Met with dietician today: Some answers to questions the group asked

Posted by TurtBean @turtbean, Jul 29 6:10pm

I met today with a dietitian who specializes in cancer survivorship nutrition. Here’s how that went:

We met for about an hour, just a telephone visit. I had a couple of specific questions, and was happy to hear him provide immediate, detailed responses tailored to prostate cancer - you know how sometimes you’ll talk to an “expert” and you’ll be able to work out pretty quickly that they’re a generalist giving you a general answer with a lot of extra words to pad their response out so they sound like they know more than they do? That wasn’t this guy, he gave very precise answers to my questions. That made me feel confident in talking with him.

Onto the food:

I asked about eggs, because there are a lot of controversy around eggs and prostate cancer.

The dietician talked about the pros and cons about eggs in relation to prostate cancer, then stated the position of the nutritional department at the cancer center is that eggs don’t need to be severely limited, just moderated - no more than two a day. Since I rarely have more than four eggs a week these days, I’m good, but now I feel ok in increasing that a little, maybe up to six eggs a week.

I also asked if there were any foods that were recommended to never consume. I said, “What’s the cigarette of the food world?”

“Two things,” he replied, “Alcohol and deli meats/cured meats. I’m all about moderation in all things, but for those two things, if you don’t have to consume them, then don’t.”

That means hotdogs, bologna, bacon, sausage, salami, even so-called healthy sliced meats, like chicken or turkey from the deli, are an avoid-at-all-costs if possible.

I was surprised by the chicken and turkey stuff, but he said those are processed in such a way to prepare them for deli sales, that it makes them unsuitable for a cancer survivorship diet. That also includes nitrate/nitrite-free stuff and chicken sausages.

Thankfully, he did ok making some of that stuff at home, including roast beef, which would still count against the recommended red meat amounts, but would be better for me than buying the pre-sliced stuff.

That one hurts a little because deli meats and cured meats made up a very large part of my diet. I had some form of that every day, and many times multiple times a day, and have done so since I was old enough to eat solid food (maybe that’s why I developed cancer 😉). I ate obscene amounts of lunchmeats, bacon, and sausages.

So that was the worst of it. With the alcohol, he just said if I don’t feel like I have to drink, then don’t, but recognized that there’s a social component to it that’s hard to fight. I mentioned that I didn’t drink a lot beforehand, and I’m not drinking at all right now, and he simply recommended not starting back again if I could help it.

He then went through the usual things of this much red meat, that much protein, eat a plant-forward diet, eat the rainbow, blah blah blah, but did specifically point out that tomatoes appear to be very effective in curtailing prostate cancer recurrence, so eat tomatoes, fresh, canned, or cooked, as much as possible.

Then he had me tell him typical meals that we eat, three of each of breakfast, lunch, and supper, as well as snacks and desserts, and he graded me very highly on my choices overall, with little tweaks here and there. He said I was eating better than 95% of the people he meets with, and he commended me on my general food/meal knowledge…we even swapped a couple of recipe ideas.

Last thing he left me with was that he was sending me a bunch of dietary info through my patient portal, and that I had access to nutrition services through the care center for the rest of my “very long life,” and “…one more thing: holidays and vacations, throw all that out the window and eat and drink what you want. Life’s too short not to have a little fun.”

All in all, a good meeting, I thought.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

Profile picture for dpayton @dpayton

@surftohealth88

Right, I heard use olive oil which I absolutely love anyhow. I'm gonna cut 'em up today and I'll let you know how it goes. Thanks for the tips! Always appreciated!!!! 🙌👍👌😊

Jump to this post

@dpayton

My wife takes 1/2 inch slices of beefsteak tomatoes, sprinkled with salt, pepper and a pepper and a tad bit of Italian seasoning and sautés them in olive oil for a couple of minutes on each side. Same with cherry tomatoes, cut em in half, put them in a bowl with a little EVOO and spices to marinate for a half hour or so, but only sauté for about 90 secs total. Don't overcook, they turn to mush quickly. Make sure you drain the liquid before you put them in the pan. Both are a delicious, simple to make side dish to just about any meal.

REPLY
Profile picture for TurtBean @turtbean

@dpayton

Start some water boiling, salt it, in with your favorite pasta.

While that’s cooking, heat some olive oil (1-2 TB) in a skillet, add in a sliced clove of garlic, let that simmer until just turning brown. You can take the slices out at that point, or just leave them in. Oil will be flavored.

In with some cherry tomatoes and some halved black olives and give it a toss/stir every now and then.

Just before the pasta is done, into the skillet with some fresh basil, cut the heat back to low.

Pull out about a half-cup of the pasta water and set aside. Drain the pasta, then dump it all in the skillet. Turn the heat off.

Toss it all for a few seconds to mix, then start adding in that reserved pasta water, a splash at a time, and turn and stir and toss. The pasta will pull that water in, and after a few minutes, you’ll have a nice, glossy sauce/coating on your pasta.

Plate it up, a little grated Parmesan, and you’re done. Maybe 20-25 minutes once the water starts boiling.

It’s a good technique to learn, because you can mix in anything, just about, and it’s how I frequently deal with leftovers or things about to go off. Last night, I did that with three wrinkly mushrooms and a half a jar of tapenade.

Jump to this post

@turtbean 1000% agree that aglio e olio is a great versatile base to build off of, so fast and fun to do flip-flop the pan

REPLY
Profile picture for brianjarvis @brianjarvis

The way I’ve heard it summarized - and this is pretty much in line with all that you mentioned from your visit with the nutritionist - is that “heart-healthy is prostate-healthy.” Since we’re inundated with information about “heart-healthy diets,” it’s a concept that’s easy to grasp.
==============

Other foods you and others mentioned:
> meats: I’ve read that as long as they’re lean meats it’s ok (and everything in moderation).

> oils - avocado oil and extra virgin olive oil are good; highly refined industrial seed and vegetable oils are bad.

> tomatoes: It’s the Lycopene in the tomatoes that appear to be very effective in curtailing prostate cancer recurrence. But be aware how you prepare it and what you eat it with. Also, the studies are mixed on the benefits of Lycopene supplements’ effectiveness in curtailing prostate cancer recurrence.

Our bodies need a balance of proteins, fats, and carbohydrates. If avoiding too much, supplements will be needed.

I would not attribute my prostate cancer to the “deli meats and cured meats that made up a very large part of my diet.” With all the environmental toxins that we’re exposed to on a daily basis (as well as the industrial solvents - like trichloroethylene - that I was exposed to on a daily basis while in the military), it’s just as likely as not that the cause is there.

I was a meat and potatoes guy growing up and through adulthood, so I was cautious about changing to a diet that I wasn’t going to maintain —> I decreased red meats; increased fish, salads; added more fruits, vegetables, and grains/nuts; cut out soft drinks; cut back on processed foods, and made other tweaks here and there. (Still, I do have a beer, burger, or a donut once in a while.)

(Added to all that is exercise - both load-bearing and cardio; I engage in one or the other daily. Again, heart-healthy is prostate-healthy.)

Jump to this post

@brianjarvis yea i work for the navy a tri-co was used like water even then i was concerned

REPLY
Profile picture for carlsbadguy @carlsbadguy

@dpayton

My wife takes 1/2 inch slices of beefsteak tomatoes, sprinkled with salt, pepper and a pepper and a tad bit of Italian seasoning and sautés them in olive oil for a couple of minutes on each side. Same with cherry tomatoes, cut em in half, put them in a bowl with a little EVOO and spices to marinate for a half hour or so, but only sauté for about 90 secs total. Don't overcook, they turn to mush quickly. Make sure you drain the liquid before you put them in the pan. Both are a delicious, simple to make side dish to just about any meal.

Jump to this post

@carlsbadguy

Very helpful!!! Thank you sir!!!

REPLY

Well the tomato thing must only be for prostate cancer. I have an older brother that about half what he eats comes from his own garden. They can tons of tomatoes and many other things and have them a lot and eat them in various cooked forms. He found out last week he has Sarcoma in the spine, brain, one end of his liver and spots on his lungs. They've already removed as much of the tumor they could off his spine to help him walk again. They did Gamma Knife surgery on his brain Friday, the spots were on the brain and not deep in the brain. He's getting a full PET scan this week. I've been trying to post what's going on with me but can't get it posted for some reason, maybe the content is too long. Let's just say the family is shocked that two brothers have been hit with serious cancer issues at the same time.

REPLY
Profile picture for im62at2024 @im62at2024

Well the tomato thing must only be for prostate cancer. I have an older brother that about half what he eats comes from his own garden. They can tons of tomatoes and many other things and have them a lot and eat them in various cooked forms. He found out last week he has Sarcoma in the spine, brain, one end of his liver and spots on his lungs. They've already removed as much of the tumor they could off his spine to help him walk again. They did Gamma Knife surgery on his brain Friday, the spots were on the brain and not deep in the brain. He's getting a full PET scan this week. I've been trying to post what's going on with me but can't get it posted for some reason, maybe the content is too long. Let's just say the family is shocked that two brothers have been hit with serious cancer issues at the same time.

Jump to this post

@im62at2024
I am so sorry to hear this : ((((. Did any of you have genetic test done to see if there is some inheritable mutation responsible for cancers in the family : ((( ?
Wishing you both complete healing and the best of luck 🍀🍀🍀.

REPLY
Profile picture for im62at2024 @im62at2024

Well the tomato thing must only be for prostate cancer. I have an older brother that about half what he eats comes from his own garden. They can tons of tomatoes and many other things and have them a lot and eat them in various cooked forms. He found out last week he has Sarcoma in the spine, brain, one end of his liver and spots on his lungs. They've already removed as much of the tumor they could off his spine to help him walk again. They did Gamma Knife surgery on his brain Friday, the spots were on the brain and not deep in the brain. He's getting a full PET scan this week. I've been trying to post what's going on with me but can't get it posted for some reason, maybe the content is too long. Let's just say the family is shocked that two brothers have been hit with serious cancer issues at the same time.

Jump to this post

@im62at2024 Sorry to hear about your brother…your family genetics has a lot more to do with your issues than a few tomatoes can solve.
My friend had melanoma and prostate cancer; his wife had adeno CA of the colon age 35.
Their son died from glioblastoma age 35…a very nasty gene sequence is in there somewhere.
Best wishes for your brother’s recovery and yours as well.
Phil

REPLY

After my prostate cancer surgery last year, I made further improvements to my already fairly healthy diet, hoping to at least slow down the progression of any cancer that might recur, even if diet alone may not prevent recurrence.

Based on my research, I compiled the attached list of “Top 20 Anti-Cancer Food Groups,” which largely aligns with what others have shared in this discussion thread.

I did not include a separate list of foods to avoid or minimize, such as the usual suspects: processed meats, red meat, added sugars, and refined grains.

In my case, I had already been avoiding fast food, processed meats, and other unhealthy foods for decades. So, the biggest changes involved making my diet more plant-forward, increasing my consumption of fatty fish and cruciferous vegetables, and adding green tea to my daily routine.

My latest blood work shows substantial improvements in my A1C and other health markers, reinforcing my belief that this type of diet offers benefits beyond any potential impact on cancer, particularly for cardiovascular health, blood sugar control, and weight management.

REPLY
Profile picture for soli @soli

After my prostate cancer surgery last year, I made further improvements to my already fairly healthy diet, hoping to at least slow down the progression of any cancer that might recur, even if diet alone may not prevent recurrence.

Based on my research, I compiled the attached list of “Top 20 Anti-Cancer Food Groups,” which largely aligns with what others have shared in this discussion thread.

I did not include a separate list of foods to avoid or minimize, such as the usual suspects: processed meats, red meat, added sugars, and refined grains.

In my case, I had already been avoiding fast food, processed meats, and other unhealthy foods for decades. So, the biggest changes involved making my diet more plant-forward, increasing my consumption of fatty fish and cruciferous vegetables, and adding green tea to my daily routine.

My latest blood work shows substantial improvements in my A1C and other health markers, reinforcing my belief that this type of diet offers benefits beyond any potential impact on cancer, particularly for cardiovascular health, blood sugar control, and weight management.

Jump to this post

@soli

Thanks for sharing your list and your experience, I am sure that it will help many.

I agree 100 % - healthy diet benefits us in so many ways and puts us in the best possible place to fight any disease.

Studies show that most patients die "from other causes" rather than from PC but very few actually do anything for preventing "other causes" regardless of known and proven strategy of implementing healthy diet and exercising.

So - good for you 🏆 and keep up with your great program 😊👍 !

REPLY

Thank you @surftohealth88 for your kind and encouraging words! You make an excellent point that deserves more attention. While we understandably focus on preventing prostate cancer recurrence, we should not overlook the other major threats to our health, particularly cardiovascular disease. A healthy diet, good sleep hygiene, and regular exercise are among the few things we can control that offer proven benefits for our overall health and quality of life, regardless of whether they prevent cancer recurrence. That's a win-win in my book!

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.