Thumb arthritis: Did anyone have carpometacarpal (CMC) surgery?

Posted by dmk @dmk, Oct 5, 2022

Has anyone had CMC surgery where the trapezium bone is removed and your tendons are knotted to sit in the space to cushion your thumb? If so what was your experience? Thanks in advance

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Bones, Joints & Muscles Support Group.

I had both thumbs done a year apart 20 years ago. First one was at the base of my cmc joint where he inserted a zerconia sphere “ball”. Lots of PT for a month.
Second thumb he did a “snap” procedure attaching a wire the size of a thread as he described it, attaching it to my middle finger then to the base of my thumb. No PT required for that one.
Supposedly both lasting 10 years…. It’s been 20 plus. Doing fine.

REPLY
Profile picture for heatherblynn @heatherblynn

@sueinmn
Hi,
I am an art teacher and surgeon recommending tightrope surgery.
You said complete rest
So should I stay home from work three weeks?
Also can you mention you are a fiber artist. Can you thread a needle and hold fabric to hand sew since surgery?

Jump to this post

@heatherblynn I am an artist and 25 years ago my thumbs and rest would swell and I was misdiagnosed with tendinitis and told I had carpal tunnel, osteoarthritis and more. I went to see an acupuncturist and we got the swelling down, and I learned not to put severe stress on my thumbs, which twisting glue and paint containers. Fast-forward to two years ago when my hands were stiff and swollen and I could only miserably use my hands. I went to a top drawer arthritis doctor at UCSD. He said my hands were so loaded with arthritis. He wouldn’t know where to start with the surgery. I was pretty depressed. I’m 69 and Art is all I know my whole life. Someone here recommended tart cherry capsules (I bought Zazzee brand on Amazon 10,000:1) for $10. In 24 hours the pain and stiffness was gone after 25years. Turns out I had gout, causing the pain and stiffness beyond the osteoarthritis that everyone could see. It was a true miracle. My finger stopped looking like sausages and I could go without my day doing the things I love like pulling weeds and opening bills, lol. But now I could do my artwork pain-free.

REPLY
Profile picture for SusanEllen66 Susan McMichael @SusanEllen66

@pat9892 I had arthoplasty on my right thumb in 2012, and 2013. Yes, same thumb 3 times!
First time he did the process, and packed the space with cadaver tendon. That tendon material slid into the palm of my hand. Second surgery, he removed about half of that tendon material. Again, it slid into my hand.

Third try, doctor took my own tendon. That was the trick! However, that was a long process. No more pain, that’s the point.

Jump to this post

@SusanEllen66 that's a lot of time, inconvenience, and therapy to go through, especially if involves your dominant hand. Glad to hear that the third time was the charm. It's pretty amazing surgery when it works isn't it!

REPLY
Profile picture for pat9892 @pat9892

@SusanEllen66 that's a lot of time, inconvenience, and therapy to go through, especially if involves your dominant hand. Glad to hear that the third time was the charm. It's pretty amazing surgery when it works isn't it!

Jump to this post

@pat9892
Yes especially when you don’t trust your doctor.

REPLY
Profile picture for loriesco @loriesco

@heatherblynn I am an artist and 25 years ago my thumbs and rest would swell and I was misdiagnosed with tendinitis and told I had carpal tunnel, osteoarthritis and more. I went to see an acupuncturist and we got the swelling down, and I learned not to put severe stress on my thumbs, which twisting glue and paint containers. Fast-forward to two years ago when my hands were stiff and swollen and I could only miserably use my hands. I went to a top drawer arthritis doctor at UCSD. He said my hands were so loaded with arthritis. He wouldn’t know where to start with the surgery. I was pretty depressed. I’m 69 and Art is all I know my whole life. Someone here recommended tart cherry capsules (I bought Zazzee brand on Amazon 10,000:1) for $10. In 24 hours the pain and stiffness was gone after 25years. Turns out I had gout, causing the pain and stiffness beyond the osteoarthritis that everyone could see. It was a true miracle. My finger stopped looking like sausages and I could go without my day doing the things I love like pulling weeds and opening bills, lol. But now I could do my artwork pain-free.

Jump to this post

@loriesco you have had quite a journey!
The tart cherry help gout. Do you know if it did anything for your arthritis?

I’ve had 4 different surgeries on my left hand alone. The right thumb has had arthroscopic surgery.

I love to do art. It is something I do almost everyday. I’ve never had a lesson except a YouTube video here and there.
Right now I’m attempting to learn Modeling paste, and oil pastels.

Do you have a TOTALLY hands free can opener?
I recommend using one and a totally hands free jar opener.
I got mine on Amazon.

REPLY
Profile picture for loriesco @loriesco

@heatherblynn I am an artist and 25 years ago my thumbs and rest would swell and I was misdiagnosed with tendinitis and told I had carpal tunnel, osteoarthritis and more. I went to see an acupuncturist and we got the swelling down, and I learned not to put severe stress on my thumbs, which twisting glue and paint containers. Fast-forward to two years ago when my hands were stiff and swollen and I could only miserably use my hands. I went to a top drawer arthritis doctor at UCSD. He said my hands were so loaded with arthritis. He wouldn’t know where to start with the surgery. I was pretty depressed. I’m 69 and Art is all I know my whole life. Someone here recommended tart cherry capsules (I bought Zazzee brand on Amazon 10,000:1) for $10. In 24 hours the pain and stiffness was gone after 25years. Turns out I had gout, causing the pain and stiffness beyond the osteoarthritis that everyone could see. It was a true miracle. My finger stopped looking like sausages and I could go without my day doing the things I love like pulling weeds and opening bills, lol. But now I could do my artwork pain-free.

Jump to this post

@loriesco Thanks for this tip! Having a hard time with finger swelling post-CMC Suspensionplasty. Was supplement 10000:1 or 10:1? I am looking on Amazon right now. Thank you!

REPLY
Profile picture for handsdown @handsdown

@loriesco Thanks for this tip! Having a hard time with finger swelling post-CMC Suspensionplasty. Was supplement 10000:1 or 10:1? I am looking on Amazon right now. Thank you!

Jump to this post

@handsdown whew! It went up in price! last I bought it was $10! But I ended up going on the medicine Allopurinol for the gout does the same thing. Here's the link: https://a.co/d/0ivB3SDE oh, you can buy less: https://a.co/d/0alkSLm2

REPLY
Profile picture for SusanEllen66 Susan McMichael @SusanEllen66

@loriesco you have had quite a journey!
The tart cherry help gout. Do you know if it did anything for your arthritis?

I’ve had 4 different surgeries on my left hand alone. The right thumb has had arthroscopic surgery.

I love to do art. It is something I do almost everyday. I’ve never had a lesson except a YouTube video here and there.
Right now I’m attempting to learn Modeling paste, and oil pastels.

Do you have a TOTALLY hands free can opener?
I recommend using one and a totally hands free jar opener.
I got mine on Amazon.

Jump to this post

@SusanEllen66 hi Susan! To answer your question gout is one of the many types of arthritises. There are two kinds of gout one is because a person has too much uric acid running through their system and their body creates crystals which depositsqin their joints. The other gout is called pseudo gout, and it’s formed by calcium deposits. There’s rheumatoid arthritis (there are several kinds of RA) and there is osteoarthritis which I have as well along with some erosive arthritis. there are inflammatory types of arthritis (which might fall outside of RA and be called immune disorders instead of arthritis.)
I have moved beyond the supplements to a medicine called allopurinol. My father and other relatives had gout. it’s something that is inherited. With the medication I have no pain and I can move pretty well at 69! Be well!

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.