Can vegan diet and HIIT workouts move the needle?
Hello! I am so pleased that I found this group. What an incredible wealth of information it contains. Here's my story and I would appreciate any feedback on whether my plan of action sounds like a good one. My name is Steve, i'm 69 years old, and weigh 180 pounds and an 6'. In February I had a yearly check-up and my doc saw that my PSA was 3.9. He drew some blood and did a K4test, They came back with a PSA of 4.8 and a 8.3 which put me at 9.6%chance of aggessive prostate cancer. He suggested that I see a urologist and see what he thought. The urologist said to come back in September and get another PSA test. I asked if we could get an MRI and he thought that would be unnecessary. After the appointment, my doctor asked me how it went and he said that if the urologist won't order the MRI, than he would. The MRI came back with a gland size of 5.5 x 5 x 4.5 A PSA density of .136
There is a far left apex lesion measuring 0.8 x 0.8 DWI score 4 CCE negative T2 score 3 PI-RADS 4
impression:
The pI-RADS 4 sub centimeter lesion is in the far left apex peripheral zone. No visualized seminal involvement or definite extra-capsular disease.
I went back to the urologist and he thought it probably wasn't cancer but he would do a biopsy. Here is the important part of the results.
Part 6- Prostate left medial apex, core needle biopsy: Prostatic adenocarcinoma, Gleason 3+4=7 (grade group2) involving 40% 0f 1 of 3 cores. All other cores were ok.
We then did a Decipher test and it came back .46 which is .01 away from the high point of low risk. (.45)
I meet the urologist again and he told me just go home and live your life. You can do Active Surveillance and in September we will recheck PSA and in March he would do a follow up biopsy and another MRI. I asked about diet and exercise which I had been reading could help the situation but he did not think I could do anything that would change the outcome. I spent hours and hours reading everything I could and decided that i would up my exercise to HIIT workouts as well as really step up an already very active life and I would also transition to a vegan diet since everything I found showed that plant based diets could have an impact on PC. I began the diet on May 18th and i'm doing great on it, obviously missing meat, cheese and dairy but if it changes the picture I will be pleased. I lost 15 pounds and leveled out at 180.
I have 2 questions for this group - First, do you agree that active surveillance is the way to go with this small lesion and second do you think the diet and exercise program can have an effect on lowering PSA and possibly shrinking the tumor? I sure appreciate your time and insight!
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.
Connect

@jim18 I live in Fairbanks so the biopsy and pathology were done here. We don't always have the latest and greatest here and I am wondering if I shouldn't travel to a place taht specializes in prostate cancer and see what they determine. I totally understand your question and will see if my doctor can give me an answer, Sure appreciate you taking the time to respond!
@swl1956 Thanks for taking the time to respond. I may have already made the same mistake you had! I have never read so much about something as I have this PC. I saw so much discussion about how animal protein and dairy were feeding the tumor that I made a radical decision to try starving the little sucker and go vegan. I also dropped weight but have since stabilized at 180 and feel great. Otherwise i would have a terrible time if I was hungry all the time. I think the trick for me was to get enough protein. It takes work but I am in a good spot now.
Glad you put some meat back on your bones! Hope you successfully beat your PC. God Bless!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
4 ReactionsThe evidence for resistance exercise is very strong. A good fairly short article by Dr. Rob Newton is "Prostate cancer treatment with Exercise Medicine". https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/tre.884
Newton has been researching the effect of exercise on prostate cancer specifically for decades.
I agree with Jeff Marchi that the Dr. Claire de la Calle video is excellent.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 Reactions@sulatnasteve You do not have to travel to get a second pathology opinion. jeffmarc (posted video) can give you details. Cost is $500. Primarily want to confirm the percentage of type 4 in your biopsy (I take it this was targeted at the PIRAD4 lesion). The assignment of a score is part art, part science so 2 pathologists do not always agree. Want someone with lots of experience in prostate cancer. Also to make sure there are no aggressive features in the cells. All of this is to make sure that there is a low probability of progression on AS for the next few years.
If you decide on surgery than you should travel since the skill of the surgeon becomes your destiny to minimize ED and incontinence. Should go to center of excellence. Fred Hutch in Seattle (UW) is probably the closest but also in SF & LA areas on west coast. Same may go for focal treatments although there the risk is more poor execution leading to a recurrence requiring radiation or surgery. Even with radiation they are now doing SBRT (5 treatments over 10-12 days) so not as long as traditional IMRT of 4-7 weeks.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 Reactions@swl1956 Great point about too little weight being dangerous. You never know when a spare 20–30 lb might come in useful, e.g. if you're having trouble eating during chemo some day, or (as in my case) if your digestive system shuts down completely for two weeks after surgery and you can't eat normally for 3 months.
If you can't eat and your body doesn't have enough fat stores, it will start consuming muscle, and you can really go into decline fast when that happens.
I'm not saying going into cancer a little overweight saved my life, but it definitely saved my mobility (my leg and core muscles were atrophying enough with paraplegia from the spinal tumour, without having my body burn the muscles for fuel as well).
Nature gives us a little extra padding for a good reason.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 ReactionsSorry you have been drafted into our club!
My situation is somewhat similar to yours, although there are differences. Let me say upfront, I am not a physician, but as a retired chemical engineer I tend (sometimes to my chagrin) to quantify everything.
At 66 years old my PSA was 7.8 and after a MRI-guided fusion biopsy, including 21 cores, I was diagnosed in October 2023 with low volume Gleason 3+4 (GG2).
Two 3+4 cores were found and they had 10-20% pattern 4. As others have indicated, it's important to determine the percentage of pattern 4, and the type of pattern 4, if possible. My original mpMRI found three lesions (PIRADS 3, 4 and 5) and my original PSA density was 0.179. I also had a Decipher score of 0.22 and the clinical-genomic risk model, in my Decipher GRID report, placed me in the Low Risk group and indicated AS was the preferred treatment.
I spent many hours researching and it soon became apparent that a man diagnosed with GG2 has probably the greatest number of treatment or AS options of any PCa diagnosis...it can be confusing and daunting to make a decision for a specific path forward....
As you have already done, and are asking, I also sought out information regarding diet and exercise.
Early on I found a small randomized clinic trial (ERASE) that was reported in 2021 JAMA article https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaoncology/fullarticle/2783273). ERASE tested the effectiveness of a 12 week HIIT program for men on AS and came to this conclusion:
"The ERASE trial demonstrated that HIIT increased cardiorespiratory fitness levels and decreased PSA levels, PSA velocity, and prostate cancer cell growth in men with localized prostate cancer who were under active surveillance. Larger trials are warranted to determine whether such improvement translates to better longer-term clinical outcomes in this setting."
I've modified the ERASE "HIIT protocol" to fit my own needs, BUT I've been implementing it now for 144 weeks. IMHO CONSISTENCY and SAFETY are the most important features for anyone wanting to implement a HIIT program. At our age especially, less is more, and safety is paramount.
I won't go into all the details, but my protocol (I call it my "proactive surveillance" program) can be summarized as: three sets of push-ups (strength exercising) followed by a Zone 2 5K run (70% of your max heart rate) and two 0.25 mile HIIT runs. I do this three times a week, always taking at least one day of recovery between outings, use super cushioning Hoka Bondi 8 running shoes and run on a rubberized 400m oval track.
In my case, the greatest benefit is measured in my overall fitness, as shown in the attachments. The plot averages many VO2 Max readings between each point, over the last four years, which smooths the curve and shows the trend. To give you an idea, I could barely slow jog one lap around the track when I first started at 66 years old....so I was in no way a fit individual when I started.
As it relates to my PCa diagnosis, my third mpMRI (after 28 months in February) indicated the three original lesions were no longer visible, my urologist believes they were actually just inflammation which resolved. My latest PSA was 6.4, I test every three month. That is still elevated, but my PSA velocity has always been negative since my pre diagnosis 7.8 level, but my PSA density has dropped to 0.145.
I should say a couple things about diet...I went on a vegan diet for the first 4 months and lost 30 lbs...but only to reach my objective of a BMI of 22.5 - 23.0. Once accomplished I maintained the things I liked from the vegan diet (Matcha tea, broccoli sprouts, dark berry smoothies and a veggie chili, which I have since modified) and added back chicken, salmon and even the occasional steak.
My primary "cheat" includes spicy cheese, whole wheat crackers and a glass of red wine every late afternoon; which I add to my carrots, red peppers and hummus. I've been able to maintain my BMI between 22.5 - 23.0 ever since I quit the strict vegan diet.
A "one-stop" website that rates various evidence based interventions, for PCa folks on AS, can be found here https://evidence.zone. "What's proven, what's promising, and what's noise", by Paul Sweeney.
As I'm sure you are already finding out, PCa treatment is virtually the opposite of "one size fits all". Therefore, each PCa man will decide upon an active treatment or an active surveillance program for which they are comfortable implementing.
All the best as you put together your plan, whatever it may include, and may it be super successful!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
4 Reactions@jim18
Probably the most experienced pathologist to get your second opinion is Dr. Epstein who was seen hundreds of thousands of biopsies
Dr. Jonathan Epstein biopsy
https://advanceduropathology.com
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 Reactions@northoftheborder Good advice. Thanks for taking the time to respond. I sure appreciate it!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
1 Reaction@handera What an encouraging message! I reread it 3 times! Yes, we do have some similar situation and I believe a similar mindset! I will have my 6 month psa in September and I am supposed to have a follow up MRI and a biopsy in March. I think I may travel to Washington for a MRI-guided fusion biopsy since they are not available in Alaska. I would sure like to see that little lesion shrink away! I am going to stick with the diet till I at least September and hope my PSA hasn't climbed. Well done on your end! I haven't been much of a runner but I would be willing to give it a try. Right now I work out on the stationary bike for about 35 minutes and I am smoked when I get off. I lift for a little over 45 minutes mostly using dumbbells. I also work most days on a large garden and we raise turkeys and goats and chickens which sure keep me busy doing manual labor.
I was in really good physical health and then found out I had this Cancer and just wanted to do everything possible to avoid treatment but not at the risk of it getting out of hand. It seems so easy to treat it but the treatment side effects have motivated me to work out harder! Thanks for sharing your workout routine and the link to evidence.zone. I sure appreciate it and the time you spent writing that all out for me. If you come to Alaska I'll make you a veggie Chile with a side of fresh salmon!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 ReactionsAn interesting explanation of Canola: https://gastropod.com/seed-oil-scare-the-curious-case-of-canola/