More on Supplements and “Natural”
As some of you know I am often on the soapbox about how there is no such thing as “natural”. And I rarely see anyone provide a clear answer on where they draw the line between what they consider “natural” “cures” and “unnatural”. Osteoporosis is a disease.
I’m also continually harping on the fact that supplements are to be viewed, not with just the same scrutiny as what some consider “medications”, but as potentially DAMAGING. Each of us have our own unique medical history and conditions. EVERYTHING you take should be discussed with both your medical team and your pharmacy.
Here’s just one tiny example of MANY medical articles on this issue.
https://www.health.com/can-you-take-too-many-supplements-11839485
In addition many “supplements”, like all medicine, can have contraindications with other medications or supplements you are taking.
I see people here hype collagen. Collagen as one small example should not be taken again without discussing with your medical team and pharmacist. It happens to be one MEDICINE, aka supplement, that can be contraindicated in some people with certain conditions. But this equally applies to all medicine you take.
Liver toxicity is increasing rapidly in the US due to overloading of unregulated “supplements”, again aka self medication. I see articles on this pop up every day. There’s nothing “natural” about that. HRT is a hormone, Vitamn D is a hormone chain, and guess what? The anabolic “medication” many people are terrified of are also hormones!
So, off the soapbox for awhile but had received another article on this today and felt the need to rant. I find I am frequenting this site less because of so much talk about “natural” that in medical terms (according to my team) makes no sense and I feel bad for people who come here and seem to be steered into what IMO is confusing information. Off box and rant now.
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.
Connect

Supplements are not particularly more "natural" than the substances we label "medication." Supplements are unnatural amounts of manufactured or extracted substances that are also found in nature or in food. Moreover, they are unregulated or less regulated and often contain substances that you don't expect or a different quantity of what you do expect given the labeling. If they do work, they only work as long as you take them--like our osteoporosis meds. Medication also is trying to help your body do what healthy human bodies do naturally.
That is to say, research, think, and asses no matter what the label and try to find doctors or other medical practitioners you trust to also research, think, and asses on your behalf.
My two cents. Sorry if I'm long-winded!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
3 Reactions@gravity3
After much research and interacting with others I decided to use Strontium Citrate. As well as started BHRT.
I know my DEXA would be skewed, but Im also getting a TBS score with my upcoming DEXA, which should be helpful.
Osteoporosis meds purpose is to prevent fractures, Strontium Citrate can do the same without some of those serious side effects the osteoporosis meds can have.
Here is a study on Strontium Citrate
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3265100/
My decison was also based on how to manage osteoporosis long term for my age. It did not seem feasible to use the osteoporosis meds for 20 plus years and not have side effects.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
3 Reactions@noc13
Not sure what you mean. Isn't the post about supplements vs meds?