Ice Therapy Machines

Posted by doll53 @doll53, Aug 5, 2023

Hello, group! I’m new here. I bought an ice therapy machine to use after my TKR only to find out my doctor doesn’t approve of them. He won’t give me any guidance on how long on and how long off to use it, how often, etc. All I can find online is follow your doctor’s recommendations. Anybody use one and if so, how did you use it? Can’t find any negatives about it. Had 3 therapists tell me they’re great. But they work for the hospital/doctor, so….
Thanks!

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Joint Replacements Support Group.

@heyjoe415

Your Dr didn't recommend physical therapy AFTER a TKR??????? Get a new surgeon.

Jump to this post

He's a really good surgeon and everyone who has had him recommends him highly. He has no bedside manner but I was more concerned with his expertise. He did order it for me and actually wrote orders for 3 months which I did do so he really has been good. He's an older Dr. and thinks most can do things at home and many prefer it (not sure who though lol)

REPLY

Well as long as you're happy with him Cindy, that's all that matters.

It's my experience that TKR surgeons see disappointing results because their patients simply don't do the work required. They seem to believe that surgery is magic and they should be out dancing in a month. Reality is very different.

Now cynicism shouldn't be part of a Dr's practice, but after years of hearing mostly unfounded complaints, I can see where he would tire of it and save the therapists' time for more serious patients. My surgeon made it clear that while great surgical technique is critical, the majority of the work lies with the patient.

And that's why I always choose younger surgeons - mid 30s to mid 40s. They are up on the new developments in the field, and they want patients to succeed and haven't had time to become disillusioned.

REPLY
@roxxxy2626

Hello,
I have had 4 joint replacements in 2 1/2 years (2 hips and 2 knees). I'm 54 years old with osteoarthritis. I'm 16 weeks out on my right knee and 9 weeks out on the left knee. I used ice packs that were flexible to go around your knee I had four different kinds of ice packs and they were still cheaper than the ice machine that doesn't seem to get very cold. I had rented an ice machine on my first hip replacement replacement, I wasn't a fan of it.

Jump to this post

Good point that the machines do not get as cold as good ol' ice packs. I used the machine after pt sessions but would not pay 3 or 4 grand for one of these.

REPLY

I've had both knees replaced and tomorrow a total shoulder replacement. I loved the ice machine for knees. Gradually transitioned to soft ice packs. My post op instructions for tomorrow are to use rhe ice machine for 20 minutes on, 40 minutes off at least 6 times a day. To be truthful I use the ice more than that. The main thing is whatever the source of cold, always protect your skin with toweling.

REPLY
@heyjoe415

Good point that the machines do not get as cold as good ol' ice packs. I used the machine after pt sessions but would not pay 3 or 4 grand for one of these.

Jump to this post

@roxxxy2626
The doctor ordered our ice machine and we paid $175 and it is more than worth it,

REPLY

Has anyone here used a Game Ready ice machine? My surgeon recommended one for my total knee replacement post-op and i rented one for 2 months. Hip to ankle sleeve; 20 minutes on and 1 hour off, i had next to no problems achieving extension. For the first few days after the surgery i also had a nerve block catheter and that also helped with pain control, which allowed me to initially extend my leg to fit the straight sleeve.

REPLY

My insurance covered it and it was wonderful. I would fill it in the morning and it would stay cold and ice all day. I gradually switched to a soft pack but for the first month it was invaluable

REPLY

My ice therapy machine is the original CryoCuff, circa 1994? It has been used by me for over a half dozen surgeries, and by others dozens of times. When I got it, the insurance company balked and the knee surgeon insisted - it cost $125. It lacks the pump in the machines now - it was a simple gravity feed - open the valve and lift the bucket to fill the cuff, then close the valve. When it was time to change the water, open the valve and let gravity drain the water, swirl the bucket to get the water ice cold again, and repeat. It held the ice all day so I could go back to work right after ACL/MCL replacement (back then I was young and foolish - now I would take my allotted time off!), traveled with me on business trips, and allowed my husband to sleep through the night after my hips surgeries - no running to the freezer for new ice packs. I even used it as a hand wrap after one of my wrist surgeries!
I am a fan - and if it ever fails, no doubt a newer version will replace it, but it is so simple that I doubt it will.
Sue

REPLY
@ack0205

I am 4 and a half months TKR. I used the ice machine frequently for the first 3 months. It was great for pain relief and swelling reduction. I set the machine to run for 30 minutes and off for thirty minutes. I found it to be extremely important for my recovery. I still occasionally use it after going to the gym for a pilates class or strength class. Hope you find relief using it as well.

Jump to this post

30 on, 30 off…..thanks!

REPLY
@heyjoe415

Good point that the machines do not get as cold as good ol' ice packs. I used the machine after pt sessions but would not pay 3 or 4 grand for one of these.

Jump to this post

I feel like it doesn’t work as well as ice, but on the other hand, ice packs get warm in a half hour…..not the ice therapy machine. I was just worried that I’d do it too long and cause harm. I think I’m not doing it long enough or maybe not often enough. It does feel very good after therapy. Mine was around $200.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.