Collagen heavy metal content

Posted by njx58 @njx58, Sep 26, 2025

In another thread, some people were discussing the heavy metal content of collagen peptide supplements. I asked Keith McCormick about his own OsteoNaturals supplement. He sent me the Gelita lab report. I'll summarize the key tiems. For each metal, I'll list the desired specification, and the actual result.

Cadmium: < = 0.10 ppm, < 0.10 ppm
Mercury: < = 0.02 ppm, < 0.02
Arsenic: < = 0.7 ppm, < 0.7 ppm
Lead: < = 0.50 ppm, < 0.01 ppm

So, it is not free of heavy metals, but it doesn't have a lot. What I don't know is what levels are acceptable. Most of the brands contain metals. Vital Proteins was sued a few years ago; they are owned by Nestle, a notorious company for ignoring consumer health. Of course it's a little suspicious that the OsteoNaturals lab test was performed by Gelita itself - the maker of Fortibone.

I am now thinking that the benefit of using collagen peptides, which is small to begin with, is not worth it. I need to do some more research.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for jozer @jozer

Funny this popped up today, saw my primary care doctor yesterday and asked about adding collagen peptides to my diet (have read more protein, more collagen is good for bones; also for thinning hair and wrinkles!). Seen posts about products with Fortibone which sound helpful and has been studied. My primary care said she didn't see any reason to take any collagen products; to up the protein from lean meats, plants, protein bars, etc. She said the collagen products (like supplements) are unregulated so all could have various amounts of ingredients in them. I also am questioning the use of collagen; although there are studies (there are studies on everything if you dig deep enough!) that seem to show a benefit for osteoporosis. So once again the best treatments for osteoporosis are clear as mud!

Jump to this post

@jozer According to Harvard Health, a review and analysis of 19 studies, published in the International Journal of Dermatology, that had a total of 1,125 participants. Those who used collagen supplements saw an improvement in the firmness, suppleness, and moisture content of the skin, with wrinkles appearing less noticeable. That sounds promising, but it's unclear if these skin improvements were actually due to collagen. Most of the trials used commercially available supplements that contained more than collagen: vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, coenzyme Q10, hyaluronic acid, and chondroitin sulfate were among the additional ingredients.

REPLY
Profile picture for tombenson @tombenson

@glojo The reason your parents lived a long life is because of the quality of food they ate. Corporations, on the quest for greater profits, grow and process animal and produce in infant states, steers at 18 to 24 months, produce is picked green and then exposed to ethaline or xyline gas to turn it the appropriate color. The fruit remains firm. Less is lost in shipping. This creates a mineral and protein deficiency. All the collagen on the market is still processed from the same animals except one and it won't be on the market for another month: Rejuvenation Guaranteed. Com. The sourced animals are older, free range, wild caught, organic. Their protein is hydrolyzed for bioavalability and mixed at concentrations that corporations won't touch because that have boards to answer to. For instance collagen 10 is expensive so most collagen companies use no more than 1 to 3 percent. RG also adds a true bioflavinoide not an ascorbic acid which is a synthesised vitamin C. Your body knows the difference. This product guarantees results in 90 days or your money back. How do I know about this? I was in the clinical study. I feel better now than when I was in my late thirties. I workout and I have the body and skin of a much younger man. Their website will be up in a week or so. This is the future of medicine. Give your body "Nutritional restoration" and the body will do what it evolved doing, heal itself.

Jump to this post

@tombenson I just went to their website but when I clicked on the links within the website noting worked. Shouldn't the website be up and running now?

REPLY
Profile picture for rjd @rjd

Question for original poster: what did you decide to do about taking collagen?

I started Osteonaturals collegen last Sept and saw a noticeable difference in skin resilience within a couple of months. Since then I have not noticed anything else.

I am not due for a DEXA until next year.....presently on a drug holiday since last April, after ending Fosomax as the follow-on for Prolia. Trying to convince my new PCP to order CTX and P1NP and have next appointment in a couple of weeks.

Jump to this post

@rjd Just to update, I decided to continue taking it. My conclusion was that the heavy metal content was low enough to not be a concern. Sometimes I mix it into a smoothie, but my go-to drink is fat-free milk + 1 tbsp collagen + 1 tbsp Ovaltine. It's a calcium / collagen / vitamin drink all in one.

My wife does take collagen, and she has mentioned something about skin and nails, so I guess it is helping her.

REPLY
Profile picture for njx58 @njx58

@rjd Just to update, I decided to continue taking it. My conclusion was that the heavy metal content was low enough to not be a concern. Sometimes I mix it into a smoothie, but my go-to drink is fat-free milk + 1 tbsp collagen + 1 tbsp Ovaltine. It's a calcium / collagen / vitamin drink all in one.

My wife does take collagen, and she has mentioned something about skin and nails, so I guess it is helping her.

Jump to this post

@njx58 thanx for info. There was a sense that maybe you were going to stop collagen and if you did, I was interested in your rationale.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.