Does anyone have info re Maradyne, a low intensity vibration
device that may help stimulate bone density?
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.
device that may help stimulate bone density?
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.
It sounds like you decided to keep the Marodyne LIV based off of the results in https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33314313/. If that's correct, actually that study was published by the Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, not NIH, though the investigators received grants from NIH to conduct the study. (Pubmed is a search engine to biomedical and life sciences literature and is maintained by the National Library of Medicine, which is part of NIH.)
I admit I only skimmed that article after you referenced it. It seemed the study was small (n=80 total); included only postmenopausal women with normal bone density or osteopenia (low bone mass); did not take into account nutrition, exercise, fracture history, and other factors; etc. The study may have been more meaningful to me if it had used postmenopausal women with osteoporosis (though that may be deemed unsafe or unethical).
I continue to wait for more evidence (including VIBMOR trial) regarding vibration platforms. Perhaps they are helpful for persons with osteoporosis who have a sedentary lifestyle or can't do weight-bearing exercise. I am grateful that I'm physically capable of doing weight-bearing exercise. And it doesn't require a major outlay of money either!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 ReactionsThank you, for pointing out all of that. We do appreciate it. And, yes, keeping and using the Marodyne LIV, not based on adequate, definitive research, but the paucity of momentum for the device. Like you, we'll watch for the VIBMOR results and hoping that will validate our decision. (On another related subject, I'm about to post a question about collagen peptides and their influence on calcium uptake as applies to BMD and Osteoporosis. You seem a good person to ask for an opinion. Specifically we're using a product from Health Direct, called AminoSculpt, claiming to contain 18gm of amino peptides.)
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 ReactionsNote that the first study had only 42 people using the machine average age of 61 and 38 in the placebo group average age of 58. None of the participants had DEXA scores lower than -2.5 and none of them had fractures.
The second study was odd and concluded "This study indicates that low-level mechanical stimuli may have the potential to prevent bone loss in the postmenopausal population, but failed to stimulate the formation of bone."
The 2nd 12 month 2009 study started with 70 participants and ended up with 46, but since the study allowed replacement of anyone who dropped out within the first 3 months they weren't the same participants. The machines were used at home and none of the participants' diet or exercise was monitored. None of the participants had fractures before the study and starting DEXA scores were not a factor in eligibility. All of the women were 3 to 8 years past menopause but age was not recorded.
The 2nd study was paid for by the manufacturer of a vibration machine.
Also include trace minerals and going up the stairs then jumping from the last 2 or 3 steps, 20 times at least 3 times a week.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
1 ReactionThank you for your post. My question is, since it has been about 1 1/2 years since you posted this would you please give us the results of your usage of the Marodyne LIV? I am very interested in hearing if it proved to be beneficial to you. I want to try it but only if I feel it has really been effective in real life. I cannot afford to waste $3200. Thank you very much!
Carol
Hi Naomid, I just bought a Marodyne and have read many stories, both positive and negative so a bit worried! I'm wondering if you like yours and how your DEXA was one year later?
Many thanks,
Lisa
Hi! How is your machine now, and your bones? Hopefully all good! Lisa 🙂
Hi Lamay, I just ordered one. How is your's doing now? And how are you doing? Many thanks, Lisa
Hi TG,
Just read your great post. I bought a Marodyne, and haven't received it yet, and I really hope it helps me but can you please tell me your experience over the past year? Many thanks, Lisa
Thank you so much Hans. I hope you're doing well with the marodyne and your osteo? Please share an update if you can 🙂 All the best, Lisa