Food Sensitivity Testing - worth it or not?

Posted by debhammel @debhammel, Dec 12, 2023

I was diagnosed with collagenous colitis and pancreatic enzyme insufficiency in early November. Doing well on Budesonide and Creon but am wondering if it's worth the expense to do food sensitivity testing? I see some articles claiming that EnteroLab's testing is outstanding, and that it is a sham, and that Everlywell's testing is highly accurate and that it isn't. So far, I can identify that beans and raw veggies are a hard "no" for me, but I seem to tolerate everything else. Did the low FODMAP diet early in my journey for about a month, eliminating gluten and lactose, and saw no changes. Thoughts?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Digestive Health Support Group.

@debhammel The "food sensitivity testing" world is yet pretty undeveloped and unregulated, I'm not surprised you're having a hard time figuring out what to do. And trying "standard diets" like FODMAP do not account for individual sensitivities or interactions.
You have already begun your own sensitivity testing - why not continue? That is what my neighbor is doing because the results of her tests were "all over the place."
Do you have a list of foods that feel safe for you at this point? Devise an eating plan that includes those, preferably fresh/frozen and minimally processed. For example, an egg sandwich you prepare, not a frozen sausage & biscuit combo. Plain frozen veggies you cook and season, not the pre-sauced. Lean meat or fish you bake, broil, poach or panfry with your own seasonings - you get the idea.
Next make a list of foods that feel "questionable" to you based on your diagnosis and your history. Try to concentrate on high-value nutritious foods, or that you really miss if they are not in your diet. Then add one food at a time for a period of 3-5 days. If it goes OK, leave it in and move on to the next, if not, eliminate it & wait for your body to settle, then try the next.
Finally, remember all your beverages, spices, seasonings, oils, preservatives...
This is a process - one we have gone through repeatedly in our highly allergic family. I have learned some really interesting things - I do well with lactose free milk, but can also eat pure Greek yogurt and hard cheeses with no problem whatsoever. But protein supplements with whey in them give me issues. So I would say my body is "dairy selective." And I eat a gluten-free diet because I am allergic to wheat, but I tolerate modest amounts of pure rye flour in bread or plain barley in soup. I can eat one slice of fresh pineapple or 1/2 grapefruit, but then must let my body rest from it for 2-3 days before another.
It is a matter of patience and personal care.
What are you willing to try next?
Sue
PS I very rarely "cheat" because I hate the aftereffects. And my friends and acquaintances generally respect my choices.

REPLY
@sueinmn

@debhammel The "food sensitivity testing" world is yet pretty undeveloped and unregulated, I'm not surprised you're having a hard time figuring out what to do. And trying "standard diets" like FODMAP do not account for individual sensitivities or interactions.
You have already begun your own sensitivity testing - why not continue? That is what my neighbor is doing because the results of her tests were "all over the place."
Do you have a list of foods that feel safe for you at this point? Devise an eating plan that includes those, preferably fresh/frozen and minimally processed. For example, an egg sandwich you prepare, not a frozen sausage & biscuit combo. Plain frozen veggies you cook and season, not the pre-sauced. Lean meat or fish you bake, broil, poach or panfry with your own seasonings - you get the idea.
Next make a list of foods that feel "questionable" to you based on your diagnosis and your history. Try to concentrate on high-value nutritious foods, or that you really miss if they are not in your diet. Then add one food at a time for a period of 3-5 days. If it goes OK, leave it in and move on to the next, if not, eliminate it & wait for your body to settle, then try the next.
Finally, remember all your beverages, spices, seasonings, oils, preservatives...
This is a process - one we have gone through repeatedly in our highly allergic family. I have learned some really interesting things - I do well with lactose free milk, but can also eat pure Greek yogurt and hard cheeses with no problem whatsoever. But protein supplements with whey in them give me issues. So I would say my body is "dairy selective." And I eat a gluten-free diet because I am allergic to wheat, but I tolerate modest amounts of pure rye flour in bread or plain barley in soup. I can eat one slice of fresh pineapple or 1/2 grapefruit, but then must let my body rest from it for 2-3 days before another.
It is a matter of patience and personal care.
What are you willing to try next?
Sue
PS I very rarely "cheat" because I hate the aftereffects. And my friends and acquaintances generally respect my choices.

Jump to this post

Thank you, Sue, for your insightful and detailed response! My husband and I have been eating "cleanly" for many years: local, organic produce as much as possible, locally-raised/pastured/grassfed, etc. meat and poultry; very few desserts; not much in the way of alcohol; very minimal processed foods- you get the idea. Since my diagnosis I have learned that I can tolerate small amounts of dairy - half & half in my mostly decaf coffee, a splash of organic A2 milk in my tea, hard cheeses appear to be no problem, and the Good brand of cottage cheese is okay, too. Haven't tried yogurt yet, although I did buy some Greek yogurt recently and maybe that's the next food I will try.

I minimize gluten exposure; however, I am able to tolerate my homemade sourdough bread that I make with heritage wheat. Wine in small amounts (about a 3-4 oz pour) is okay with a meal and I limit that to weekends. For a while I went totally decaf free, dairy-free, gluten-free, alcohol free along with the low FODMAP stuff and when I wasn't seeing any changes in my symptoms I gradually added back in the items listed above. So far, beans and raw veggies are a definite "no" and I've noticed that even well-cooked broccoli gives me gas and bloating, so I'm avoiding that for now. Other veggies like corn, cabbage (well-cooked), green beans, winter squashes, carrots and avocado are well-tolerated, as are fruits like blueberries, bananas, and apples - haven't tried citrus yet except small amounts of lemon as a seasoning. But with all this, and the meds, I still experience more gassiness and bloating than is normal for me which is why I was considering the food sensitivity testing. While I was still heavily symptomatic, I noticed that there were many foods that just didn't appeal to me, so I followed my gut if you will, and ate what did appeal - and generally found that I was okay with those foods. I think I will continue to do this and see what happens as I taper off the Budenoside starting this weekend. I greatly appreciate your advice and information!

Debbie

REPLY
@sueinmn

@debhammel The "food sensitivity testing" world is yet pretty undeveloped and unregulated, I'm not surprised you're having a hard time figuring out what to do. And trying "standard diets" like FODMAP do not account for individual sensitivities or interactions.
You have already begun your own sensitivity testing - why not continue? That is what my neighbor is doing because the results of her tests were "all over the place."
Do you have a list of foods that feel safe for you at this point? Devise an eating plan that includes those, preferably fresh/frozen and minimally processed. For example, an egg sandwich you prepare, not a frozen sausage & biscuit combo. Plain frozen veggies you cook and season, not the pre-sauced. Lean meat or fish you bake, broil, poach or panfry with your own seasonings - you get the idea.
Next make a list of foods that feel "questionable" to you based on your diagnosis and your history. Try to concentrate on high-value nutritious foods, or that you really miss if they are not in your diet. Then add one food at a time for a period of 3-5 days. If it goes OK, leave it in and move on to the next, if not, eliminate it & wait for your body to settle, then try the next.
Finally, remember all your beverages, spices, seasonings, oils, preservatives...
This is a process - one we have gone through repeatedly in our highly allergic family. I have learned some really interesting things - I do well with lactose free milk, but can also eat pure Greek yogurt and hard cheeses with no problem whatsoever. But protein supplements with whey in them give me issues. So I would say my body is "dairy selective." And I eat a gluten-free diet because I am allergic to wheat, but I tolerate modest amounts of pure rye flour in bread or plain barley in soup. I can eat one slice of fresh pineapple or 1/2 grapefruit, but then must let my body rest from it for 2-3 days before another.
It is a matter of patience and personal care.
What are you willing to try next?
Sue
PS I very rarely "cheat" because I hate the aftereffects. And my friends and acquaintances generally respect my choices.

Jump to this post

I just read your blog and you have given me hope, after 2yrs of throwing up, after my last meal,every morning and 3 Gastros told there was nothing wrong with me, finally went to the VA HOSPITAL, I'm a veteran they sent me to the University of Miami, they did the myotomy test and told me I have ACHALASIA TYPE 2, BASICALLY THEY SAID YOUR ESOPHAGUS IS PARALYZED AND YOUR SHINXSTER IS CLOSED, AND HAD TO HAVE THE PROCEDURE POEM, SO THEY BASICALLY CUT THROUGH MY ESOPHAGUS AND CUT THE SPHINCTER OPEN, AND NOW I CANNOT EAT,BECAUSE IMMEDIATELY I GET SO NAUSEOUS AND HAVE TO THROW UP, SO FAR I HAVE NOT EATEN FOR ABOUT 9 DAYS I DON'T HAVE AN APPETITE, I HAVE LOST ABOUT 20PDS, IAM SO DEPRESSED, DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO, 🤮😵‍💫🥺😭💀💀please HELP

REPLY

As I age I notice foods bothering more. I keep a food diary. But don’t overlook the effect stress and anxiety can have on your gut! I can vomit just from anxiety.

REPLY
@lizziel1

As I age I notice foods bothering more. I keep a food diary. But don’t overlook the effect stress and anxiety can have on your gut! I can vomit just from anxiety.

Jump to this post

I've been keeping a detailed food/activity diary including bowel habits and meds since all this started back in early September. Despite all the detail, I'm unable to tie specific foods to my symptoms. It's at a minimum annoying because I'm concerned that as I start to taper off the Budesonide, I'll be right back where I started from. We'll see. I know this is a process and a journey, so will try to be patient.

REPLY
@debhammel

I've been keeping a detailed food/activity diary including bowel habits and meds since all this started back in early September. Despite all the detail, I'm unable to tie specific foods to my symptoms. It's at a minimum annoying because I'm concerned that as I start to taper off the Budesonide, I'll be right back where I started from. We'll see. I know this is a process and a journey, so will try to be patient.

Jump to this post

It is annoying isn't it - my issue isn't with digestion as much as allergy, and things "lurk".

One thing I figure out a few years ago, quite by accident - a hidden culprit - is "sugar alcohols" - sorbitol, mannitol and xylitol, among others, that can cause me days of pain and problems. Often found in chewing gums and "reduced sugar" foods...

Sue

REPLY
@achalasia2

I just read your blog and you have given me hope, after 2yrs of throwing up, after my last meal,every morning and 3 Gastros told there was nothing wrong with me, finally went to the VA HOSPITAL, I'm a veteran they sent me to the University of Miami, they did the myotomy test and told me I have ACHALASIA TYPE 2, BASICALLY THEY SAID YOUR ESOPHAGUS IS PARALYZED AND YOUR SHINXSTER IS CLOSED, AND HAD TO HAVE THE PROCEDURE POEM, SO THEY BASICALLY CUT THROUGH MY ESOPHAGUS AND CUT THE SPHINCTER OPEN, AND NOW I CANNOT EAT,BECAUSE IMMEDIATELY I GET SO NAUSEOUS AND HAVE TO THROW UP, SO FAR I HAVE NOT EATEN FOR ABOUT 9 DAYS I DON'T HAVE AN APPETITE, I HAVE LOST ABOUT 20PDS, IAM SO DEPRESSED, DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO, 🤮😵‍💫🥺😭💀💀please HELP

Jump to this post

Welcome, @achalasia2. you sounds like you need expert medical care. If you would like to get a second opinion from Mayo Clinic experts, you can request an appointment at Mayo Clinic. Hopefully, the Jacksonville Florida location might be an option for you. Click this link to talk with a scheduler http://mayocl.in/1mtmR63

If you would like to connect with other people living with achalasia, you might wish to join one of these discussions:
– POEM Surgery for Achalasia: https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/two-months-after-poem-surgery-for-achalasia/
– Achalasia Chronic pain: https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/achalesia-chronic-pain/
- End-Stage Achalasia. Anyone been there? https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/end-stage-achalasia-anyone-been-there/

REPLY
@sueinmn

It is annoying isn't it - my issue isn't with digestion as much as allergy, and things "lurk".

One thing I figure out a few years ago, quite by accident - a hidden culprit - is "sugar alcohols" - sorbitol, mannitol and xylitol, among others, that can cause me days of pain and problems. Often found in chewing gums and "reduced sugar" foods...

Sue

Jump to this post

Yes - I eliminated sugar alcohols when my GI doc suspected I had IBS - early in this journey. No idea if that helped or not, but I don't see any reason to resume ingesting these 🙂

REPLY

I’ve had a food sensitivity test done. And when I cut the foods out that I was sensitive to, my symptoms went away. My granddaughter actually had one that was ordered by her PCP. They thought her issues were caused by grease but it’s actually the type of grease, such as corn and soybean.
I can’t say it would benefit everyone but it did me.

REPLY
@cpd54

I’ve had a food sensitivity test done. And when I cut the foods out that I was sensitive to, my symptoms went away. My granddaughter actually had one that was ordered by her PCP. They thought her issues were caused by grease but it’s actually the type of grease, such as corn and soybean.
I can’t say it would benefit everyone but it did me.

Jump to this post

Which tests did you and your granddaughter have? I've been looking at Everlywell and EnteroLabs but am concerned about accuracy. About 15 years ago I had this done through US Biotek, which requires a doctor's order and am leaning towards that one if I can convince my medical provider to write the order.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.