Options if MAC goes untreated

Posted by goatlady @goatlady, Feb 22, 2021

MY ID Doctor took me off the "BIG 3" last October because I wasn't able to produce any sputum (never have). Had a CT-Scan done in January showing the MAC is still and Bronchiectasis has gotten worst. My Pulmonary Doctor got in touch with ID Doctor about putting me back on the "Big 3". The ID Doctor won't, she called in a prescription of propranlol. Many years ago another doctor prescribed that for me. I had the worst reaction to that. There is no way I am going to try that drug again. So what happens if I don't treat the MAC?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the MAC & Bronchiectasis Support Group.

@blm1007blm1007

Linda-
It appears I did not send properly my original reply, I don't see it here on this thread.
To keep it short and for confirmation did it take two years to rid yourself of the MAC?
Have you had a positive culture(s)at any time after that period when your cultures showed you eliminated the MAC?
You apparently did build a "brick house."
Barbara

Jump to this post

@blm1007blm1007 I read a while back in a study that spontaneous clearance of MAC takes on average 2 1/2 years, so Linda’s 2 year time frame seems on point. Off the top of my head I believe the study said that in a group that had stable CT’s for three years, 38% achieved spontaneous clearance, again with average timeframe of 2.5 years. The trick of course is having a stable CT. And even then the majority don’t spontaneously clear. Still, the percentage of those with a stable CT that do clear is not insignificant.

REPLY
@bayarea58

@blm1007blm1007 I read a while back in a study that spontaneous clearance of MAC takes on average 2 1/2 years, so Linda’s 2 year time frame seems on point. Off the top of my head I believe the study said that in a group that had stable CT’s for three years, 38% achieved spontaneous clearance, again with average timeframe of 2.5 years. The trick of course is having a stable CT. And even then the majority don’t spontaneously clear. Still, the percentage of those with a stable CT that do clear is not insignificant.

Jump to this post

Do you happen to know where you read that? I always try to make certain I am relying on researched evidence based info. Not that I think you are mistaken or giving bad information- just like to read it for myself.

REPLY
@jnmy

Hi Sue, @sueinmn Thanks for the response and tips from others as well. I do use postural drainage, breathing techniques and will restart Aerobika. Airway clearance is most important I was told, and I eat healthy meals and snacks and try to keep up my BMI. I often wear masks in crowded places, use nasal irrigation to help with occasional sinus issues and after being out in crowds. Exercise too but I could do more at times. I will use NAC once in the mornings now since twice a day might have lowered my diastolic pressure. Trying to figure that out.

Fortunately I don’t have MAC or cavities to treat at this point, and was told that my BE is mild despite the coloured mucus that must be cleared each day. BE can leave me feeling fatigued at times. I pace myself if that is the case.

I guess the cilia in my lobes / lungs were destroyed or partially destroyed by infections but the specialist says I only have mild Bronchiectasis.

I’m fortunate that my lung function etc is normal. I’ve read about the various scales that are used to assess severity of BE. I have mild BE now, but with age and possible infections over the years, that could change? That’s why I’m adamant about doing the airway clearance each day. I was told it can potentially help clear infections.

Nebulizing with saline is not something that has been recommended to me, although I have a lot of mucus to expel, but no asthma or other health challenges at present. I’m grateful for that.

I was wondering if nebbing might be something to consider to help avoid MAC or are there some risks to it at this stage for anyone without MAC? Thanks again. I welcome the suggestions or tips.

Jump to this post

I sure wish I had known about nebulizing with saline when my BE was still mild! I think it would have been a game changer.

REPLY
@irenea8

I sure wish I had known about nebulizing with saline when my BE was still mild! I think it would have been a game changer.

Jump to this post

I also think that what does get lost between patient and doctors, after they tell you about starting and using nebulizing and Aerobika, is the full air way clearance techniques that are so important.....such as postural drainage and the importance of why you want to do deep breathing to get air behind the mucus/mucus plugs to help move it out. That is what truly happened to me until I came to this Mayo site and learned there is more to just nebulizing and the Aerobika. The understanding and finding my best postural drainage technique along with my full understanding was/is a 'game changer'. Thanks to all who post and give videos to watch.!
Barbara

REPLY
@cwal

Do you happen to know where you read that? I always try to make certain I am relying on researched evidence based info. Not that I think you are mistaken or giving bad information- just like to read it for myself.

Jump to this post

@cwal I went through my stack and located the study, it is one of the foundational studies supporting and cited in the 2020 NTM Guidelines. My memory was more conservative than the actual study results, which note that 51.6% of those stable for 3 years achieved spontaneous clearance. I highly recommend that everyone read the 2020 guidelines and the studies cited therein.

Hwang JA, Kim S, Jo K-W, Shim TS. Natural history of Mycobacterium avium complex lung disease in untreated patients with stable course. Eur Respir J 2017;49:1600537.
Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar

I want to add that this is a patient-based support group and none of us are providing medical advice. No one should be relying on my comments, or any other member’s comments, for their treatment decisions. We are all sharing our experiences and resources as acts of generosity, and to the extent that shared information is of interest, it should only be a starting point for each of us to do our own research and analysis, discuss with our medical team., etc. I really appreciate this group, it has been a tremendous resource for me precisely because of other’s candor. For me, I don’t want anyone to hesitate to share their thoughts on a topic for fear of being labeled “mistaken” or “bad information”.

Lastly, while I understand the significance of “researched evidence based info” the 2020 NTM treating guidelines themselves note throughout how little evidentiary support there actually is for the guidelines. And to me much of the available “science” on NTM is of uncertain value given they are frequently small, single center review studies of incomplete medical records. We are all in waters that have been relatively unstudied, and for me, that necessities an open mindset. Again, I want everyone to share whatever thoughts, opinions, experiences, and resources they’ve got. It is all valuable to me.

REPLY

Hello forum. So happy to have found all this wisdom and grateful for being able to share the MAC experience. I was diagnosed with MAC in Oct 2024. My main symptom is coughing up blood which I did last night for about 20 min until I reached clear sputum. This is now the 5th time since April 2024. I’ve been to the ER twice but now am getting used to it and Dr says it’s part of the diagnosis but it happens at the most impossibly inconvenient times
Ex: night before Thanksgiving, right before I have to get on an airplane like now, etc. The first visit to ER after coughing up about 1/4 cup of blood is when they noticed the “several small cavitary nodules in lower and upper right lung” Am just getting used to Pulmonary hygiene which still needs refining - it’s the part I’m resisting and need help with. I’m very active but Dr said no more hot yoga which is awful because I’ve been doing it forever. Speaking of which, on the three occasions I’ve done a handstand and plow (both inversions) I began to cough up blood so not sure what that means other than the lungs are being affected by the compression of the yoga asana. Also nose is running constantly. The shortness of breath is getting uncomfortable too and I’m having constant heart palpitations which Dr says is from Azithromycin (Cardiologist says heart looks perfect) Given that everyone has a different experience of this condition I’m wondering how to think about the progression of things: do I expect more blood? Increased shortnesss of breath? More inhalers? Dr doesn’t give a clear picture but maybe this disease is not linear - at least he says my case isn’t serious but that seems hard to believe with all this coughing up of blood. I started titrating the 3 antibiotics (first Azithromycin, then Ethambutol, have yet to add Rigampin) on Oct 20, 2024 and felt better initially but not feeling great now. Also wondering about altitude as I love to ski. One last question: has anyone read “Reducing Exposure to NTM” by Joseph Falkinham? Be well everyone. Many thanks Joanna

REPLY
@bayarea58

@cwal I went through my stack and located the study, it is one of the foundational studies supporting and cited in the 2020 NTM Guidelines. My memory was more conservative than the actual study results, which note that 51.6% of those stable for 3 years achieved spontaneous clearance. I highly recommend that everyone read the 2020 guidelines and the studies cited therein.

Hwang JA, Kim S, Jo K-W, Shim TS. Natural history of Mycobacterium avium complex lung disease in untreated patients with stable course. Eur Respir J 2017;49:1600537.
Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar

I want to add that this is a patient-based support group and none of us are providing medical advice. No one should be relying on my comments, or any other member’s comments, for their treatment decisions. We are all sharing our experiences and resources as acts of generosity, and to the extent that shared information is of interest, it should only be a starting point for each of us to do our own research and analysis, discuss with our medical team., etc. I really appreciate this group, it has been a tremendous resource for me precisely because of other’s candor. For me, I don’t want anyone to hesitate to share their thoughts on a topic for fear of being labeled “mistaken” or “bad information”.

Lastly, while I understand the significance of “researched evidence based info” the 2020 NTM treating guidelines themselves note throughout how little evidentiary support there actually is for the guidelines. And to me much of the available “science” on NTM is of uncertain value given they are frequently small, single center review studies of incomplete medical records. We are all in waters that have been relatively unstudied, and for me, that necessities an open mindset. Again, I want everyone to share whatever thoughts, opinions, experiences, and resources they’ve got. It is all valuable to me.

Jump to this post

Thanks for digging up that info! In agreement with all you said. And as I stated, I like to read it for myself.

REPLY
@joannamaria

Hello forum. So happy to have found all this wisdom and grateful for being able to share the MAC experience. I was diagnosed with MAC in Oct 2024. My main symptom is coughing up blood which I did last night for about 20 min until I reached clear sputum. This is now the 5th time since April 2024. I’ve been to the ER twice but now am getting used to it and Dr says it’s part of the diagnosis but it happens at the most impossibly inconvenient times
Ex: night before Thanksgiving, right before I have to get on an airplane like now, etc. The first visit to ER after coughing up about 1/4 cup of blood is when they noticed the “several small cavitary nodules in lower and upper right lung” Am just getting used to Pulmonary hygiene which still needs refining - it’s the part I’m resisting and need help with. I’m very active but Dr said no more hot yoga which is awful because I’ve been doing it forever. Speaking of which, on the three occasions I’ve done a handstand and plow (both inversions) I began to cough up blood so not sure what that means other than the lungs are being affected by the compression of the yoga asana. Also nose is running constantly. The shortness of breath is getting uncomfortable too and I’m having constant heart palpitations which Dr says is from Azithromycin (Cardiologist says heart looks perfect) Given that everyone has a different experience of this condition I’m wondering how to think about the progression of things: do I expect more blood? Increased shortnesss of breath? More inhalers? Dr doesn’t give a clear picture but maybe this disease is not linear - at least he says my case isn’t serious but that seems hard to believe with all this coughing up of blood. I started titrating the 3 antibiotics (first Azithromycin, then Ethambutol, have yet to add Rigampin) on Oct 20, 2024 and felt better initially but not feeling great now. Also wondering about altitude as I love to ski. One last question: has anyone read “Reducing Exposure to NTM” by Joseph Falkinham? Be well everyone. Many thanks Joanna

Jump to this post

Hello Joanna, you said: Am just getting used to Pulmonary hygiene which still needs refining - it’s the part I’m resisting and need help with.

I bet if you could tolerate the saline and or other airway clearance routines, you might not cough up the blood as often or as much? I have found that true in my case.

REPLY
@joannamaria

Hello forum. So happy to have found all this wisdom and grateful for being able to share the MAC experience. I was diagnosed with MAC in Oct 2024. My main symptom is coughing up blood which I did last night for about 20 min until I reached clear sputum. This is now the 5th time since April 2024. I’ve been to the ER twice but now am getting used to it and Dr says it’s part of the diagnosis but it happens at the most impossibly inconvenient times
Ex: night before Thanksgiving, right before I have to get on an airplane like now, etc. The first visit to ER after coughing up about 1/4 cup of blood is when they noticed the “several small cavitary nodules in lower and upper right lung” Am just getting used to Pulmonary hygiene which still needs refining - it’s the part I’m resisting and need help with. I’m very active but Dr said no more hot yoga which is awful because I’ve been doing it forever. Speaking of which, on the three occasions I’ve done a handstand and plow (both inversions) I began to cough up blood so not sure what that means other than the lungs are being affected by the compression of the yoga asana. Also nose is running constantly. The shortness of breath is getting uncomfortable too and I’m having constant heart palpitations which Dr says is from Azithromycin (Cardiologist says heart looks perfect) Given that everyone has a different experience of this condition I’m wondering how to think about the progression of things: do I expect more blood? Increased shortnesss of breath? More inhalers? Dr doesn’t give a clear picture but maybe this disease is not linear - at least he says my case isn’t serious but that seems hard to believe with all this coughing up of blood. I started titrating the 3 antibiotics (first Azithromycin, then Ethambutol, have yet to add Rigampin) on Oct 20, 2024 and felt better initially but not feeling great now. Also wondering about altitude as I love to ski. One last question: has anyone read “Reducing Exposure to NTM” by Joseph Falkinham? Be well everyone. Many thanks Joanna

Jump to this post

Welcome, Joanna, to our group. When you are first diagnosed with MAC, it can feel as if your entire world has been turned upside down - new medications (and their side effects), coughing (and coughing up blood), having to change the way you live life...it can seem overwhelming.

Let's start here "...Given that everyone has a different experience of this condition I’m wondering how to think about the progression of things..." Getting rid of the infection should be #1 - you are lucky we are nearly into 2025 as the protocols have changed, and if the 3 drugs don't do the trick, there is an inhaled antibiotic that can be added. After that, it depends...my Bronchiectasis has been stable per CT for 5 years now, the nodules went away after treatment, I have a new med to control my underlying asthma, and my pulmonary function has not worsened. Not everyone is so fortunate, but I believe asthma control, airway clearance, 7% saline, diet and exercise have helped (though I have slacked off on the exercise while healing from shoulder surgery.)

And you asked, "...Also wondering about altitude as I love to ski..." Everyone is different, so I can only share my own experience - while I had an active MAC infection and was on the meds, I could not tolerate even 5000 feet without severe altitude sickness symptoms, so I was leery of the mountains for a few years. Now, as long as I give my body a day to acclimate before vigorous activity , I have no problem.

Finally, I am not surprised by your doctor's prohibition on hot yoga - mycobacteria thrive in a warm, moist environment, and become concentrated in small spaces, that's why Dr Falkinham is so adamant about avoiding indoor hot tubs and spas too. He would definitely agree with your doc about hot yoga.

Have you begun doing airway clearance? @irenea8 is a great resource to consult about how to do it safely with hemoptysis.
Here is a great video on why we do it, Dr McShane is one of our best resources:

REPLY
@joannamaria

Hello forum. So happy to have found all this wisdom and grateful for being able to share the MAC experience. I was diagnosed with MAC in Oct 2024. My main symptom is coughing up blood which I did last night for about 20 min until I reached clear sputum. This is now the 5th time since April 2024. I’ve been to the ER twice but now am getting used to it and Dr says it’s part of the diagnosis but it happens at the most impossibly inconvenient times
Ex: night before Thanksgiving, right before I have to get on an airplane like now, etc. The first visit to ER after coughing up about 1/4 cup of blood is when they noticed the “several small cavitary nodules in lower and upper right lung” Am just getting used to Pulmonary hygiene which still needs refining - it’s the part I’m resisting and need help with. I’m very active but Dr said no more hot yoga which is awful because I’ve been doing it forever. Speaking of which, on the three occasions I’ve done a handstand and plow (both inversions) I began to cough up blood so not sure what that means other than the lungs are being affected by the compression of the yoga asana. Also nose is running constantly. The shortness of breath is getting uncomfortable too and I’m having constant heart palpitations which Dr says is from Azithromycin (Cardiologist says heart looks perfect) Given that everyone has a different experience of this condition I’m wondering how to think about the progression of things: do I expect more blood? Increased shortnesss of breath? More inhalers? Dr doesn’t give a clear picture but maybe this disease is not linear - at least he says my case isn’t serious but that seems hard to believe with all this coughing up of blood. I started titrating the 3 antibiotics (first Azithromycin, then Ethambutol, have yet to add Rigampin) on Oct 20, 2024 and felt better initially but not feeling great now. Also wondering about altitude as I love to ski. One last question: has anyone read “Reducing Exposure to NTM” by Joseph Falkinham? Be well everyone. Many thanks Joanna

Jump to this post

Oh Joanna-
Sounds like you are much younger than me, I'm 82. The fact is that I had/have to face "life changes." As we know, almost nothing stays the same.
As you know, it is not an easy thing to accept but if we want to do right by ourselves....well...those hard decisions have to be made.
Like for me, deciding to take the meds. vs. a personal challenge of wanting to clear the MAI on my own and hoping I can. BUT that challenge may soon come to...TAKE THE MED'S.
Wishing you a way to find all your answers and needed decisions and that as we know goes for all of us.
Barbara

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.