Can walking be accomplished without a hip or hip replacement?

Posted by stargirl13 @stargirl13, Dec 17, 2023

I had to have 8 surgeries this year for a hip replacement which didn’t take due to bacteria. I ended up with MRSA so bad it took many additional surgeries to clean it out over and over, they finally made the decision to just remove the hip replacement and clean it all out again and not replace it. It bought me almost a whole year in a care center and much physical and mental anguish. They don’t want to put another replacement in and I personally don’t want one. I want to live without one , but I’m wondering how do I go about walking again with the assistance of maybe just a cane? I’m currently using a Walker around my house and a wheelchair when I go out shopping or to events, I can’t stand or walk for too long without dealing with major pain. I also have one leg longer than the other now so I am also wondering if a shoe lift could help out my situation in the future if I try and walk with just a cane.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Bones, Joints & Muscles Support Group.

@cmarsh

Anyone interested in another shoe alternative, could try the "Even up" available on Amazon for about $30. I use it on my tennis shoes right now until I find the right sole I want to glue on. I also used it on my Merrell slides too in the beginning and it worked. I'll try to attach picture also....Cindy

Jump to this post

Also very interesting. My issue is that the length of my leg is at least 3-4 inches shorter than the other. I fear that the amount I would have to build up one shoe would be a very high platform. For example I would need to double up that product. Yikes!

REPLY
@janeen17

Also very interesting. My issue is that the length of my leg is at least 3-4 inches shorter than the other. I fear that the amount I would have to build up one shoe would be a very high platform. For example I would need to double up that product. Yikes!

Jump to this post

Hi Janeen...my leg is about 2.5 to 3 inches shorter, depending on the day and how much I stretch it....haha. I find in my circumstance, if I get my legs close to the same length it makes a huge difference in my walking and/or putting stress on other body parts. Right after surgery, I just put a sore bought lift in my shoe, then as things settled somewhat, we started with adding soles to shoes. Even when you get the approximate height correct, the knees still don't line up as its your upper leg that has shortened so you still have that issue. Sometimes there is stress on my knees so I use a small knee or IT band strap or a sleeve in my knee. I have a lot of arthritis in all my joints. I do exercises daily to keep my muscles as strong as possible for that reason. You definitely want to keep your unaffected leg as strong as possible as it has to do more of the work, therefore, I exercise both legs equally. In the beginning, I had my husband gently pull on my bad leg to stretch it while laying on the bed. Now I just use my good leg to stretch the bad one by curling my foot on it. I don't do it to the point of any pain....but just a nice gentle stretch that feels good. All this was done by physical therapy in the beginning, but I've adapted a lot so I can do it myself now. When was your surgery?

REPLY

Hi. I’m 75, live in Portugal and am a UK citizen. I had a hip replacement in October 2022 at a private clinic in Portugal. After 2 weeks I got a terrible infection (came on very suddenly). I went to my local state owned hospital and was transferred to nearby orthopaedic hospital (also part of the national health system in Portugal). The surgeon told me my immune system had failed and said I was lucky to be alive. Very soon the hip was removed and a spacer fitted. I was allowed home two months later. The care was excellent by the way. They monitored me closely for some months and then I was admitted for a second hip replacement in late August 2023. I was told that the risks of failure were quite a bit higher than with the first hip, but worth pursuing. Unfortunately, I got an infection about 10 weeks later. The surgeon removed the hip and now I have no hip joint. He said the risk is now even higher and he was concerned with the risk of death. I started physiotherapy a few days after the operation - very gently at first because it was painful. That was early November 2023. I was kept in for 1 month, requiring IV antibiotics every day. I was sent home and continued with IV antibiotics, administered by a travelling nurse for another month. I’ve since had blood tests once a month and I visit the surgeon once a month for a short consultation (at the hospital) - not sure how long this will continue, but probably several more months. This is to monitor any lingering infection.
Since I arrived home in December I’ve had regular physiotherapy. I can walk well with a walking frame and/or crutches and can do stairs with one crutch and a handrail. I can also drive. Luckily I’ve had very little pain. My aim is to get stronger and see how much mobility I can finally achieve. I’m hoping, but not pinning my hopes, that I will eventually walk with just one crutch or a stick. Time will tell. I’m going to ask my surgeon for advice on a special shoe to compensate for leg length difference. I’m optimistic but also realistic. I’m quite pleased with my progress so far (3.5 months after leaving hospital). I’m lucky to have a wife who does almost all the chores. Hopefully I’ll be able to help a little in the future.
Finding this site has been really helpful and encouraging. I’ve learnt so much from all those who have contributed. Thank you so much.

REPLY
@terrylis

Hi. I’m 75, live in Portugal and am a UK citizen. I had a hip replacement in October 2022 at a private clinic in Portugal. After 2 weeks I got a terrible infection (came on very suddenly). I went to my local state owned hospital and was transferred to nearby orthopaedic hospital (also part of the national health system in Portugal). The surgeon told me my immune system had failed and said I was lucky to be alive. Very soon the hip was removed and a spacer fitted. I was allowed home two months later. The care was excellent by the way. They monitored me closely for some months and then I was admitted for a second hip replacement in late August 2023. I was told that the risks of failure were quite a bit higher than with the first hip, but worth pursuing. Unfortunately, I got an infection about 10 weeks later. The surgeon removed the hip and now I have no hip joint. He said the risk is now even higher and he was concerned with the risk of death. I started physiotherapy a few days after the operation - very gently at first because it was painful. That was early November 2023. I was kept in for 1 month, requiring IV antibiotics every day. I was sent home and continued with IV antibiotics, administered by a travelling nurse for another month. I’ve since had blood tests once a month and I visit the surgeon once a month for a short consultation (at the hospital) - not sure how long this will continue, but probably several more months. This is to monitor any lingering infection.
Since I arrived home in December I’ve had regular physiotherapy. I can walk well with a walking frame and/or crutches and can do stairs with one crutch and a handrail. I can also drive. Luckily I’ve had very little pain. My aim is to get stronger and see how much mobility I can finally achieve. I’m hoping, but not pinning my hopes, that I will eventually walk with just one crutch or a stick. Time will tell. I’m going to ask my surgeon for advice on a special shoe to compensate for leg length difference. I’m optimistic but also realistic. I’m quite pleased with my progress so far (3.5 months after leaving hospital). I’m lucky to have a wife who does almost all the chores. Hopefully I’ll be able to help a little in the future.
Finding this site has been really helpful and encouraging. I’ve learnt so much from all those who have contributed. Thank you so much.

Jump to this post

The shoe will help tremendously for you. Helped me with pain when I figured out my leg was shorter after replacement. I live north of Seattle, Washington, USA. I saw several podiatrists to get something for the bottom of shoes on the outside because an orthotic was too tight on the inside. The podiatrists where not helpful so I figured it out. Before surgery I was using a walker with my hip fractured horizontally almost 2 inches. This happened during Covid so I had to wait over a year to have it fixed. I started going to a swimming pool. After 9 months I can easily swim 60 laps or 1 k. It is great you are doing your therapy. You have a real positive attitude and want to improve. There is a lady 97 that swims with me and many people in there 70-90's who were in rough shape like me when they started. I wish you all the best.

REPLY
@janeen17

Also very interesting. My issue is that the length of my leg is at least 3-4 inches shorter than the other. I fear that the amount I would have to build up one shoe would be a very high platform. For example I would need to double up that product. Yikes!

Jump to this post

HI, After hip surgery my leg was quite a bit shorter. Podiatrists were no help so I took the sole off of a shoe and duck taped it to the bottom of another shoe just to see. It helps so much with balance and standing evenly. Putting a lift in was too tight.

REPLY
@drorvick

The shoe will help tremendously for you. Helped me with pain when I figured out my leg was shorter after replacement. I live north of Seattle, Washington, USA. I saw several podiatrists to get something for the bottom of shoes on the outside because an orthotic was too tight on the inside. The podiatrists where not helpful so I figured it out. Before surgery I was using a walker with my hip fractured horizontally almost 2 inches. This happened during Covid so I had to wait over a year to have it fixed. I started going to a swimming pool. After 9 months I can easily swim 60 laps or 1 k. It is great you are doing your therapy. You have a real positive attitude and want to improve. There is a lady 97 that swims with me and many people in there 70-90's who were in rough shape like me when they started. I wish you all the best.

Jump to this post

Thank you for the advice. I’ll try soon with a built up shoe. Swimming sounds a great idea. I could get in the pool, but not sure I could get out 😂. Good to hear there are plenty of people trying hard. I’m curious to see how much better I can get. I’ll keep plodding along, doing the exercises, etc. I think I’m very lucky that I have hardly any pain - just a little discomfort if I over do it. You also have a positive attitude and I wish you all the best too.

REPLY

The pool I go to has a chair lift on the side for people who need it to get in and out of the pool. It runs on battery power. Check to see if your pool might have one. They have one for the hot tub too. I only stay in that 5 minutes. Wish you the best. Doreen

REPLY
@terrylis

Hi. I’m 75, live in Portugal and am a UK citizen. I had a hip replacement in October 2022 at a private clinic in Portugal. After 2 weeks I got a terrible infection (came on very suddenly). I went to my local state owned hospital and was transferred to nearby orthopaedic hospital (also part of the national health system in Portugal). The surgeon told me my immune system had failed and said I was lucky to be alive. Very soon the hip was removed and a spacer fitted. I was allowed home two months later. The care was excellent by the way. They monitored me closely for some months and then I was admitted for a second hip replacement in late August 2023. I was told that the risks of failure were quite a bit higher than with the first hip, but worth pursuing. Unfortunately, I got an infection about 10 weeks later. The surgeon removed the hip and now I have no hip joint. He said the risk is now even higher and he was concerned with the risk of death. I started physiotherapy a few days after the operation - very gently at first because it was painful. That was early November 2023. I was kept in for 1 month, requiring IV antibiotics every day. I was sent home and continued with IV antibiotics, administered by a travelling nurse for another month. I’ve since had blood tests once a month and I visit the surgeon once a month for a short consultation (at the hospital) - not sure how long this will continue, but probably several more months. This is to monitor any lingering infection.
Since I arrived home in December I’ve had regular physiotherapy. I can walk well with a walking frame and/or crutches and can do stairs with one crutch and a handrail. I can also drive. Luckily I’ve had very little pain. My aim is to get stronger and see how much mobility I can finally achieve. I’m hoping, but not pinning my hopes, that I will eventually walk with just one crutch or a stick. Time will tell. I’m going to ask my surgeon for advice on a special shoe to compensate for leg length difference. I’m optimistic but also realistic. I’m quite pleased with my progress so far (3.5 months after leaving hospital). I’m lucky to have a wife who does almost all the chores. Hopefully I’ll be able to help a little in the future.
Finding this site has been really helpful and encouraging. I’ve learnt so much from all those who have contributed. Thank you so much.

Jump to this post

Hi....I'm 2 years now without a hip also. My husband has been wonderful through all this. He glues soles from one shoe onto another for me and it works great for my 2.5-3 inch leg length issue. I continue to do daily exercises to keep all supporting muscles as strong as possible. I did overdo it last fall and I tore meniscus on my "good leg" as well as arthritis is giving me a problem on that leg as well. Of course my "good leg" has more stress on it than the other, as it carries more of the weight. I'm optimistic I can get that pain under control and I want to walk with just a cane or 1 crutch someday. Wishing you wellness.....Cindy

REPLY
@cmarsh

Hi....I'm 2 years now without a hip also. My husband has been wonderful through all this. He glues soles from one shoe onto another for me and it works great for my 2.5-3 inch leg length issue. I continue to do daily exercises to keep all supporting muscles as strong as possible. I did overdo it last fall and I tore meniscus on my "good leg" as well as arthritis is giving me a problem on that leg as well. Of course my "good leg" has more stress on it than the other, as it carries more of the weight. I'm optimistic I can get that pain under control and I want to walk with just a cane or 1 crutch someday. Wishing you wellness.....Cindy

Jump to this post

Yeah I’ve had no luck walking without a walker unfortunately, I’m hoping to someday but it’s not looking too good, seems impossible to ever walk again without the assistance of something to help you for the rest of your life, I refuse to get a replacement after all the grief, infection and damage the last one caused, I currently use a wheelchair to go out to events and even do something as simple as grocery shopping as advised by my surgeon….its a long hard road….Im hoping to have somewhat of a recovery someday. Good luck to you.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.