Naturopath

Posted by chris1321 @chris1321, Jun 19 9:19am

Has anyone worked with Carrie Daenell, ND? She worked with the author of Beating Bronchiectasis. If you have worked with her & would be willing to share your story, I’d appreciate it. Just vetting another practitioner. Thanks!

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the MAC & Bronchiectasis Support Group.

Profile picture for rmoore901 @rmoore901

Agreed! The smell and taste were rough along with the increased tiredness. I also started getting mouth sores. Thank you for validating this as I thought it was just me not being able to tolerate it and questioned my decision to discontinue. I’m now doing saline and just started with my vest this week.

Jump to this post

It is the NAC oral that makes me more tired. I have extreme fatigue in general but the NAC makes it worse. So does Mucinex! But the glutathione inhalation did not have that effect that I can recall. It was just bad tasting/smelling and may or may not have had any benefits. Was never sure.

REPLY
Profile picture for irenea8 @irenea8

It is the NAC oral that makes me more tired. I have extreme fatigue in general but the NAC makes it worse. So does Mucinex! But the glutathione inhalation did not have that effect that I can recall. It was just bad tasting/smelling and may or may not have had any benefits. Was never sure.

Jump to this post

Is the glutathione the same as inhaled NAC?

REPLY
Profile picture for reneemc @reneemc

Is the glutathione the same as inhaled NAC?

Jump to this post

not the same.

REPLY
Profile picture for reneemc @reneemc

Is the glutathione the same as inhaled NAC?

Jump to this post

Not the same but I believe both are considered mucolytics. When I went off nebulized NAC, my pulmonologist said I could try Mucinex (which I have yet to start as I was also starting other meds and modalities at the time)

REPLY
Profile picture for irenea8 @irenea8

I have read (cannot remember where) that he did not actually have Bronchiectasis and was misdiagnosed. Hence his being able to "beat bronchiectasis".

Jump to this post

I read somewhere that a CT scan might not show bronchiectasis in someone not suffering an active infection. Bronchia were compared to a blown-up and emptied balloon: flaccid, stretched, but nothing inside to let you see that. When full of mucus, as during an active infection, the misshapen bronchia "fill out" and reveal bronchiectasis on a CT scan. When they're relatively empty, they don't. The author's follow-up CT scan showed no bronchiectasis, which he interpreted as not having bronchiectasis anymore, but it may have been he was clearing his airways so successfully there was no pooled mucus in them to show stretching. Which is also great! If true, it means some of us can enjoy decent health as long as we neb saline and practice airway clearance and nasal lavage and live right.

I could have this all wrong of course! But if it's correct then right now my own condition might not show up on a CT scan as it did 7 weeks ago, when I was coughing constantly and infected by multiple viruses and something bacterial that caused conjunctivitis (because anti-bacterial eyedrops resolved that). I've been diligently nebbing saline since then and feeling much, much better, to the point I only cough a few times a day now, lightly and usually when speaking. My slack worn-out bronchia were probably filled with scan-able gunk when I finally went to the urgent care. I bet they look better now, but I can't afford another CT scan to find out. I'm curious what my scheduled scan next year will show -- hopefully I won't suffer any more hideous respiratory infections by then.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.