Benign carcinoid tumor in bronchi tube

Posted by jessie1990 @jessie1990, Oct 30, 2025

Hi I've been diagnosed with a benign typical carcinoid tumor in my bronchi tube in right lung was found when I went to A&E with pneumonia back in July of this year I've had 2 bronchoscopys 2 biopys which showed benign carcinoid tumor I was sent for ct scan mri scan and pet scan pet scan was clear I was put under general anesthetic as my lung specialist said he might be able to remove tumor by going down my throat instead of haven surgery but didn't work but he was able to take 40% of tumor out as it was blocking my air way that's how pneumonia set in the 40% he removed also came back benign carcinoid 1 lymph node was removed and checked also clear now I need surgery to remove the rest I'm so confused as doctor said its a benign tumor then Google is telling me it's a low grade cancerous tumor but doctor nor lung specialist said anything about cancer just said its benign doesnt benign mean non cancerous and can any one tell me how surgery went thank you bless you all xx

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Neuroendocrine Tumors (NETs) Support Group.

Profile picture for Turkey, Volunteer Mentor @tomrennie

@nannybb That would be great. I have known a few Catholic nuns. They are tenacious and entertaining. Sounds like a fun lunch.

Jump to this post

@tomrennie I love all of the Sisters I work with and around. There are two branches. One side was already in Oregon (hundred years ago) and they were the nursing side (Providence) The other side came from Canada, and they were the teachers of the orphanage that was located on campus. The history of the place is fascinating. At some point there was a University, which is no longer. Some of the original buildings are still up and being used however. The grounds are beautiful and actually open to the public to visit, ride bikes and walk.

REPLY
Profile picture for Zebra @californiazebra

@nannybb
I always had asthma when I was sick or exposed to many animals. Then in my 20s I became so sensitive to fragrances that caused coughing, shortness of breath, mucus, bronchitis, etc. I just thought it was allergies and chemical sensitivity. In 2008, I had my first chest CT scan for chronic bronchitis. They discovered over 50 nodules scattered across all lobes. They first said it presented as metastatic cancer that had spread to my lungs but where was the primary cancer? They also said it could be benign as a result of valley fever or some other healed virus. The latter didn’t make sense to me since they were still growing very slowly. I was monitored with CT scans after I declined a biopsy because they couldn’t reach the largest nodule without cutting my chest wide open. Uh no! After 4 years I declined CTs as most radiologists, oncologists and pulmonologists guessed it was likely benign (mainly because I was still alive and thriving). I pointed out that even if benign they would eventually be a problem as they grew and displaced healthy tissue or caused blockages.

I was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2012 but stage 1 w/BRCA2 mutation so that wasn’t related. Fast forward to 2020 when my breast cancer came back. The CT/PET scan showed most lung tumors had doubled in size in 12 years (that’s very slow growing) so they could now biopsy the largest with a needle and the PET indicated it was cancer. They wanted to know if the lung tumors were related to the breast cancer. The biopsy came back as a typical carcinoid not related to BC. I read up on carcinoids and when I used the term lung NETs to my breast oncologist, he said, “The what?” Hmmm. Maybe I need someone else for the lungs. It was my research on lung NETs that had me baffled why no one else had so many tumors and why didn’t any doctor ever guess lung NETs? It just didn’t make sense to me. They were missing something. That’s when I found the DIPNECH study and the cases sounded more like my case. DIPNECH is multiple benign neuroendocrine tumors that can turn into lung NETs and mine did. DIPNECH also has my respiratory symptoms and typically is diagnosed in middle-aged non-smoking women after years of misdiagnosis as asthma, COPD, etc. Bingo! The official diagnosis came from the NETs team based on the biopsy, history, nodule pattern and symptoms.

Jump to this post

@californiazebra @nannybb @jessie1990 I just got off a Mayo NETs support group call. A lady was just diagnosed with lung carcinoid tumors. She was told by a Thoracic Surgeon that wants to remove a lobe or two. I tried to present what you folks all just taught me. But we talked about finding a NET specialist. Others agreed in general. She is in Louisiana. I found a NET Carcinoid Tumor Surgery Specialist there. Never saw that specialty before. Thanks for the education. We just helped someone.

REPLY
Profile picture for Zebra @californiazebra

@nannybb
I always had asthma when I was sick or exposed to many animals. Then in my 20s I became so sensitive to fragrances that caused coughing, shortness of breath, mucus, bronchitis, etc. I just thought it was allergies and chemical sensitivity. In 2008, I had my first chest CT scan for chronic bronchitis. They discovered over 50 nodules scattered across all lobes. They first said it presented as metastatic cancer that had spread to my lungs but where was the primary cancer? They also said it could be benign as a result of valley fever or some other healed virus. The latter didn’t make sense to me since they were still growing very slowly. I was monitored with CT scans after I declined a biopsy because they couldn’t reach the largest nodule without cutting my chest wide open. Uh no! After 4 years I declined CTs as most radiologists, oncologists and pulmonologists guessed it was likely benign (mainly because I was still alive and thriving). I pointed out that even if benign they would eventually be a problem as they grew and displaced healthy tissue or caused blockages.

I was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2012 but stage 1 w/BRCA2 mutation so that wasn’t related. Fast forward to 2020 when my breast cancer came back. The CT/PET scan showed most lung tumors had doubled in size in 12 years (that’s very slow growing) so they could now biopsy the largest with a needle and the PET indicated it was cancer. They wanted to know if the lung tumors were related to the breast cancer. The biopsy came back as a typical carcinoid not related to BC. I read up on carcinoids and when I used the term lung NETs to my breast oncologist, he said, “The what?” Hmmm. Maybe I need someone else for the lungs. It was my research on lung NETs that had me baffled why no one else had so many tumors and why didn’t any doctor ever guess lung NETs? It just didn’t make sense to me. They were missing something. That’s when I found the DIPNECH study and the cases sounded more like my case. DIPNECH is multiple benign neuroendocrine tumors that can turn into lung NETs and mine did. DIPNECH also has my respiratory symptoms and typically is diagnosed in middle-aged non-smoking women after years of misdiagnosis as asthma, COPD, etc. Bingo! The official diagnosis came from the NETs team based on the biopsy, history, nodule pattern and symptoms.

Jump to this post

@californiazebra Thank you so much for all that information. I looked up DIPNECH as soon as you mentioned it. I have to say, you are tenacious. And it's a good thing you are! I am kind of amazed the breast cancer was not related. I can't remember if I told you a rare form of it is in my family (grandmother and mother). It presents on the outside as a sore on the nipple. Both of my grandmother's breast were removed and she lived for several years. They only took one of my mother's, and hers came back about 7 years later when my father passed. By then it was in her bones and liver. So you still have a lung (or both) full of NETs that they are just watching for now? Did you ever have any medical background?

REPLY
Profile picture for Turkey, Volunteer Mentor @tomrennie

@jessie1990 Did any of your pet scans use a contrast? If so, do you know what type?

Jump to this post

@tomrennie I was going to ask that as well. Also Hopeful are your doctors/surgeons have specialty in NETs /Carcinoid tumors?

REPLY
Profile picture for Turkey, Volunteer Mentor @tomrennie

@californiazebra @nannybb @jessie1990 I just got off a Mayo NETs support group call. A lady was just diagnosed with lung carcinoid tumors. She was told by a Thoracic Surgeon that wants to remove a lobe or two. I tried to present what you folks all just taught me. But we talked about finding a NET specialist. Others agreed in general. She is in Louisiana. I found a NET Carcinoid Tumor Surgery Specialist there. Never saw that specialty before. Thanks for the education. We just helped someone.

Jump to this post

@tomrennie
Good job finding a local NET surgeon for her! Great that our conversation helped someone else. The hope in life is always that our experiences can help those who come behind us. Hopefully a NET surgeon can remove the minimal amount of lung tissue necessary.

REPLY

Hallelujah! Great job!! You all have helped me in so many ways. Most of which has been encouragement and solid information. Just finding out about actual NETs specialists in my area for second opinion was huge. I didn't even know the connection between Carcinoid tumors and NETs until I reached this spot through Mayo. It's sort of a good thing to know in and of itself. 🫶

REPLY
Profile picture for nannybb @nannybb

@californiazebra Thank you so much for all that information. I looked up DIPNECH as soon as you mentioned it. I have to say, you are tenacious. And it's a good thing you are! I am kind of amazed the breast cancer was not related. I can't remember if I told you a rare form of it is in my family (grandmother and mother). It presents on the outside as a sore on the nipple. Both of my grandmother's breast were removed and she lived for several years. They only took one of my mother's, and hers came back about 7 years later when my father passed. By then it was in her bones and liver. So you still have a lung (or both) full of NETs that they are just watching for now? Did you ever have any medical background?

Jump to this post

@nannybb
My breast cancer is your most common hormone driven kind. Even though stage 1, I had a double mastectomy because I have two genetic mutations for BC so had an 85% chance of getting it. I didn’t want more new BC. It recurred in my chest wall and pectoral muscle 7 years later anyway. More surgery, 37 radiation treatments and 5 years of targeted meds so far. Doing good, but the meds are challenging. BC not related to NETs. Nothing alike. Cancer runs heavily in my family and everyone gets a different kind(s) so it wasn't unexpected.

Yes, they just monitor my 50+ tumors with CT scans because I need to preserve the healthy lung tissue. That’s a heavy tumor load. They destroyed the largest 2.6 cm tumor with microwave ablation because it was large and growing faster than others. They feared it might metastasize. That was 5 years ago and successful. All tumors are still confined to my lungs after decades. I need 2 more smaller tumors ablated because they are blocking airways and my lower right lung is shut down but my NETs team disagrees on when. Next CT and discussion is 3 months away.

I’ve been taking octreotide injections for 5 years now and they have been life changing and stopped the 30+ years of coughing all day long. Those around me are thankful too. Octreotide makes me diabetic but worth the trade off. Octreotide has also made me way less sensitive to fragrances so I’m free to go most places now. My coughing was disruptive in movies, at work, pretty much everywhere. I can even pet non-hypoallergenic animals for the first time in my adult life! Yay!!!

Some DIPNECH cases have required lung transplants but that is not the norm. All the other cases I’ve read about had under 15 tumors though. I had a 73 year old pulmonologist tell me he’d never seen so many lung tumors on anyone. He was excited like he had found Bigfoot! Lol

REPLY
Profile picture for nannybb @nannybb

@californiazebra Thank you so much for all that information. I looked up DIPNECH as soon as you mentioned it. I have to say, you are tenacious. And it's a good thing you are! I am kind of amazed the breast cancer was not related. I can't remember if I told you a rare form of it is in my family (grandmother and mother). It presents on the outside as a sore on the nipple. Both of my grandmother's breast were removed and she lived for several years. They only took one of my mother's, and hers came back about 7 years later when my father passed. By then it was in her bones and liver. So you still have a lung (or both) full of NETs that they are just watching for now? Did you ever have any medical background?

Jump to this post

@nannybb
As for any medical background, no, just read a lot. That’s mostly how doctors learn. I have also watched a lot of YouTube videos, presentations and received medical newsletters. Interesting. I did pay medical claims back in the 80s, but that training was about manually calculating insurance benefits in the days of sending in handwritten bills and getting reimbursed. It’s all automated now. However, I would see medical conditions listed and wonder what that was so out came the medical books to find out. Curiosity is the key to learning. 😊

REPLY
Profile picture for nannybb @nannybb

@tomrennie I was going to ask that as well. Also Hopeful are your doctors/surgeons have specialty in NETs /Carcinoid tumors?

Jump to this post

@nannybb when you say your, do you mean Mayo? If so, I have no idea on surgeons. I know each location has NET specialist oncologists. Mine is in Phoenix. When I do any search for medical info, I start the Google search with Mayo then my question or doctor search. My answer usually comes up with Mayo data or links to it I trust their data. If I need further clarification, I search with another reputable health system name in the search. I never use AI. I don't know where that data comes from. AI is like an encyclopedia with blank pages until anyone provides something on the subject online. The AI algorithm finds it. If some better data comes along, then AI replaces it on the page. Make sense? Give it a try for the Mayo surgeons. I am curious what you find. If you can't find out in 3 clicks, stop. Don't waste your time. I will check for you in the morning. OK?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.