Weight lifting - bone scans improved in one year!

Posted by vga @vga, Apr 21 6:47pm

I'm a 62-year-old woman, average weight, healthy eater, and a runner. I was diagnosed with osteoporosis last year with my first bone scan. I tried one dose of oral Fosamax--it made me terribly sick--so I stopped immediately. I researched alternatives, adding Vitamin K2 and D to my supplements, and started weight lifting with heavy weights 5-6 times a week. I researched specific osteroporosis weight lifting programs, but couldn't find a coach nearby. So, I just started using youtube videos and lifting heavy weights. I just had a repeat bone scan that showed improvement in all my numbers--moving osteoporosis to osteopenia for some locations. My worst area is my L3--this improved by 30%! In one year! Very excited to share this. I hope that sharing my results might encourage others to try weight lifing.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

I do drop jumps as described in the below video. But starting off more gently with heel drops etc is the safer way. Building bone in the femoral neck is the hardest, and impact exercise seems to be the only way to do it. I also use WBV on my non-gym days. Lots of other discussions about WBV on this site. My model was recommended by a doctor's office and

REPLY
Profile picture for daisy17 @daisy17

@mvelazquez26 I also take AlgaeCal collagen. It was the cheapest one I could find on Amazon, especially if you buy two at one time and sign up for autoship.

Jump to this post

REPLY

I’ve taken a couple of containers, did fine in coffee,but now I want to ask my primary care doc about it It’s not that it’s bad by itself, but I’ve been reading articles that said women with dense breasts might find that collagen makes scans harder to read because of how it adheres and blocks things. I might be overthinking it, but I’d feel better if she looked into it too because the Internet’s full of tiny studies.

REPLY
Profile picture for debraran @debraran

I’ve taken a couple of containers, did fine in coffee,but now I want to ask my primary care doc about it It’s not that it’s bad by itself, but I’ve been reading articles that said women with dense breasts might find that collagen makes scans harder to read because of how it adheres and blocks things. I might be overthinking it, but I’d feel better if she looked into it too because the Internet’s full of tiny studies.

Jump to this post

@debraran That's interesting so I did some research. Here's one article I found that summarizes: "Studies reveal that dense or disorganized collagen around tumors can contribute to cancer cell migration. However, this refers to natural tissue collagen, not dietary supplements. There’s no direct evidence that taking collagen orally causes these structural changes."
https://rootvitalityhealth.com/blogs/news/does-collagen-supplements-increase-the-risk-of-breast-cancer-expert-evidence-safety-insights

REPLY

Thanks, it's a little disconcerting. I know my sister who had breast cancer had the estrogen receptive type but my mom didn't. My mom lived to 97 but never was tested for gene, my sister was and negative. (although I swear they find new gene tests daily) This article made me think of finishing the rest of collagen but not daily, a few times a week. My doctor said sadly, although very healthy right now, my breasts didn't get less dense after menopause. I need an ultrasound done at the same time. Another part of article:
Current evidence does not show that collagen supplements increase the risk of breast cancer. Collagen plays a natural structural role in breast tissue, but supplements do not appear to trigger or promote cancer. However, collagen’s interaction with breast density, estrogen levels, and the tumor microenvironment remains under scientific review. Individuals with hormone-sensitive conditions or BRCA mutations should consult a healthcare professional before use.
And from this site, some women are blaming it on cancer but who knows if they never took it, would it be the same? You can't comment on that, with all the stress of diagnosis you always look for something.
https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/collagen-supplements-and-breast-cancer/

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.