Hydroxychloroquine v methotrexate

Posted by mah7925 @mah7925, Dec 22, 2025

Anyone have experience with either drug to combat arthritis resulting from Keytruda?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Autoimmune Diseases Support Group.

Profile picture for 2penelope @2penelope

I was on Plaquenil for a long time to treat lupus. A few comments. It worked great. When my rheumatologist retired two years ago, I switched doctors and learned that the dosage he had prescribed was at least double what it should have been given my size and weight. The result, despite every six month eye exams, was damage to my retinas. I had to quit plaquenil which resulted in lots of fatigue, stiffness etc. I'm now on Benlysta which isn’t perfect but helping a lot.

My suggestion: be a strong advocate about dosage and get your eyes checked by a specialist who knows about this drug every six months, not annually. Finally, both my current rheumatologist and retinal specialist have told me that the patient shouldn’t be on plaquenil for more than 8-10 years, at most. I was on it for 13 years, my current doctors were truly horrified, and my former doctor never said anything or offered alternatives.

As always, educate yourself and be your own best advocate.

Jump to this post

@2penelope
Ugh, I should have searched about Plaquenil on this site a long time ago and finally just started searching and reading about Plaquenil users. I TOO was on Plaquenil for a long time. I was put on it in December 2010 and since then I have been taking 2x a day 200 mg. My rheumatologist has changed two times with me remaining on it at that dose. I remember the first rheumatologist who was excellent doctor, said at a certain point I would need to stop taking it. Then my replacement rheumatologist #2 just didn't raise it as being a big issue. Additionally Dr. #2 had to take me off Sulindac because after I had two ischemic strokes I had to go on Warfarin. So when my inflammation got bad she put me on Predisone daily doses up to 5 mg this year. About a year ago she said I had been on Plaquenil way longer than I should be using it. So I needed to get some big screenings done by an eye specialist. The good news is that nothing severe has showed up yet in my eyes, Soon after we started tests on my eyes Doctor #2 quit her job. I had to wait for a new rheumatologist #3 to get hired and catch up with my first appointment with the new rheumatologist. He was like, I must get you off the Plaquenil and no more steroids! That leaves me on zero medicines for lupus. In the meantime the eye specialist had inconclusive results of eye damage, but gave a very, very strong suggestion to the NEW rheumatologist to take me off Plaquenil after roughly 15 years.
A big concern I have is that I also am a warfarin patient, due to me having APS (of course that being related to the lupus) causing me to have 2 ischemic cerebellum strokes in 2022. I am worried about coming off the Plaquenil AND the Predisone at the same time sending me into a bad flare. I have been lucky to have NO flares since 2009-2010. I am starting to have more pain as my body's cells begin to eek out the medicine. I wish there were options for things to treat my lupus that do not interfere with the warfarin. Years ago I did take Celebrex, but as of right now all I am doing is large dose D3, Vitamin E and Fish Oil to remedy my increasing inflammation in my right hand, right hip, sometimes low back and neck, left knee and left foot. My first lupus flare actually attacked my rib cage and it was a combo of Lupus and Tietze's Syndrome. I had never hurt so bad in my life when that first flare happened. I hurt so badly I was afraid I was having a heart attack, and the pain was like nothing I had ever felt before. Going back to that kind of pain is something I thought would never ever happen, but now it could be back and is lurking right around the corner.

REPLY

I was on methotrexate, but my liver didn't like it, then hydroxy but I reckon it affected my eyesight, the rheumy doesn't think so and wants me back on it but I am not prepared to take a risk. and Im feeling it , where don't I hurt that would be the ?

REPLY
Profile picture for suzupergrrrl @suzupergrrrl

@2penelope
Ugh, I should have searched about Plaquenil on this site a long time ago and finally just started searching and reading about Plaquenil users. I TOO was on Plaquenil for a long time. I was put on it in December 2010 and since then I have been taking 2x a day 200 mg. My rheumatologist has changed two times with me remaining on it at that dose. I remember the first rheumatologist who was excellent doctor, said at a certain point I would need to stop taking it. Then my replacement rheumatologist #2 just didn't raise it as being a big issue. Additionally Dr. #2 had to take me off Sulindac because after I had two ischemic strokes I had to go on Warfarin. So when my inflammation got bad she put me on Predisone daily doses up to 5 mg this year. About a year ago she said I had been on Plaquenil way longer than I should be using it. So I needed to get some big screenings done by an eye specialist. The good news is that nothing severe has showed up yet in my eyes, Soon after we started tests on my eyes Doctor #2 quit her job. I had to wait for a new rheumatologist #3 to get hired and catch up with my first appointment with the new rheumatologist. He was like, I must get you off the Plaquenil and no more steroids! That leaves me on zero medicines for lupus. In the meantime the eye specialist had inconclusive results of eye damage, but gave a very, very strong suggestion to the NEW rheumatologist to take me off Plaquenil after roughly 15 years.
A big concern I have is that I also am a warfarin patient, due to me having APS (of course that being related to the lupus) causing me to have 2 ischemic cerebellum strokes in 2022. I am worried about coming off the Plaquenil AND the Predisone at the same time sending me into a bad flare. I have been lucky to have NO flares since 2009-2010. I am starting to have more pain as my body's cells begin to eek out the medicine. I wish there were options for things to treat my lupus that do not interfere with the warfarin. Years ago I did take Celebrex, but as of right now all I am doing is large dose D3, Vitamin E and Fish Oil to remedy my increasing inflammation in my right hand, right hip, sometimes low back and neck, left knee and left foot. My first lupus flare actually attacked my rib cage and it was a combo of Lupus and Tietze's Syndrome. I had never hurt so bad in my life when that first flare happened. I hurt so badly I was afraid I was having a heart attack, and the pain was like nothing I had ever felt before. Going back to that kind of pain is something I thought would never ever happen, but now it could be back and is lurking right around the corner.

Jump to this post

@suzupergrrrl I’m sorry to hear what you’ve been through. I’m on Benlysta and it’s helping a lot. Also, I started red light full body treatments two months ago. I go three times a week for 20 minutes each. My wrists and elbows aren’t aching like usual.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.