Advice needed for CMC thumb implant failure

Posted by shontell @shontell, Jul 28, 2025

I had a Biopro thumb implant surgery 12/4/24 which has caused constant debilitating pain. Was told it’s a “simple” procedure for an annoying ache. Original doctor was insulted that I questioned the results of this surgery & walked out the room.

Been in PT since December, tried nerve & pain medicine.
Got 2 options who said I need to get it removed.
I’m searching for a Dr that has experience in removing the implant.

I am so overwhelmed with pain and limited use of my hand. Hoping I can get some suggestions for y’all. Willing to travel!

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Bones, Joints & Muscles Support Group.

@shontell
I am so sorry!

I had arthroplasty surgery on my thumb in 2013.
My trapezium bone was removed and replaced with my own tendon material.
I had a few problems, but it’s not painful anymore.

Assuming you had a Hand Surgeon perform the surgery, I suggest that you might want to consider a Hand Surgeon in another town/city. Maybe one associated with a teaching hospital.

It’s possible that your therapist may know of a good doctor?Because they work with the patients everyday, they sometimes can guide you.

REPLY

Thanks! I went to top hand surgeon in my city. I’m looking in different states. I’m so scared to pick the wrong Dr.

REPLY

@shontell. I’m sorry to hear about your situation. Have you been able to find a surgeon to remove the implant? Best wishes to you!

REPLY

Thank you! I did! About 45 minutes away. Implant was removed in December and it’s crazy how my hand immediately felt better. Still not normal but so much better

REPLY
Profile picture for shontell @shontell

Thank you! I did! About 45 minutes away. Implant was removed in December and it’s crazy how my hand immediately felt better. Still not normal but so much better

Jump to this post

@shontell Just curious - was the implant replaced by another type of CMC repair?

REPLY
Profile picture for shontell @shontell

Thank you! I did! About 45 minutes away. Implant was removed in December and it’s crazy how my hand immediately felt better. Still not normal but so much better

Jump to this post

@shontell Glad to hear your thumb is somewhat better. Have you had any Occupational therapy or hand therapy since surgery in December? It can take several months to get decent ROM and strength back.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.