, back up to the bladder since a ~one-inch portion of the urethra is removed by necessity with the prostate. And of course, lack of use and the 'ole "use it or lose it" rule seems to be applying itself to my situation. Thanks for your replies in advance.

Jump to this post

Sounds great! What constitutes a 'traction device'? I hae a vacuum pump that I use religiously, but am not familiar with this other one. Thanks.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.