It is hard to know why you have tingling in your toes. Perhaps you should see a neurologist or rheumatologist as many autoimmune diseases manifest with some form of neuropathy. There are tests for those diseases and it would be helpful if you can rule them out. I found myself with neuropathy after having a severe sinus infection two winters ago. And, after many tests and scans, I was diagnosed with celiac disease. I now am on a strict gluten free diet. Neuropathy is not easy to manage but it can be done if you are body aware and maintain healthy diet and sleep habits. You will want to try to keep it from going beyond your toes. In the meantime you may want to consider some physical therapy to strengthen. I hope you find out what is causing toe tingling. Not knowing may produce anxiety. I wish you success and know that you are not alone.