Red meat & Prostrate Cancer

Posted by cole5055 @cole5055, Jan 30 2:02pm

Some Doctors recommend not eating any Beef, pork, or eliminate all animal proteins……..They say it feeds the cancer? I have encountered say many different opinions very confusing on which path to chose? Keto or Carnivore? Also let me know what has worked well for you 😊

Thank you in advance for your feedback 🙏😊

Ray

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

Profile picture for carbcounter @carbcounter

@drcopp My friend went on the Ornish diet after a (completely unexpected) coronary and stents, but it seemed a little old fashioned and behind the times and oversimplifies. I'll say once again, eliminating red meat is not nearly as important as balancing your omega 6-3-9, a red meat carnivore diet will unbalance your omegas. And really there are several other EFA issues. This may be a fair criticism of keto diets, too. Balance and moderation has a lot going for it.

Even in diabetic diets what is most important is moderation, you can eat small amounts of almost anything just so the totals stay below a certain level.

And anti-inflammatory foods and supplements, turmeric/curcumin and colored fruits and vegetables - and some mushrooms for the ergothioneine - also teas with hibiscus or berries, reinforce these moderate diets.

Jump to this post

@carbcounter Yes, I agree with most of what you are saying, yet we can't dismiss the idea that if something like a bacon or lunchmeat is a class I carcinogen, then I stay away from it. Again, the ICF-1 molecular structure in all meats and fish, along with the heme proteins in pork put us at risk for stimulating cancer.
The American Dietetics Association position paper on the best diet reported the veggie or vegan, but apparently the lead committee chairman on national health didn't think that Americans could handle so radical of a change, so he sided with the Mediterranean or DASH diets. See attached study.

Shared files

ADA Dietetics Position on Vegetarian-Diet (1) (ADA-Dietetics-Position-on-Vegetarian-Diet-1.pdf)

REPLY
Profile picture for gkgdawg @gkgdawg

@cole5055 I agree with you, Cole. My husband had a biopsy (not targeted, unfortunately) and it seemed that things went badly after that. We were assured by his urologist that we had caught it in time and there was no rush. Wrong. Within 6 months, PSA had gone up considerably and it had metastasized.

Jump to this post

@gkgdawg Also, he ended up with sepsis and was in hospital for 5 days.

REPLY
Profile picture for cole5055 @cole5055

@gkgdawg

Yes, I understand sometimes sticking needles into prostate cancer is not good! common sense tells us this, it’s just frustrating we still use this barbaric 60 year old technology despite all our advancements in medical technology?

When I had the random biopsy my PSA jumped from 8 to 15.1 in a few months. This is why if you’re going to biopsy anything we need a specific target! Not stabbing the prostate with a blind fold on it makes absolutely no sense! Hoping we hit something and possibly spreading the disease?

The Doctors are so used to doing things as usual. I think if they were the ones on the other end of the needle they would have an entirely different perspective…………. I hope things turn for the better for your Husband Godspeed 🙏

Ray 😊🇺🇸

Jump to this post

@cole5055 That is my feeling, as well

REPLY

You may want to chase down the original article, but here's a link: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35637041/ and the You/Tube presentation referred to it.

REPLY

I followed a very healthy Mediterranean-style diet even before my prostate surgery last September, with little to no processed food and very minimal red meat. After my prostate cancer diagnosis, I refined my diet further with the goal of reducing the risk of recurrence.

My diet now consists mostly of fish (especially salmon and sardines), tree nuts like walnuts and almonds, broccoli and other leafy greens, tomatoes (particularly cooked), mushrooms, whole grains, lentils, beans, pomegranates, blueberries, yogurt, and fruits such as mangoes and cantaloupe. I’ve also added turmeric and ginger, which fit well into this overall pattern.

REPLY
Profile picture for soli @soli

I followed a very healthy Mediterranean-style diet even before my prostate surgery last September, with little to no processed food and very minimal red meat. After my prostate cancer diagnosis, I refined my diet further with the goal of reducing the risk of recurrence.

My diet now consists mostly of fish (especially salmon and sardines), tree nuts like walnuts and almonds, broccoli and other leafy greens, tomatoes (particularly cooked), mushrooms, whole grains, lentils, beans, pomegranates, blueberries, yogurt, and fruits such as mangoes and cantaloupe. I’ve also added turmeric and ginger, which fit well into this overall pattern.

Jump to this post

@soli I think there's an aspect of this that many miss: processed foods. I cut them out a long time ago as well, and if one is to cut something then this should be it - who knows how many health issues we have as of a result of highly processing what we eat with chemicals that we can barely pronounce!

REPLY
Profile picture for heavyphil @heavyphil

@kjacko Yeah, I think the concern with dairy is that the cows may be treated with rBST, which in turn boosts IGF-1 which can cause certain cancers to grow - NOT CAUSE, but grow. So drink milk with no rBST and you should be OK.
As far as milk substitutes, even the unsweetened ones are made with seed oils, which have been said to promote cancer and heart disease because of their reduced Omega 3 levels…I’m just stating what I’ve read and I surely don’t know for a fact if anything I wrote in this entire post is true or not; everything we post here is mostly based on what we’ve been told, heard or read.
The only thing I DO know for sure is that milk comes from cows, goats and sheep and has been consumed in various forms for thousands of years - thousands, OK?
If it’s so freakin bad and causes prostate cancer, PCa should have been mentioned in some form - even a non scientific one - millennia ago, no?
If WE have messed up our planet so much that the grass the ruminants eat is poisoned and the other man made things we feed them is detrimental to us (rBST), then extend that logic to every darn thing you put in your mouth, because believe me, BIG AGRO didn’t stop at the cows…
Sorry to rant, been reading way too much about Monsanto/Bayer et al….Best,
Phil

Jump to this post

@heavyphil Can’t argue with your reasoning. We could ask 10 experts about a single topic and get ten different opinions. The world we live in.

REPLY
Profile picture for survivor5280 @survivor5280

@soli I think there's an aspect of this that many miss: processed foods. I cut them out a long time ago as well, and if one is to cut something then this should be it - who knows how many health issues we have as of a result of highly processing what we eat with chemicals that we can barely pronounce!

Jump to this post

@survivor5280

No question about that: processed meats such as bacon, hotdogs and sausage are classified as Group 1 carcinogens by the World Health Organization.

REPLY
Profile picture for drcopp @drcopp

@carbcounter Yes, I agree with most of what you are saying, yet we can't dismiss the idea that if something like a bacon or lunchmeat is a class I carcinogen, then I stay away from it. Again, the ICF-1 molecular structure in all meats and fish, along with the heme proteins in pork put us at risk for stimulating cancer.
The American Dietetics Association position paper on the best diet reported the veggie or vegan, but apparently the lead committee chairman on national health didn't think that Americans could handle so radical of a change, so he sided with the Mediterranean or DASH diets. See attached study.

Jump to this post

@drcopp
FWIW I have cut my consumption of bacon and lunchmeats down very close to zero, but this is more because of fat and salt content than association with cancer. And generally eat far less red meat than I was brought up with, but again not directly with cancer in mind. As far as that goes, I don't know. The sun is a class I carcinogen yet a little sun exposure seems to have important benefits. The cancer risk from meat may come more from unbalancing your diet in that direction - yet these carnivore diets seem very popular and if they brought on added cancer risk in proportion I think we'd know it. So I still arrive at moderation in all things, and try to eat better quality red meat when I eat it at all, and also try to avoid burning it, another detail that might have outsized consequences.

The paper is quite good, they make it clear that one MUST watch nutrition more carefully if you pursue a vegan diet. Still it reads as someone supporting a decision already made, not so much concluding it from a neutral study.

I had a neighbor who was vegan and always telling me about it, he never seemed to mention supplements, yet anytime I raised an issue he was already taking care of it - he did his homework! I also surveyed a number of vegan restaurants around town with another friend who was on the Ornish diet, one impressed me, but usually I get better food at a general restaurant that has some vegan dishes, IMHO.

REPLY
Profile picture for cole5055 @cole5055

@carbcounter

Yes, absolutely 👍🏻 I really appreciate your input! I have been looking into white button mushrooms. They have capsules @ powder, but I believe they also have multodextrose after reading the ingredients. So buying fresh ones is the way to go and short and long term fasting would also help……..

Thank you 😊
Ray

Jump to this post

@cole5055
I should do more fasting, one day is generally sufficient for me, I think, or two or three days of very light eating, I've seen that touted recently and it makes sense to me.

Types of mushrooms don't matter too much, it seems, none has a lot of nutrients, I was big on shiitake (aka black mushrooms) for a while, can be very directly helpful on blood pressure, but have to be cooked correctly to have good texture. The "baby bella" aka cremini are good, or simple white mushrooms. Prefer most foods as foods, not capsules, just sauté (or microwave) with a little olive oil or butter, some Worcestershire sauce or your choice of spices, just black pepper and garlic will do, and suddenly they're quite savory and you can throw them into anything on the plate with excellent results!

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.