Collagen for osteoporosis?

Posted by cpb @cpb, Jul 26, 2021

My friend's medical doctor has her take collagen for her bones. I decided to try it and wondered if anyone knows more than I do about this.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for 4deborahrb @4deborahrb

Should be National Science Foundation? Not Sanitation

Jump to this post

Yes lol!

REPLY
Profile picture for patmacastclk @patmacastclk

I wouldn't take Forteo because I take Synthroid for hypothyroidism. I hope it helps you.

Jump to this post

@patmacastclk, I'm wondering why you wouldn't take Forteo with Synthroid. I am taking Forteo with Tirosint which is a brand name for Levothyroxine like Synthroid.

REPLY

Just make sure you supplement with whatever else you need as well for the collagen to work inside your body such as calcium, magnesium, vitamin D3 and K2, and vitamin C. Otherwise, the collagen alone won't do the trick. That's actually where I'm at. I'm reading a book entitled 'The Healthy Bones' Nutrition Plan and Cookbook by Laura Kelly and Helen Bryman Kelly and it's been extremely informative. Wishing you nothing but the best!

REPLY
Profile picture for drsuefowler @drsuefowler

@patmacastclk, I'm wondering why you wouldn't take Forteo with Synthroid. I am taking Forteo with Tirosint which is a brand name for Levothyroxine like Synthroid.

Jump to this post

Because I would be afraid of a drug interaction.

REPLY
Profile picture for bunky44 @bunky44

Morning Lynn...I like that more info and interest is being directed towards emelorating our bone conditions..instead of having that sinking "oh well" feelings about what we, as patients , we can do for ourselves that not only improves our bone density, but gives us back our power to seek out reasons why we've lost so much bone.
I'm on the search for this reason myself. There has to be a point where something went wrong in my body to cause this amount of bone loss. I'm going to be seeing an Endocrinologist and get as many tests done to try and find the impetus....otherwise I'm just adding to a bucket with a hole in it...leaking out all the bone nutrients that could be going to my bone health.
MD's seem all too happy to write a script for whatever ails us...while not really seeing 'us' as an important component in regaining our bone health and overall health as well....it really is up to us!
I'm not anti-drug...just a seeker of knowledge..wherever that will lead me.
If using a trampoline helps and the data seem reasonable..then do it! If changing one's diet to a more mediterranean one would help..then change! Add in more colors...organic...it doesn't cost more when one eats this way...my costs have gone down now that I eat what I buy and buy small amounts at a time to make sure it's as fresh as I can get. Probiotics are easy to find and enjoy these days..very good for our 'gut'...grass fed dairy....come on folks...I challenge you all reading these to do something different each day for 'you'...get into the solution and out of the worry that's keeping you back from enjoying your lives. I'm here...let's do this! Hugs.....

Jump to this post

so in agreement but totally depressed because despite Algaecal (just for half my daily requirements) walking w weighted vest standing to use laptop during day wt lifting (but not huge amounts per the LIFTMOR test from Austrailia) and lots of dairy my scores got a little worse past 2 .5 years femoral from 2.7 to 2.9 and total hip 2.2 or 2.4 or maybe that's the spine - anyway Dr said they're all 4-6 % worse and is really pushing the Evenity she wanted me on since 2020. It scares me I don't have perfect teeth for one thing. I read this past year about an operation Local Osteo Enhancement Procedure . I'd rather do this than take drugs Curious if anyone knows anything about it.

REPLY
Profile picture for sl303 @sl303

so in agreement but totally depressed because despite Algaecal (just for half my daily requirements) walking w weighted vest standing to use laptop during day wt lifting (but not huge amounts per the LIFTMOR test from Austrailia) and lots of dairy my scores got a little worse past 2 .5 years femoral from 2.7 to 2.9 and total hip 2.2 or 2.4 or maybe that's the spine - anyway Dr said they're all 4-6 % worse and is really pushing the Evenity she wanted me on since 2020. It scares me I don't have perfect teeth for one thing. I read this past year about an operation Local Osteo Enhancement Procedure . I'd rather do this than take drugs Curious if anyone knows anything about it.

Jump to this post

Would you be kind enough to let this group know if you have an evaluation for this procedure and what you learn. I read a small explanation and wondered if it is only for femur and hip. Thanks

REPLY
Profile picture for sl303 @sl303

so in agreement but totally depressed because despite Algaecal (just for half my daily requirements) walking w weighted vest standing to use laptop during day wt lifting (but not huge amounts per the LIFTMOR test from Austrailia) and lots of dairy my scores got a little worse past 2 .5 years femoral from 2.7 to 2.9 and total hip 2.2 or 2.4 or maybe that's the spine - anyway Dr said they're all 4-6 % worse and is really pushing the Evenity she wanted me on since 2020. It scares me I don't have perfect teeth for one thing. I read this past year about an operation Local Osteo Enhancement Procedure . I'd rather do this than take drugs Curious if anyone knows anything about it.

Jump to this post

Hello and thank you for your reply and questions.

I looked up Local Enhancement and it looks really interesting! This procedure looks like it could be used in many areas of bone loss to be able to get a jump start on growing more 'good' bone.

This is the first time I've heard of this..so I'll be looking more into it to see if there is anyone in my area that's dealing with this and offering it as a treatment. I don't know if Medicare would cover the procedure either..so more to learn here.

I agree with you..that dealing with a more holistic approach..rather then a medication that could have other contraindications for our particular physical bodies to deal with. This doesn't look like it has some of those concerns.

I wish you the very best and please keep us all updated on how you are doing..and what you did decide to do.

My very best to you...Bunky

REPLY
Profile picture for bunky44 @bunky44

Hello and thank you for your reply and questions.

I looked up Local Enhancement and it looks really interesting! This procedure looks like it could be used in many areas of bone loss to be able to get a jump start on growing more 'good' bone.

This is the first time I've heard of this..so I'll be looking more into it to see if there is anyone in my area that's dealing with this and offering it as a treatment. I don't know if Medicare would cover the procedure either..so more to learn here.

I agree with you..that dealing with a more holistic approach..rather then a medication that could have other contraindications for our particular physical bodies to deal with. This doesn't look like it has some of those concerns.

I wish you the very best and please keep us all updated on how you are doing..and what you did decide to do.

My very best to you...Bunky

Jump to this post

I would also like to know more about this.

REPLY
Profile picture for sl303 @sl303

so in agreement but totally depressed because despite Algaecal (just for half my daily requirements) walking w weighted vest standing to use laptop during day wt lifting (but not huge amounts per the LIFTMOR test from Austrailia) and lots of dairy my scores got a little worse past 2 .5 years femoral from 2.7 to 2.9 and total hip 2.2 or 2.4 or maybe that's the spine - anyway Dr said they're all 4-6 % worse and is really pushing the Evenity she wanted me on since 2020. It scares me I don't have perfect teeth for one thing. I read this past year about an operation Local Osteo Enhancement Procedure . I'd rather do this than take drugs Curious if anyone knows anything about it.

Jump to this post

@sl303 I may have missed something but what do you mean when you state "It scares me I don't have perfect teeth for one thing.?" Thanks!

REPLY

Is LiveWell brand of collagen peptides (grass fed and pasture good, where can you find this? I need to try it, instead of having a doctor hand a rx etc. thanks!

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.