i will be 98 on 9/4/2026. should i get a colonoscopy?

Posted by noelcliffmsncom @noelcliffmsncom, Jul 16 8:57pm

I am in good physical and mental health for 98.
My bowel habits changed a year ago from firm stool to more water.
My doctor recommended a gastroenterologist at local rural hospital.
Is colonoscopy a better choice for discovering cause for change ...
or is there a better way? I gave stool sample and have appointment.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Aging Well Support Group.

Profile picture for gently @gently

Hi Noel,
you might consider a pill cam scan instead
https://www.medtronic.com/en-us/healthcare-professionals/products/digestive-gastrointestinal/capsule-endoscopy/endoscopy-systems/pillcam-sb-3-capsule-endoscopy-system.html
The lining of the intestine becomes more friable as we age and it becomes easier to tear with the scope.

With the pill you still have to do the prep.

Digestion often slows down as well sometimes causing the inconvenient watery effect.
The pill camera is good at examining the small intestine which is difficult to see with the scope and may be the source of your changes. It can detect celiac disease, crohn's, polyps or other obstruction, but importantly changes to the lining of the intestine which could cause absorption issues.

I try to avoid anesthesia; the usual is propofol with colonoscopy, but it's is only a little uncomfortable without.

A low supplementation of magnesium glycinate might help.

It isn't your 96 years that give me pause; it's the "rural" clinic.

Bless your choice.

Jump to this post

There is a little mix-up in thinking that this test, in this situation, is being pursued for cancer exploration. The inflammatory situation here is already causing discomfort. Inflammatory conditions can further damage the intestinal lining.
Still, the responses have been valuable and interesting on their own.
Related and unrelated also interesting: https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-create-a-gut-on-a-chip-that-reveals-hidden-drivers-of-inflammatory-bowel-disease?

REPLY

I have IBS-D so have had many colonoscopies and so far nothing found in my colon. I also have had to have an endoscopy each time. My last one was two years ago at age 82. I have learned that polyps are very slow growing so that's the good news but if you have never had a colonoscopy as a base line maybe you should. Everything that has been said is also true. And I second the idea of getting a second opinion especially at your age.

REPLY
Profile picture for Fred @fred1

@bjk3 In response to your comment, wishing that you could have someone with you at doctors visits. I've noticed recently while at the doctors, a notice, stating that if you want another person to accompany you during your consultation - that is your right, just let the doctor know! Don't know if it is just a law in NJ, but you might want to check it out.

Jump to this post

@fred1
Hi, @fred1 ~ Here in Iowa, it is also most certainly allowed and even encouraged. My problem isn't permission but availability...I have two sons here, both married, and all four are wonderfully employed - one out of state, two self-employed with no one to take their place, and the fourth most days out of town. I know if it were a real emergency someone would make arrangements but I won't ask if it isn't "life or death". My friends are not in a position to accompany me (age, mainly) ~ that's what was in my head when I said I wish I had someone to go with me. It didn't transfer very cohesively or clearly to the comment I wrote.
I appreciate your reply and concern. Thank you!!
~ Barb

REPLY
Profile picture for bjk3 @bjk3

@fred1
Hi, @fred1 ~ Here in Iowa, it is also most certainly allowed and even encouraged. My problem isn't permission but availability...I have two sons here, both married, and all four are wonderfully employed - one out of state, two self-employed with no one to take their place, and the fourth most days out of town. I know if it were a real emergency someone would make arrangements but I won't ask if it isn't "life or death". My friends are not in a position to accompany me (age, mainly) ~ that's what was in my head when I said I wish I had someone to go with me. It didn't transfer very cohesively or clearly to the comment I wrote.
I appreciate your reply and concern. Thank you!!
~ Barb

Jump to this post

@bjk3 Hello, sorry for the misunderstanding. Have you checked with your State or County senior citizen office. They may be able to direct you to a volunteer agency, or a government agency, that may be able to assist you when needed. Best to you, good luck.

REPLY
Profile picture for vic83 @vic83

I am turning 85 and I had my last colonoscopy at 83. They removed three precancerous polyps, so I am happy I did it. They told me to come back in 3 years (at 86), health permitting. I will do it because the husband of a friend died from colon cancer and it wasn't pleasant.
It is good that you are going to see a gastroenterologist. That specialist should answer all your questions. Since you are using a computer and Internet, you could ask AI like ChatGPT or Google Gemini. AI can give you a lot of background and suggest questions to ask the gastroenterologist. Certainly, with advanced age there is more risk to tear the intestine. And there is the anesthesia risk - but they should have someone monitoring your O2 during the procedure - and not leave the room. I have lung issues, so I require constant monitoring with anesthesia. It is a risk benefit. As one of my doctors at Mayo told me "my job is not to make you live as long as possible, but to preserve your quality of life as long as possible".
The worst part of the colonoscopy is the prep because having a very clean colon is important. And you might consider getting a second opinion after seeing the rural gastroenterologist. Try a teaching institution as they are typically the more advanced. Good luck!

Jump to this post

@vic83
Hi
I would still start with the colongard plus.
A friend of mine used this and it came back positive so then she had a colonoscopy.
I think this is a safer route for older people.

REPLY
Profile picture for vic83 @vic83

I am turning 85 and I had my last colonoscopy at 83. They removed three precancerous polyps, so I am happy I did it. They told me to come back in 3 years (at 86), health permitting. I will do it because the husband of a friend died from colon cancer and it wasn't pleasant.
It is good that you are going to see a gastroenterologist. That specialist should answer all your questions. Since you are using a computer and Internet, you could ask AI like ChatGPT or Google Gemini. AI can give you a lot of background and suggest questions to ask the gastroenterologist. Certainly, with advanced age there is more risk to tear the intestine. And there is the anesthesia risk - but they should have someone monitoring your O2 during the procedure - and not leave the room. I have lung issues, so I require constant monitoring with anesthesia. It is a risk benefit. As one of my doctors at Mayo told me "my job is not to make you live as long as possible, but to preserve your quality of life as long as possible".
The worst part of the colonoscopy is the prep because having a very clean colon is important. And you might consider getting a second opinion after seeing the rural gastroenterologist. Try a teaching institution as they are typically the more advanced. Good luck!

Jump to this post

@vic83 I like what one of your Mayo doctors told you: "My job is not to make you live as long as possible, but to preserve your quality of life as long as possible."

I think I will have that tattooed on my chest and reveal that to a few of my docs!
Although I have fired the ones that don't have that attitude and replaced them with those that do!

REPLY
Profile picture for Fred @fred1

No medical doctor will perform a colonoscopy on anyone over the age of about 85, let alone at 98. I believe there is a blood test that will give you the answer you're looking for.

Jump to this post

@fred1 I had a colonoscopy at Mayo Clinic at age 83 and they told me to come back in 3 years (age 86). I have a history of multiple colonoscopies and each time I had colon polyps.
Cologuard Plus site specifically states that this blood test is for adults 45 years of age and older who are at AVERAGE risk for colon cancer. It is not for people with history of colon polyps It is not a replacement for colonoscopy in high-risk individuals.

REPLY
Profile picture for patgreen11 @patgreen11

@vic83
Hi
I would still start with the colongard plus.
A friend of mine used this and it came back positive so then she had a colonoscopy.
I think this is a safer route for older people.

Jump to this post

@patgreen11 Cologuard Internet page specifically states "Cologuard Plus is for adults 45 years of age and older who are at AVERAGE risk for colon cancer. It is not a replacement for colonoscopy in high-risk individuals."
Definition of Average Risk
Being at average risk means you do not have high-risk factors that significantly increase your likelihood of developing colorectal cancer. Specifically, people at average risk:
Have no personal history of colorectal cancer or precancerous polyps
Do not have a first-degree relative (parent, sibling, or child) with colorectal cancer or advanced polyps
Do not have hereditary syndromes such as Lynch syndrome or familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP)
Do not have inflammatory bowel disease like Crohn’s disease or ulcerative colitis

REPLY
Profile picture for mikead63 @mikead63

@vic83 I like what one of your Mayo doctors told you: "My job is not to make you live as long as possible, but to preserve your quality of life as long as possible."

I think I will have that tattooed on my chest and reveal that to a few of my docs!
Although I have fired the ones that don't have that attitude and replaced them with those that do!

Jump to this post

@mikead63 ...well maybe not a tatoo. But you can definitely ask them about their philosophy. I always recommend researching doctors and reading all their Notes

REPLY
Profile picture for vic83 @vic83

@mikead63 ...well maybe not a tatoo. But you can definitely ask them about their philosophy. I always recommend researching doctors and reading all their Notes

Jump to this post

@vic83 - Agree! I always research potential doctors. I am fortunate to live in the state of Minnesota where there is an abundance of excellent medical facilities and physicians. In fact I have a procedure scheduled at Mayo Rochester in August after researching and interviewing a number of other options and physicians.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.