Thank you for letting me know you moved my question to the appropriate place.
I did start physical therapy immediately after my knee replacement therapy which lasted four months. It did not reduce my swelling at all, but my knee pain diminished a great deal during that time. Additionally, I returned to swimming 3 to 5 times a week 2 or 3 months after my surgery. I had to stop swimming about 4 months ago because it exacerbated the pain so much.

Hi @rosiegirl, I would like to add my welcome to Connect along with @colleenyoung and other members. I'm 2 months post op from a total knee replacement for my right knee. I have not had the pain that you have experienced but my ankle and leg are still quite swollen although the knee itself is not as bad. Part of my swelling issue is that I also have lymphedema and need to wear compression socks to help keep the swelling down.

Have you discussed the popping and the knee bent backwards a few times with your doctor? I would want to know if there was a possibility that the knee might have been re-injured. I had some issues sleeping due to some aching in my knee (not real sharp pains) when I got back from the hospital from the knee surgery. What has helped me was a really small fluffy travel pillow that I keep between my knees/legs. Another thing that helped the swelling was to elevate and ice the leg several times a day, keeping the leg at eye level by laying on the couch with a large pillow under the leg.

@rosiegirl I am really sorry to hear of the problems you having with your knee. I was in a lot of pain for about four weeks and around then it started improving and I was great at the six-week mark.
For you to have this much pain still really does not sound right. Have you sought a second opinion? I think I would do that if I had that much pain, preferably one from a really top ortho at an excellent medical center. I have no idea if having sciatica could contribute to your pain or now, that is not a problem I have had.
As @colleenyoung mentioned, I am a huge advocate of water exercise, and also the recumbent bike. When I was talking to my ortho I asked him about the best exercises and coincidentally these are two of the exercises he considers best also. I continue to do both of those but now I also do other exercises in the gym at my health club.
I really hope you find a top doctor to get a second opinion from. You should not have to deal with this much pain for so long.
JK

The surgeon who did the TKN retired only 6 months after my surgery (he was only 60!). I am not happy with the surgeon to whom he referred me, so I am scheduled next week to see a surgeon my family doc recommended. I had been swimming until about 2 or 3 months ago, when it became too painful to do so. Had to stop exercising except for a few core exercises.
Thank you for your response.

@rosiegirl I hope the new doctor can help you, but if not do not give up. I have found that sometimes doctors are influenced by personal feelings toward a doctor. I have had that happen a couple of times. Check out the doctor's ratings on things like Vitals and Healthgrades. I never believe the ratings unless there are a substantial number of them though.
JK

John, thank you for your response. I've iced the knee, but that made no dofference. I've always found icing swelling hlps, but not this time. The doctor who operated retited not long after my surgery, and when this all started, the surgeon to whom he referred me told me it would go away. Not going back there. I was able to make an appointment next week for a surgeon referred by my family physician. I've always slept with a pillow under my knees or between them while lying on my side because of back issues, so that hasn't provided any relief. The replacement itself was successful, so I am flummoxed at the amount of pain so long after the surgery.
Someone recently reminded me of my extreme sensitivity to nickel. Many knee replacements, although mostly titanium, do contain some nickel. My cousin had the same problem and eventually had to get a new, nickel-free knee. I am really hoping it is not that or anything else that that requires another surgery.

I hope your swelling eventually dissapates.

Hi @rosiegirl – I want to add my Welcome to the others. Glad you are here on Connect! It must be awfully discouraging to have the pain/swelling you have had and THEN have your doctor retire. I'm glad you are seeing another surgeon. I've had two TKRs – one in 2017 and the last one earlier this year. My surgeon told me that many people have problems kneeling after surgery. That has been true for me. He also said that many people report that kind of popping or clicking noise. I have not had that. So while I wouldn't necessarily be too concerned about the kneeling or the sound, I would be worried about the bending backwards, the pain and the continued swelling. It sounds as if you are doing all you can do to get to the bottom of the problem. Have you prepared a list of questions for your new doctor? If I were you, I would jot some down – along with some of the things you have told us here like when you had to quit swimming and how the pain has gotten worse and worse (not better and better). If you are anything like me, I have the timeline and questions in my head, but the facts don't necessarily make it out of my mouth when the doctor steps in. Will you let us know how your new doctor visit goes?

It seems that mznyndoctors really don't listen, which is the problem I had with the doctor referred by my original orthopedist. I agree about the ratings. The surgeon I will be seeing has excellent ratings, and my family physician told me other patients of his were very happy with him. . Additionally he is the team sports doc for local university's teams. Keeping my fingers crossed.

Thank you

I have experienced the popping since my TKR, but until a few months ago it was not associated with any pain. Something has definitely changed, and I am hoping that this new surgeon will be able to help me. If not, I'll keep searching for a resolution. I already have a script prepared for the new orthopedist. I want to make sure I don't leave anything out.

Thank you.

@rosiegirl It sounds as if you are doing all of the right things. Generally, orthos who do sports teams are very good.

@debbraw is right — prepare a list and make sure you get through the list. I had a PCP appointment a couple of weeks ago and afterward, I realized I had neglected to put a couple of things on my list. I try to remember to jot them down as I think of them, but I sometimes tell myself that I will remember, and then I don't.

I hope you will let us know how the appointment goes, and that the new doctor finds something that he can help you with.
JK

HI Everyone, It does seem that knee discomfort and pain continue for a long while for some people. I'm 4 months out and have extremely tight bands around my knee. I had relief for about a week when taking Meloxicam but it all came back. I walk and exercise but fine it easer to do things if I warm up first. i.e. leg on ball with strap under foot gently back and forth. So it seems not to go away. My pt offered "Ive never seen anyone lay down scar tissue like you." So I guess keep moving.

Hi all – Add me to the list of people with long "recoveries." I had my surgery just a few days after rosiegirl — July 2018 — and continue to encounter problems. I have pain with stairs, especially going downstairs when my (right) surgery leg is the one behind, if that makes sense. Overall though, my knee is getting *much* better when in the car, sitting, and walking, but it still feels strange. I attribute recent improvement to at home PT/stationary bike and to finding a *gentle* physical therapist who practiced cupping, myofascial release, and massage. Her work really made a difference. I can also relate to rosiegirl's sensitive scar – I went through the entire winter unable to wear *anything* that rubbed my scar, tights, jeans, everything. It made life pretty miserable. Only now can I wear jeans, etc. This entire experience has made me willing to do *anything* to avoid having my L knee replaced. I hear there are gel-type injections, now being used instead of cortisone shots. I think that's my next step.

@babette I'm glad to hear that things are getting better for your knee. I feel so fortunate to not have encountered any of the problems mentioned. My scar was never sensitive, and other than not having quite as much flex as I would like I couldn't ask for more. They say every TKR is different. I can understand your reluctance to undergo another but just because you struggled with one does not mean a second one would cause the same problems. I have even heard of people having bi-lateral TKRs and the two knees being totally different in recovery.
JK

@babette I'm 5 months post-op bilateral and have plenty of pain in right knee, left is getting better. The therapist I see is like yours with the gentle bending and myofascial release. What has cupping done for you? My scars are sensitive too, I've cut a lot of my pants off at the knee! I've been wearing shorts since January.

Although my swelling never went down after my surgery, the pain was minimal. It's only been weeks, almost 2 years since the TKR, that the pain has started to impact my mobility and ability to sleep. I have not gone back to PT. I am waiting until I see the surgeon before doing anything.
I hope that you find relief soon and your swelling starts lessening soon.
Thank you.