What's a good answer to How are you? when you're in bad pain?

Posted by tyyne21wigwam @tyyne21wigwam, Mar 7, 2023

Should you answer fine if you really aren't

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Chronic Pain Support Group.

@rwinney

If you want the scoop right from Mayo Clinic Pain Rehabilitation Center - Dr. Sletten teaches it's okay to say you are having difficult day. No explanation needed. It's good to have one person that you can talk to honestly but no one else needs to know all the details of what you're going through. He teaches about "pain behaviors" which is anything you do say or think that reminds you of pain, and explains that talking about symptoms accesses your pain pathways and can lead to more pain.

I like to reverse the question by answering I'm fine, or doing well, then ask how are you how , how are the children , how is your new job?

Jump to this post

This really helped! Thanks for your reply. I hadn't thought about the idea of adding pain by reiterating the problem

REPLY

It does matter who’s asking the question. Our self image and the image we allow others to see is often different, sometimes quite different. Honesty is the path of least resistance but with chronic pain it can be telling.

REPLY
@rwinney

If you want the scoop right from Mayo Clinic Pain Rehabilitation Center - Dr. Sletten teaches it's okay to say you are having difficult day. No explanation needed. It's good to have one person that you can talk to honestly but no one else needs to know all the details of what you're going through. He teaches about "pain behaviors" which is anything you do say or think that reminds you of pain, and explains that talking about symptoms accesses your pain pathways and can lead to more pain.

I like to reverse the question by answering I'm fine, or doing well, then ask how are you how , how are the children , how is your new job?

Jump to this post

Yes, diversion from the truth is good politics and with the truth is even better.
Thank you! Honestly!

REPLY

I say, "Status Quo" or "Another Day of the Same"

REPLY
@tedjones77494

It does matter who’s asking the question. Our self image and the image we allow others to see is often different, sometimes quite different. Honesty is the path of least resistance but with chronic pain it can be telling.

Jump to this post

So true, Ted. I work on treating myself with kindness and grace. Through cognitive behavioral therapy I learned that I needed to talk to myself like I talk to others with encouragement, support and care. Taking my own advice through positive self-talk has helped a lot. I try to think about how would I talk to my kids in this moment. And that's how I should treat myself. It's a work in progress somedays more than others but that's ok.

How do you talk to yourself?

REPLY

yo digo "de la patada" porque estoy sufriendo de artritis reumatoidea por mas de 2 anos

REPLY
@mikaylar

I say, "Status Quo" or "Another Day of the Same"

Jump to this post

Hi Mikayla and all -
One thing I learned was that I am more than my pain, and got sick of letting pain define me. Cognitive behavioral therapy helped teach that I was still a person with abilities and interests, and could choose to not be defined by pain by shifting focus, mindset and working towards mindfulness and gratitude. I learned that I could teach my friends and family how I wanted to be spoken to. For example, I asked them to stop asking me how I was "feeling" and start asking me how I was "doing". Living with chronic pain means I pretty much "feel" poor most of the time so asking how I was feeling just kept "accessing the network" of pain pathways and did me no good. Now when asked how I'm doing (depending on if it's my close person or not) I may acknowledge I'm having a difficult day, without unloading the kitchen sink of pain behaviors, or say I'm okay, or I'm well, then either shift to talk about the other person or bring up a positive about my life, family, the weather, a movie - whatever I can find in that moment that brings my mind away from pain and allows me to be an active participant with a positive mindset. In the end its everyone's individual choice as to how to respond to questions, just remember you get out of it what you put in to it. If change never happens then you stay the same.

Here's a mantra (and I have many) that really helps keep me on the path towards change...

REPLY
@tyyne21wigwam

This really helped! Thanks for your reply. I hadn't thought about the idea of adding pain by reiterating the problem

Jump to this post

I'm glad it helped.

REPLY
@rwinney

Hi Mikayla and all -
One thing I learned was that I am more than my pain, and got sick of letting pain define me. Cognitive behavioral therapy helped teach that I was still a person with abilities and interests, and could choose to not be defined by pain by shifting focus, mindset and working towards mindfulness and gratitude. I learned that I could teach my friends and family how I wanted to be spoken to. For example, I asked them to stop asking me how I was "feeling" and start asking me how I was "doing". Living with chronic pain means I pretty much "feel" poor most of the time so asking how I was feeling just kept "accessing the network" of pain pathways and did me no good. Now when asked how I'm doing (depending on if it's my close person or not) I may acknowledge I'm having a difficult day, without unloading the kitchen sink of pain behaviors, or say I'm okay, or I'm well, then either shift to talk about the other person or bring up a positive about my life, family, the weather, a movie - whatever I can find in that moment that brings my mind away from pain and allows me to be an active participant with a positive mindset. In the end its everyone's individual choice as to how to respond to questions, just remember you get out of it what you put in to it. If change never happens then you stay the same.

Here's a mantra (and I have many) that really helps keep me on the path towards change...

Jump to this post

This was so helpful! I wrote down the mantra thank you for your ideas.

REPLY
@rwinney

So true, Ted. I work on treating myself with kindness and grace. Through cognitive behavioral therapy I learned that I needed to talk to myself like I talk to others with encouragement, support and care. Taking my own advice through positive self-talk has helped a lot. I try to think about how would I talk to my kids in this moment. And that's how I should treat myself. It's a work in progress somedays more than others but that's ok.

How do you talk to yourself?

Jump to this post

I am going to remember this. I think it will help!

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.