Keep bladder or remove?

Posted by jurunado @jurunado, Oct 6 10:22am

Hello everyone, I hope you are all doing ok today. My husband had his last cystoscopy yesterday. He has MIBC T2 highly aggressive. He is a fit 61yr old. The Urology surgeon was very happy with his bladder and scraped out a tiny bit of root to send off for biopsy. He’s had 3 months of chemotherapy prior to this. The thing is this.. his urologist thinks he should have the bladder out and that’s it. Done. Cancer gone. She also thinks he might be a good candidate ‘if’ he wanted to save his bladder but she said that after radiation if he does need the bladder out it will be a more complex surgery.
The radiologist thinks he should give it a go and try save his bladder. None of them are forcing him to a decision but he does need to make one soon. He doesn’t really know what to do. Can anyone advise us or guidance on your own experiences? Thanks a lot to you all.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Bladder Cancer Support Group.

You said MIBC. It really comes down to the variant of MIBC . This is where a genitourinary oncologist that specializes in bladder cancer comes in. Some of these variants i am told the gold standard of care is bladder removal. My suggestion get a 2nd opinion from a genitourinary oncologist from a major academic bladder cancer center. Hope this helps

REPLY

Tough decision, and one only your husband can make. And if the decision is to go with bladder removal, another big decision follows - ostomy or Neo bladder.
As the previous post suggests, information is his friend, get additional opinions, and particularly ask about success rates, risks and side effects. The surgical options are no picnic, but he is relatively young and fit, so that is positive. Radiation is probably the least disruptive with much less risk of issues to body and sexual functions. But many urologists may believe complete removal is the best chance of complete cure. I also think that although most physicians may give what they believe to be impartial advice, we all tend to have bias. So I think I would consult additional opinion from radiologists and surgical urologists, and ones with good reputation and a lot of experience of bladder removal.

REPLY

Just to add, I was faced with a similar decision after TURBT, and decided on complete radical removal - bladder, prostrate, lymph nodes - and Neo bladder. But the decision was a little easier than now because it was 28 years ago and oncology and radiation for bladder cancer were at such an early stage of development, they had a poor track record. That has changed.
Actually Neo bladder was also pretty new, as opposed to osteomyelitis bags, but my surgeon was one of the few at the time with actual Neo bladder experience and so confident it was the best option for me at age 52 that it swung my decision.

REPLY
Profile picture for gs121 @gs121

You said MIBC. It really comes down to the variant of MIBC . This is where a genitourinary oncologist that specializes in bladder cancer comes in. Some of these variants i am told the gold standard of care is bladder removal. My suggestion get a 2nd opinion from a genitourinary oncologist from a major academic bladder cancer center. Hope this helps

Jump to this post

@gs121 thank you for your reply

REPLY
Profile picture for mikf @mikf

Tough decision, and one only your husband can make. And if the decision is to go with bladder removal, another big decision follows - ostomy or Neo bladder.
As the previous post suggests, information is his friend, get additional opinions, and particularly ask about success rates, risks and side effects. The surgical options are no picnic, but he is relatively young and fit, so that is positive. Radiation is probably the least disruptive with much less risk of issues to body and sexual functions. But many urologists may believe complete removal is the best chance of complete cure. I also think that although most physicians may give what they believe to be impartial advice, we all tend to have bias. So I think I would consult additional opinion from radiologists and surgical urologists, and ones with good reputation and a lot of experience of bladder removal.

Jump to this post

@mikf thank you!

REPLY

Your husband's situation sounds almost exactly like mine except that I am 70 years old. My MIBC was discovered in February. In late March I began the first of four cycles of treatment with Padcev and Keytruda that ended mid-June. I had a follow-up exam in July, and there was no more evidence of the tumor and all biopsies were negative. CT scans indicated that the tumor that was previously evident in February was no longer visible. This month I am starting radiation treatment to make sure any remnants of the cancer are eliminated. Admittedly, I am still early in this fight, but so far I am keeping my bladder and it's cancer free. I hope this gives your husband something to discuss with his urologist.

REPLY
Profile picture for jrh3 @jrh3

Your husband's situation sounds almost exactly like mine except that I am 70 years old. My MIBC was discovered in February. In late March I began the first of four cycles of treatment with Padcev and Keytruda that ended mid-June. I had a follow-up exam in July, and there was no more evidence of the tumor and all biopsies were negative. CT scans indicated that the tumor that was previously evident in February was no longer visible. This month I am starting radiation treatment to make sure any remnants of the cancer are eliminated. Admittedly, I am still early in this fight, but so far I am keeping my bladder and it's cancer free. I hope this gives your husband something to discuss with his urologist.

Jump to this post

@jrh3 Thank you for your post. My husband is in an identical situation to yours except he is a very fit 84 years old. He is on his 3rd cycle of Padcev and Keytruda and has told me he really doesn't want to have his bladder removed. Of course we don't know yet if this is even a possibility - but your post was encouraging and I will pass this on to him.

REPLY
Profile picture for anthemal @anthemal

@jrh3 Thank you for your post. My husband is in an identical situation to yours except he is a very fit 84 years old. He is on his 3rd cycle of Padcev and Keytruda and has told me he really doesn't want to have his bladder removed. Of course we don't know yet if this is even a possibility - but your post was encouraging and I will pass this on to him.

Jump to this post

@anthemal, Keytruda and Padcev is almost a miracle combo for metastatic bladder cancer. I am in complete remission. However, the Keytuda and neprostomy stents create an auto immune reaction with my bladder and major symptomolgy that has effected my lifestyle. As a healthcare professional, I did my homework and having a radical cystectomy in 2 weeks. We can all adapt.

REPLY

Ask about EVP. There are patients with EVP who retain their bladder if done at first notice of malignancy. Example of a more advance disease patient saving his bladder: https://www.treffertinnovations.com.

REPLY

My husband had MIBC with one positive lymph node 7 years ago. Treated at Mayo Clinic Rochester, BCG failure, Keytruda alone failure. With continued recurrences in bladder he went for the cure and had radical cystectomy/prostatectomy with neobladder. Lots of postop complications but ultimately he is satisfied with 3-4 times daily catheterization and no daytime incontinence. so far no recurrence elsewhere. There are more treatments available now than when he was offered tx. It is worth getting a second opinion even if it involves travel.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.