I’m scheduled for knee replacement but read so many negatives ?

Posted by andoman @andoman, Jul 9 3:03pm

Im having full knee replacement very soon and researching I read so many negatives so for all of you who have had it, is it worth it ? I’m definitely concerned that I’ll be worse off by reading so many problems with pain, swelling and movement with knee replacements and maybe one should just put up with what we deal with now than adding pain and swelling into the mix.
Any advice would be much appreciated.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Joint Replacements Support Group.

I had mine done a little over 10 years ago and I am so happy I did. Both knees 6 weeks apart. Husband is going in at the end of August. Just remember most seeking answers are struggling. Choose your doctor carefully and follow what they tell you. I couldn't even stand to cook without pain. They aren't like the originals but they are pretty darn good.

REPLY

Along with myself having both TKR knees done a year apart, I know of at least four other acquaintances or family members that have had at least one TKR per person. None regret their choice and are happy or at least content with the results. As with any surgery, there is a small chance that something may go wrong either during surgery or the healing process and if you are that person, the majorities good results are of no consolation.

Going into surgery knowing exactly what will be done to you, and what the self-care recovery steps and PT will be like is important. I would be suspicious of any ortho office that does not give out detailed printed material for the patient to take home as well as verbal instructions. Our local ortho department requires pre-surgery attendance at a 1-2 hour TKR/THR presentation given by hospital staff of anesthiologist, surgical nurse, physical therapist, occupational therapist, which covers the surgery steps and timeline and home prep and recovery. Tips on making life easier in dressing etc. They encouraged lots of questions, presentations are scheduled several times a month in the evenings. But even if your surgeon's office is skimpy with info, it's still up to the individual to check for info on reputable medical websites which offer relevant preparation info online if you take the trouble to search for it.

REPLY

Just make sure you have PT and definitely do your exercises at home. I made the mistake of not doing home exercises and now don’t have a 120 bend. Pick a doctor that does robotic surgery.

REPLY
Profile picture for dsmit8 @dsmit8

Just make sure you have PT and definitely do your exercises at home. I made the mistake of not doing home exercises and now don’t have a 120 bend. Pick a doctor that does robotic surgery.

Jump to this post

@dsmit8 I would make sure to investigate robotic surgery. Especially if you have osteoporosis.

REPLY
Profile picture for andoman @andoman

@naughtyrascal
My pain is at night, stiffness all day everyday and if in my feet too much then my knee swells up and gives me big grief but if I take it easy and don’t do much it’s not too bad but that’s not living is it ?
My surgery is in 10 days and I’m nervous as hell, so scare I’ll become if the many who have issues and that will probably destroy me. I’m very fit, only 84kgs and trying to exercise the knee everyday as I do have a fair bit of muscle loss on that leg, had this bad knee a long time.

Jump to this post

@andoman You’re doing everything right and if you follow the post surgery therapy routine, you can be optimistic about an excellent outcome. Although my post TKR experience hasn’t been good, i believe it’s an anomaly. Life has risks, but you have every chance of success. Let us know how it goes! Sending you good thoughts.

REPLY

I had knee surgery 16 months ago. I get around better than before my surgery. I recommend that you do therapy and it is very important to do your home exercises. Both before and after the surgery. Good luck on your surgery.

REPLY
Profile picture for cmd74 @cmd74

@SusanEllen66
I am 9 months in my TKA. Please make sure you are not allergic to the glue generally used for incisions. Although my allergy chart listed latex and bandaid adhesives, glue was still used and the allergic reaction was mind blowing, debilitating and shocking. Blisters and raised rash all over the incision. I could not apply any type of scar treatment for 4 months. For the last 2 months, I have been using silicone scar tape to improve appearance. Not noticing too much difference, but will keep using tape. On a positive note, I have full flexibility in my knee.
I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention that since day 3, after nerve block wore off, I have been getting sensations of burning, stinging and zapping morning, noon and night on inside of calf since the beginning. I was told it would go away. Again, 9 months in. I work out 2-3 times a week, stretching and PT exercises in between, and I can ride my bike albeit not up inclines. From AI NIH website … following TKA, human peripheral nerves—such as the saphenous or common peroneal nerves—regenerate at a highly consistent rate of approximately 1 mm per day (or roughly 1 inch per month). I am trying to be a patient patient. When we are told TKA full recovery can take a year or more, plan accordingly. This surgery is major. Take care.

Jump to this post

@cmd74 thanks. I had mine done, 2019 & 2020.

My surgeon used a “zipper” tape to close the outside of incision. It was the most bizarre thing I’ve seen. I don’t believe it’s used anymore.
I’d post a picture, but it might scare people.

REPLY
Profile picture for lauracbaker @lauracbaker

@andoman my sympathies! I have lots of AUS relatives; their experiences with gov't healthcare have made me aware that we in USA do not want full gov't healthcare. Cortisone is not a good solution; IDK why Docs use it. The side effects are scary. HA is a naturally-occuring fluid in the body, but maybe not so financially beneficial to the "big pharma". I know many people (probably 6 or 7) who have had knee replacement and are happy with the results; I don't know anybody who is unhappy with that procedure. I pray that you'll be fine.

Jump to this post

@lauracbaker
Medicare for all as an option takes care of that. If one cares about medical equity.

REPLY

I am 78 years old. I have read and talked to several people about tkr. The continuing theme I am getting is success is very much dependent on age. Younger people heal better and faster for sure!

REPLY

Why are you scheduled for TKR?
I couldn’t walk around the block with so much pain. I tried nerve ablation then consulted about Genicular artery embolism but bone was already deformed so I had the TKR April 2025. Yes it’s the hardest thing I’ve ever done and gone through but I’m able to Zumba! I’ve been in touch with a doctor about a future clinical study for - well - Google Stanford university and shot for knee cartilage

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.