Osteoporosis with supplements

Posted by sazzam @sazzam, 3 days ago

Hi, I am a petit woman, 52 years old with osteoporosis -2.7 in my left hip, moderate oestopenia in spine and severe oestopenia in wrist and arms. I also have a tear in the interior meniscus in my right knee so I walk with a cane. I live alone as I have no family or children. I am a piscitarian, don't smoke, don't drink, and cut down on fizzy drinks and junk food 6 months ago. I learnt about my osteoporosis a year ago and I don't feel confident taking any medication. I started taking piscaldine and oesteodense, and am trying to maintain a healthy life style (enough dairy, protein, calcium intake) along with physiotherapy. The more I read about medications, their side effects and surgeries, I get petrified, especially when health care in my country is not that good, and I am on my own. Are there any natural ways to help maintain the bone density without these medications? I would very much appreciate your experience and advice.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

There a a number of existing threads addressing you questions. Check under the heading Osteoporosis. There is much written and discussed already that may help you find answers

REPLY

Sazzam,
at 52 you've only begun to lose the estrogen that keeps our bones strong. During the next ten years the pattern for women is bone loss. We usually stabilize with low bone mass and at risk for fracture at around 62 years.
I can see unusual trouble if the available healthcare isn't good and you don't have someone to fight for you, you might not get help for an adverse reaction.
What medications would be available to you? I think it is wiser to be on the safer medications abaloparatide and teriparatide because if they cause unbearable side effects you can just quit them without penalty.
Medication effects are potentially quite frightening. There are many who have mild effects or no adverse effects. Fracture is more frightening to me.
You can really help your bones with D3, K2, Calcium, collagen your already perfect diet and exercise. Tillymack mentions HRT another valuable addition to help stabilize your bones. It is just really hard to regain bone that is already lost. I decided that I had to do all of these things plus the medication to preserve autonomy.
Bless your choice.

REPLY

Has anyone tried using natural supplements to treat their osteoporosis? Even though I have a T score of -3.5 I’m not ready to jump into these heavy duty drugs for the rest of my life.
Just had my bone density done last month. I’m 77.

REPLY

Susan, most of us use supplements with heavy duty drugs. There are those who report dexa success with supplements alone. And those who fracture meanwhile.
Though this is a cautious group, Mayo connect seems a little pharmaceutical leaning.
The commenter I've found most compelling in the natural group is @kathleen1314. She has done extensive research on strontium citrate.
I was too afraid of fracturing, so I'm on Forteo.
At 77 with a -3.5, you've done well. We tend to lose the most bone between 52 and 62, because of estrogen loss.
Best wishes.

REPLY
Profile picture for gently @gently

Sazzam,
at 52 you've only begun to lose the estrogen that keeps our bones strong. During the next ten years the pattern for women is bone loss. We usually stabilize with low bone mass and at risk for fracture at around 62 years.
I can see unusual trouble if the available healthcare isn't good and you don't have someone to fight for you, you might not get help for an adverse reaction.
What medications would be available to you? I think it is wiser to be on the safer medications abaloparatide and teriparatide because if they cause unbearable side effects you can just quit them without penalty.
Medication effects are potentially quite frightening. There are many who have mild effects or no adverse effects. Fracture is more frightening to me.
You can really help your bones with D3, K2, Calcium, collagen your already perfect diet and exercise. Tillymack mentions HRT another valuable addition to help stabilize your bones. It is just really hard to regain bone that is already lost. I decided that I had to do all of these things plus the medication to preserve autonomy.
Bless your choice.

Jump to this post

@gently I certainly appreciate your caring and thoughtful responses. I now have a specialist appointment for early November. Very happy with that. I’m hoping for Forteo. Hoping I don’t have to pay but we’ll see. Kind of in limbo as alendronate while waiting did not work well for me at all.

REPLY

You might want to investigate strontium citrate and BHRT, bioidentical hormone therapy.
I had similar results in my hip area years ago, but after strontium citrte and BHRT, I now have "normal" dexa readings with no fractures, no side effects.
Other users have used strontium citrate without BHRT with similar good results so the BHRT does not seem necessary.
Here ia a posting which I did on Inspire which is a compilation of strontium research and contains a posting of the personal stories of people on Inspire who have used strontium citrate.
https://www.inspire.com/groups/bone-health-and-osteoporosis/discussion/dd823b-strontium-a-compilation-of-research-and-information/

REPLY
Profile picture for Susan @csuhilty

Has anyone tried using natural supplements to treat their osteoporosis? Even though I have a T score of -3.5 I’m not ready to jump into these heavy duty drugs for the rest of my life.
Just had my bone density done last month. I’m 77.

Jump to this post

@csuhilty
Susan where is you -3.5 femoral or spine?

REPLY
Profile picture for Susan @csuhilty

Has anyone tried using natural supplements to treat their osteoporosis? Even though I have a T score of -3.5 I’m not ready to jump into these heavy duty drugs for the rest of my life.
Just had my bone density done last month. I’m 77.

Jump to this post

@csuhilty Whatever supplement used, focused OP exercise can make a big difference…healthy diet, too…

REPLY
Profile picture for mcchesney @kathleen1314

@csuhilty
Susan where is you -3.5 femoral or spine?

Jump to this post

@kathleen1314

It’s my spine. I had a compression fracture of T12 vertebrae last April. Had a Kyphoplasty.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.