HRT alternate for ER/PR positive breast ca

Posted by trixie1313 @trixie1313, Feb 5, 2019

I am strongly ER and PR positive and have been told that I need to be on HRT following completion of 30 radiation treatments. I have clot history, osteoporosis, and small stroke history and not sure if I want to be on either AIs or tamoxifen. Anything else on the horizon? If I don't take these meds, does anyone know the percentage for recurrence this puts me at?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer group.

Just had my first check up and argument about the same thing! You r me! What stage were you? I was 1A. Everything else you wrote is me too! I tried arimidex for 2 3 weeks periods awful awful high blood pressure, joint aches….today I agreed to arimsan (sp)…he told me 10-20 % recurrence if I do not take….you also have to decide quality of life. I am 65 and have 4 young grandsons. I want to be able to play with them not just watch. Hugs to you and your decision

REPLY
@gwinter

Just had my first check up and argument about the same thing! You r me! What stage were you? I was 1A. Everything else you wrote is me too! I tried arimidex for 2 3 weeks periods awful awful high blood pressure, joint aches….today I agreed to arimsan (sp)…he told me 10-20 % recurrence if I do not take….you also have to decide quality of life. I am 65 and have 4 young grandsons. I want to be able to play with them not just watch. Hugs to you and your decision

Jump to this post

GWinter – thank you! I am Stage 1, grade 3 and 68. I was chemo resistant. The second lesion noted after first lumpectomy only shrunk 1 mm and so had second lumpectomy with reduction whereupon a third lesion was found in tissue pathology that never showed up on scans/MRI. One of the 2 sentinel nodes that was cancerous also eroded so my neck nodes had to be irradiated. I'm not good at drugs/medicine so just wish there was another way.

REPLY
@gwinter

Just had my first check up and argument about the same thing! You r me! What stage were you? I was 1A. Everything else you wrote is me too! I tried arimidex for 2 3 weeks periods awful awful high blood pressure, joint aches….today I agreed to arimsan (sp)…he told me 10-20 % recurrence if I do not take….you also have to decide quality of life. I am 65 and have 4 young grandsons. I want to be able to play with them not just watch. Hugs to you and your decision

Jump to this post

I've been on Arimidex for about 5 months now. Some bone and joint pain at first but it's settled down now and I'm okay with it. Switched from Femara, because of severe bone pain. Went without for a month, then took the Arimidex. Lost my hair with chemo, and it came back curly, but now it's straight and much thinner. I always had thick, wavy hair. Could be old age, too. Who knows?

REPLY

I feel same way…side effects of all hormone therapy are too painful and I have had osteoporosis and if I broke a home from these drugs, that would be end, of life as I now enjoy it. Also, I don't care to get another cancer….uterine from tamoxifen….also have heart problems and losing any more estrogen, which is good for the heart, might give me heart attack or worse! So I have not taken anything after lumpectomy. My oncologist d I'dif info test and score was 8….not too likely to recur…I was stage 2….did to microscopi c amt. Of cancer in first sentinel node….rest were clear. So I am just hoping and praying and forgetting I had cancer!!!!

REPLY

I was Stage 1, no node involvement (caught a lucky break there)…..I tried Tamoxifen, pre mastectomies, then tried Arimidex and Letrozole post bi lateral mastectomy.. With Letrozole I had severe joint pain, depression and although it might not be related — Shingles. I came off of it and went to Arimidex….again, joint pain, depression, fatigue and blood in my stools. So, the docs and I agreed that the meds seemed to be wearing me down so much everything that could possiblyy happen was going to happen. I had virtually every side effect…the ones I mentioned were the most pronounced.
I opted to go drug free unless I have a recurrence then I would consider the AI's. My cancer risk recurrence is 8% they say it would be about 4% with the drugs. I couldn't justify all the side effects and symptoms for so little gain. Hugs to all.

REPLY
@cindylb

I was Stage 1, no node involvement (caught a lucky break there)…..I tried Tamoxifen, pre mastectomies, then tried Arimidex and Letrozole post bi lateral mastectomy.. With Letrozole I had severe joint pain, depression and although it might not be related — Shingles. I came off of it and went to Arimidex….again, joint pain, depression, fatigue and blood in my stools. So, the docs and I agreed that the meds seemed to be wearing me down so much everything that could possiblyy happen was going to happen. I had virtually every side effect…the ones I mentioned were the most pronounced.
I opted to go drug free unless I have a recurrence then I would consider the AI's. My cancer risk recurrence is 8% they say it would be about 4% with the drugs. I couldn't justify all the side effects and symptoms for so little gain. Hugs to all.

Jump to this post

Pretty much my story….8% risk recurrence….drug free. If recurrance, I did not think you could use Als..hormone….thought it would go to stage 4

REPLY

I am in the same boat as a few of you. Triple positive, Stage 2- very lucky, lumpectomy, chemo, radiation, and now maintenance herceptin. Three weeks on Amiridex aged me 30 years. Possibility of recurrence improves with AIs, yes, but with low bone density already, I have to weigh benefits against bad side effects and weaker bones. I feel ya! I may start a new discussion thread with a clear name for those looking to explore options besides AI. 👍😘🤗

REPLY

I was on anastrozole 2 months before they had to take me off it . Too many bad side effects and I wasn’t able to live . You should talk to the dr . Some people have no problems with those drugs . Don’t be afraid of the dr it is your life and he gets paid

REPLY

Have you had Oncotypedx test? I believe that shows risk of recurrence. Ask oncologist….took 2 weeks for results.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.
  Request Appointment