BPH vs Over-active bladder - my docs are arguing
My primary Dr. has had me on Tamsulosin and other meds for over 15 years due to enlarged prostate. I now pee 5-10 times each night.
(I am 78 yr. old male with balance problems, some neuropothy, some essential tremor, moderate-high BP, high-stress job, walk or bike 20 min daily, drink one cup coffee each AM, one light beer before dinner)
Primary Dr. increased meds but told me I was maxed-out, referred me to urologist for likely surgery. Urologist ignores enlarged prostate and put me on Solimenifen 5 gr for over-active bladder. I asked about surgery & he says all men my age have enlarged protate.
After 3 months, increasing solimenifen to 10 gr and wants to add 50 mg imipramine every night but first time I tried it, was difficult to pee. Seems like imipramine is a type of sleeping pill. During annual wellness visit back with primary, he said find a diferent urologist who will consider "proceedures."
I would appreciate any suggestions re what I should do.
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Men's Health Support Group.
Connect

Get a different urologist and consider prostate artery embolization. Get off the drugs.
You will always find a surgeon that will do surgery.
Overactive bladder can be neurogenic. Nocturia with so much frequency can be related to obstructive sleep apnea. Neurological disease can be responsible for overactive bladder. Do you have a high score of daytime symptoms.? If you have a procedure with causes other than BPH in play there may be no relief. I would suggest
a neurology consultation over seeing another urologist.
My nocturia was due to autonomic neuropathy and orthostatic hypotension. Bladder Botox injections have been offered by two urologists.
Currently on Vibegron and have the head of my bed elevated with a CPAP as well. Hypertension can play a role. Have your BP determined both standing and also lying flat.
My understanding is that Tamsulosin, Alfuzosin, etc., are muscle relaxants, and target the bladder. But I'm unclear whether they address the enlarged prostate.
So, here's my story, which might (or might not) be helpful: after a recent episode of urinary retention (triggered by surgery), I needed a catheter for 2 months. Then, suddenly, my bladder sprung back to life, with normal stream and full emptying. Although my urologist recommended HoLEP surgery, when I saw a surgeon, he supported my idea of first trying Finasteride. That was three months ago, during which I've had no problems.
The rub is that it takes 3-6 months for Finasteride to work, it only shrinks the prostate up to 30%, and it has to be taken for the rest of your life (or the prostate grows to its original size). Since my prostate was about 124 cc, even if it's shrunk 30%, it would still be enlarged, at 90+cc. So, yeah, I'm living with some uncertainty as to whether there will be another episode of retention, necessitating HoLEP or some other surgery, but in the meantime I've either avoided or at least delayed surgery.
Whatever your decision, I wish you a successful outcome.