Has anyone not used medication after First Dexa scan spine -2.8?

Posted by rmasters @rmasters, 2 days ago

I am 57, 5'2" and 110 pounds and have just had my first DEXA scan spinal -2.8 osteoporosis, femoral neck and hips -1.3. I exercise and eat well. I did go through surgical menopuase at 50. I have a blocked LAD artery and use injections of repatha for this. I am giving all these details because I really don't want to start any of these medications and wondering if anyone has ignored pressure from doctors, all of mine are encouraging Reclast. I am scared and tired of looking at all the pros and cons of everything. thank you in advance

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for samclembeau @samclembeau

I found this on the internet. just typed in shilajit for osteoporosis and this popped up. I just pulled out the highlights, but there is more information there.

shilajit shows significant scientific promise for protecting against osteoporosis and slowing bone loss. A landmark 48-week human clinical trial published in Phytotherapy Research demonstrated that daily shilajit supplementation successfully preserved bone mineral density (BMD) in postmenopausal women with osteopenia (the precursor to osteoporosis). While the placebo group experienced progressive bone loss, women taking shilajit saw a dose-dependent stabilization and improvement in their hip and spine density.

If you are already taking standard prescription osteoporosis medications—specifically bisphosphonates like alendronate (Fosamax) or risedronate (Actonel)—you must exercise strict caution.

Jump to this post

@samclembeau
Thank you! Sounds like it might be out for me. Already on Tymlos…

REPLY
Profile picture for dorob @dorob

@samclembeau
Thank you! Sounds like it might be out for me. Already on Tymlos…

Jump to this post

@dorob
I think there is a difference between promise and results…
Don’t really see where before and after tscores or BMD numbers are shown.

Overview of Shilajit
Shilajit is a natural substance found primarily in the Himalayan mountains, formed over centuries from decomposed plant material. It is rich in fulvic acid, which is believed to contribute to its potential health benefits.
Potential Health Benefits
Shilajit is associated with several health benefits, largely attributed to its fulvic acid content. These include:
Antioxidant Properties: Helps protect cells from oxidative stress.
Anti-inflammatory Effects: May reduce inflammation in the body.
Neuroprotective Effects: Potentially beneficial for cognitive health, particularly in conditions like Alzheimer's disease.
Energy and Stamina: Claims suggest it may enhance physical performance and reduce fatigue.
Hormonal Support: Some studies indicate it might help increase testosterone levels.
Scientific Evidence
While shilajit shows significant promise, the scientific evidence is still emerging. Key points include:
Preliminary Studies: Some small studies support its antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties.
Need for Robust Trials: More extensive clinical trials are necessary to confirm its safety and efficacy across diverse populations.
Conclusion
Shilajit is gaining attention for its potential health benefits, particularly due to its fulvic acid content. However, further research is essential to validate these claims and ensure safe usage.

Overview of Shilajit
Shilajit is a natural substance found primarily in the Himalayan mountains, formed over centuries from decomposed plant material. It is rich in fulvic acid, which is believed to contribute to its potential health benefits.
Potential Health Benefits
Shilajit is associated with several health benefits, largely attributed to its fulvic acid content. These include:
Antioxidant Properties: Helps protect cells from oxidative stress.
Anti-inflammatory Effects: May reduce inflammation in the body.
Neuroprotective Effects: Potentially beneficial for cognitive health, particularly in conditions like Alzheimer's disease.
Energy and Stamina: Claims suggest it may enhance physical performance and reduce fatigue.
Hormonal Support: Some studies indicate it might help increase testosterone levels.
Scientific Evidence
While shilajit shows significant promise, the scientific evidence is still emerging. Key points include:
Preliminary Studies: Some small studies support its antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties.
Need for Robust Trials: More extensive clinical trials are necessary to confirm its safety and efficacy across diverse populations.
Conclusion
Shilajit is gaining attention for its potential health benefits, particularly due to its fulvic acid content. However, further research is essential to validate these claims and ensure safe usage.

😀

REPLY
Profile picture for gracie7 @gracie7

Yes, I had my DEXA scan and chose not to go on any pharmaceutical medications; I have had no fractures (fingers crossed). I am on BHRT, changed up my diet to push the protein, take supplements suggested in Keith McCormicks book "Great Bones" and exercising as best I can with bothersome knees. I also sit on a power plate daily. My bone markers calculated out to be 124 so I am hoping what I am doing with bring that up. I am 75 y.o., 5'4" and weigh 120 so my BMI is on the low end of normal, but healthy. My DEXA showed -2.8 on both the femoral necks, the spine is still osteopenia and it says I do have strong bones. My doctor is doing this same program so that gives me confidence. Hope that helps. Best - Gracie

Jump to this post

REPLY

Thank you for your support. What is a power plate. Are they effective ? Something I should invest in
Thank you again

REPLY
Profile picture for ou14mejc @ou14mejc

@callmekate I rejected all these meds for 8 years, despite my doctors insisting that I needed it (early menopause). Both my hips and spine were bad on my DEXAs and my doctor kept telling me I would be in trouble if I ever broke a hip. I finally relented and just finished 2 years of Forteo injections in May. My spine improved from severe osteoporosis to osteopenia (-1.3) but my hips made a minimal improvement and are still in the osteoporosis range. In July, I started Evenity. I will have to decide in nine months what maintenance drug to start. Prolia and Reclast are the two my doctors are recommending. I cannot take Reclast because my kidneys aren't very good, so I suppose it will be Prolia. I rejected hormone replacement because my sister had breast cancer. I'm not sure it was the right decision since doctors are now saying hormone replacement does not cause breast cancer. These drugs are scary to all of us. I just tried to find the best rheumatologist and endocrinologist I could find and trust their judgment as to which drugs are the safest for me with my health condition. Good luck!

Jump to this post

REPLY

Thank you for your support. I’m hoping to find another doctor. They all will want to start some sort of medication. I don’t think any doctor would support supplements and exercise only unless it’s a homeopathic practitioner

REPLY
Profile picture for rose140 @rose140

Went to two different doctors for osteoporosis. Easy doctor recommended something different. I said no to both.
I’d rather deal with the consequences of my actions rather than hoping I don’t cause more health issues with their medications
Seems like it’s the luck of the draw who will have no reactions.

Jump to this post

@rose140

If "their medications" means osteoporosis medications like tymlos, forteo, evenity, fosomax, reclast and Prolia, then most people who take them do not have side effects. Most people who are using sites like these are experiencing side effects and are searching for answers to what treatment will work for them.

You might enjoy a group called OsteoBoston which is free and has wonderful on all topics concerning osteoporosis. They have a Zoom meeting each month (tomorrow is the next one) and then they are posted on YouTube.
If you want to receive updates from them, email Shelley at osteoboston@gmail.com.
Are you willing to share your dexa scores with the group here?

REPLY
Profile picture for rose140 @rose140

Thank you for your support. What is a power plate. Are they effective ? Something I should invest in
Thank you again

Jump to this post

@rose140

If you are talking about a vibration plate then go up the page to search 🔎 and type vibration plates.
Their is a great piece on melioguide.com about them

REPLY
Profile picture for rose140 @rose140

Thank you for your support. I’m hoping to find another doctor. They all will want to start some sort of medication. I don’t think any doctor would support supplements and exercise only unless it’s a homeopathic practitioner

Jump to this post

@rose140 Most of them do, but that just isn't enough, especially if the osteoporosis is severe. Mine all recommend supplements and exercise IN ADDITION to the bone shots. Weight bearing exercise is very important. Good luck in finding the right doctor you trust.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.